So ... they are tied up with The Defiler.  What do they call The Defiler?  Do they worship it/s/he?  Given the power The Defiler uses over others, what do they gain by trafficing with and giving themselves over to this soul-consumer?  Are they dupes?

If you've not read The Screwtape Letters you might want to read the author's intro.  "no use for such turnip ghosts" is, as I recall it, the key phrase.  If you've read  That Hideous Strength, think of Frost and Wither and their obsession.  (Don't go out of your way now to read it.)

Blood and  Thunder ... Saundon's hot breath!  Does Ghen of the phosphorescent privates have priests?

2,803

(99 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Half-arsed?  Oh, that's a problem.

Hmm.  You use the term 'death magic' ... . Is your new term how the others describe them, or how they describe themselves?  If it's how others describe them, is the term in use from the beginning, or is it revealed as time goes on?  Do the priests of Behira know the real term?  That last question also applies if it's how they describe themselves.

Discovering the name could be a major plot point.

Since I don't know where the story is going, I have to offer avenues. These mages use other people, body and soul, as objects of their casting and as tools.  They rejoice in destruction, but it seems that there is a guiding drive behind them--which I assume will be a big plot point.  They do not obey the common laws that apply to mages, whether malum in se or malum prohibitum.  They obey their own drives and imperatives, some of them more freely than others.

Anver has had a quiet semi-apotheosis.  Kha has become a lynchpin in a battle that could destroy the gods.

And Geron ... when it was finally time for Geron to act, the crypt was already closed to the way up from the Three Hells.  All Geron did was to close the earthy gate--and the crypt remains in the hands of the Three Hells.  (I'm also assuming that it's important that there are three.)  What happens when the next Master--maybe even Geron himself--dies?

2,805

(520 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Local commercial for a web travel service:

Caller ... my boss sends me on a guilt trip!
Captain ObviousYou're lucky!  I've never been to Guilt.  But hey, a trip's a trip, right?

2,806

(520 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

And I thought that road train line was a good one, too.

2,807

(99 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Dill Carver wrote:

.... My wife once exclaimed (of the car) that 'if it were invented by a woman then it'd be a far better machine."

I remember we contemplated that for a while and then burst out laughing as we simultaneously realised that no woman has ever invented anything.

Not true.  The invention of the circular saw is attributed to a Shaker woman who was spinning and watching the wheel when she looked out at the men sawing wood.  I'm sure she wasn't the one to build it, though.

Stereotypes wouldn't exist if there were no basis for them--but sometimes the basis is no longer true, or never quite was, or is ironic falsehood.  And even the truest of stereotypes has exceptions.  I've met Wrench Wenches.  One of them was an automobile service manager.

2,808

(520 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Okay, you're going to come after me for sure after this review.

I think you've got enough material for the first scenes in the past.  It's long enough to be awkward as a flashback.  Unless there is strong reason to begin the telling in the present, after then past episodes, I'd start with the older part of the story.

Amy, up until  now we've had nothing about counting spells, or reducing questions of their strength to simply minor and major.  This is a change, a kind of rigidity that hasn't appeared until now, in Dictates.  Dictates is well away from the school, and thus seems a poor place to change the mage-rules.

2,811

(520 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Don't we al.

2,812

(520 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Yeah, but we've only seen part of it!

2,813

(212 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

In an inline review, the 'return to posting' link takes you to the first chapter of the work.  It might be helpful to return to the chapter of the review.

2,814

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Janet, if a side bit about some abusive soldiers will get you to read a chapter ... well, when Jose Luis Borges picked up The Napoleon of Notting Hill he said that the opening, less than a complete sentence, convinced him that the author was a master.  Anyone who could throw away a line like that must surely be sitting on a wealth of story.  The opening?  "The human race, to which so many of my readers belong ..."

Depends on how you define 'better' and 'worse', and how you rate the PhD.

The author of Dilbert wrote that he had so many real cases sent in by readers that he had more than a lifetime of material.  He also appeared on Babylon Five as a fellow consulting a private detective, worried that his cat and dog were out to get him.

Pointy-Haired Boss (Dilbert)

janet reid wrote:
njc wrote:

Don't get all meeting'd out by the PHBs.  It's what they do.

You had to go and mention meetings now, didn't you njc? ...  this week, it was meetings all day long, every day ...

It's what they do.

If Airen is convinced only by Ganolin to trust Kha, then when she goes off up the mountain with Kha, her memories might still give her misgivings.  We should see her holding something back in Tell Me True (great invention, BTW) and telling Ganolin what tomdo if Kha comes back and she doesn't.  Sil and the cleansing of Kha should mean more to her than is heretofore obvious.

And Kha's acts with the Black Staff and his training of an army may be what make him so dangerous to Behira ... and his cleansing and choice would reverse all that.  Zyrtec knows more than Big B.

2,819

(520 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

(Insert sound of mad laughter.)

2,820

(10 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

And some of us like to debate grammar, both in narrative and dialogue.

2,821

(342 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

njc wrote:
njc wrote:
njc wrote:

Sol, I ran a print copy of the inline review that Amy_s recently did of my Sorcerer's Progress Book 1, Chapter 5.  Starting on page four, a number of the comments were missing, even though the text was highlighted.

Fascinating ... it does not occur on the screen version, only when printed.  That's through IE.  The print preview from Chrome shows no such problem.  I'll run the print from Chrome, too.

The print preview on IE shows the problem.  The preview on Chrome does not.  I'll run the Chrome print and get you a screencap of the IE.

Postscript: The IE preview was actually the preview via the Epson driver.  When I take that same preview after the preview from within Chrome, the text shows up correctly.  I'm printing that copy now.

2,822

(342 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

njc wrote:
njc wrote:

Sol, I ran a print copy of the inline review that Amy_s recently did of my Sorcerer's Progress Book 1, Chapter 5.  Starting on page four, a number of the comments were missing, even though the text was highlighted.

Sol, I looked at this again, and I thin the problem may occur when there are unquoted double quotes in the review text.  I'll try to get some useful screencaps.  Is the snassi address still correct?

Fascinating ... it does not occur on the screen version, only when printed.  That's through IE.  The print preview from Chrome shows no such problem.  I'll run the print from Chrome, too.

2,823

(10 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

If you are debating about using or not using points, I suggest you use them.  It will require you to review the work of others, which well benefit both you and them, and it will make your work valuable to other point-users.

2,824

(342 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

njc wrote:

Sol, I ran a print copy of the inline review that Amy_s recently did of my Sorcerer's Progress Book 1, Chapter 5.  Starting on page four, a number of the comments were missing, even though the text was highlighted.

Sol, I looked at this again, and I thin the problem may occur when there are unquoted double quotes in the review text.  I'll try to get some useful screencaps.  Is the snassi address still correct?

Norm d'Plume wrote:

K is going to have to teach me how to spell all those ou words. Also, I'll need help with the pronounciation of z and about.

The key to it all is that 'receipt' is used in the old sense to mean 'recipe'.

'Victor Emmanuel, peak-haunting Peverill, Thomas Aquinas and Dr. Sacheverel."

This is the same Wm. Schwenk Gilbert who once rhymed with 'executioner' 'diminutioner', 'ablutioner', and 'you shun her'.