2,776

(99 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Dill Carver wrote:

A 1960’s racist differs from a 2015 or 1930’s racist?  Sexism has evolved into another type of sexism?  Sex offenders might approach the act of rape differently now that they have Rohypnol and handcuffs at their disposal, but the psyche of a rapist is now as it was in 200BC.

I'm not so sure about that.

There's a true story, a case out of the 1980's, when some hundreds or low thousands of Hmong people were quietly evacuated from Laos as refugees from the Communist takeover.  (The French called them Montiagnards, and I apologize for my poor spelling.)  They had many problems adjusting to American culture.  Some problems were mostly comic with a whiff of tragedy, like trying to grow rice in living room carpets.  Others were more severe.

One young man of the transplanted Hmong took a shine to an American girl and tried to get her interest.  She had no interest in him, so he did what he would have done back home in Laos: he got together with a bunch of his male friends and they kidnapped her.  They helped him rape her, in order to 'claim' her.

Not understanding their crime under Western culture and American law, they let everyone know what they did.  It was not difficult to convict them.

No rapist from within Western culture would advertise his act, or expect it to be approved by society.  He will know that his act is regarded as deeply wrong, even if he feels justified in it.

Social workers who were trying to help the Hmong assimilate approached the victim and she allowed them to explain things.  In what must surely represent a case for sainthood, she spoke at sentencing after the conviction and asked the judge to imposed a sentence recognizing  the moral and cultural ignorance, a sentence of mercy (which is often harder than simple leniency).

The Hmong culture fulfilled the first and indispensible requirement for a culture: it allowed the Hmong to survive through the centuries, as individuals and as a people.  And if we look carefully, we can find that things like the Stockholm Syndrome are likewise essential to survival of individuals and the human species when only that lowest of cultural requirements is filled.

I hope by this time you are screaming "WE KNOW BETTER!"  Yes, we do.  Not all cultures are equally good and moral, even though some 'lower' cultures may emphasize virtues that we have largely forgotten, or that we revile (the kind of courage necessary to challenge  and defeat a desperate food animal, for instance, or to defeat a neighboring clan's aggression).

Some cultures are better than others.  But all cultures face that indispensible first requirement of self-perpetuation.  A culture is not, and cannot be, a suicide pact.  The only cultures we know are the ones that survived long enough for us to see them, or to see their artifacts.

2,777

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Oh, please.  Only you consider superpowers inherently interesting.  B'sides, I'm giving away klooze

If Kha has been compromised, what about the earlier adventures, in which Kha's company averted disaster?

Oh, and if Kha finds he's been used, his wrath might bring down a god--or all of them.

Uh-huh.

Regarding the review: 'twas Lewellen, not Valharic, who spoke of breathing.

Working on the review.  Meanwhile, I'm wondering  ...

Kha has someone inside Behira's temple, feeding him information.  Could that leak also be leaking to the Enemy?  For that matter, might Kha himself have been open to the Enemy, at least until Sil shows up?  Or even after?

Is that why Zyrtec doesn't want Kha to see him when they are in Zyrtec's apartments?  Or is there another reason?

2,782

(520 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

See discussion here.

2,783

(99 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

You might also look up the story of 'Miss Tilly's orifice'.

Some writers use a lot of words, even though their pieces read very smoothly and swiftly.  Others write prose with few words that nonetheless seems very busy.

Word count is an imperfect measure, but it may be the best we have.  If your writing takes a lot of points to post, it should give your reviewers a relative lot of points, and so should be more attractive to them.

2,785

(520 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Or that they only want him because they can attract him, and can pull his strings.  Because they can pull his strings.  Because they can own him.  Maybe they're not actually like that ... but gee, it looked and felt like it.

2,786

(520 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

It could also be that a few 'suitable' women have been pushed at him and he's recoiled from their empty heads and hearts, and the experience has pushed him away from the whole business.  Catherine is not in their class, nor they in hers.  That could lead to him becoming more controlled.

Catherine's willingness to stand by her worthless brother might just make Matthew's fire burn all the hotter; this is virtue as he can appreciate it..

2,787

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

I need to spend a few hours in a hurry straightening mine.  There's a crew coming in on Friday morning to replace the bathroom floor with one that won't crack all over the place when a heavy person walks on it.  I'm lighter than I used to be, but the floor joists are only 2x6's.  A vitreous floor will crack.

Amy, I made a few edits to Books for Pengrit.  I didn't cover everything you wanted, and I probably won't.

2,788

(520 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Matthew may have been pre-occupied by taking over his position, especially if the circumstances of his father's death were drawn-out or troubling.  He might also have been tied up with fighting and family politics.

2,789

(520 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

janet reid wrote:

My first chapter can only be so long ... So would it be good to mention the raid sooner? I agree Amy. But is it really important (critically so) to know more now about the raid that killed C's father when the only reason behind it is to "show" Matthew's warrior skills? I don't think so, but I could be wrong ...

Don't stretch your first chapter.  Instead, use the current risk to Matthew to have him wonder (later in the story) about whether the two are related.  And you can put up a flashback for him to wonder about.

2,790

(520 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Janet, even when Matthew and Black J were playing, it would have been natural for Matthew to have taken the lead.  Later, when John was widowed, the natural tendency to turn to the 'technical' aspects of his work and away from the human parts would increase that effect.

2,791

(520 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Prime suspects are Catherine's step-relations.

2,792

(520 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Well, he showed up in the first chapter.  We just don't know who he is.

Just when it looks like Matthew and Catherine have either reached stasis or are an arm's length length from Real Progress, the villain must strike again.

2,793

(520 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

This is Romance.  The villians add danger as a complication.  They are serious potholes, but unlike Tom Clancy villians they must never completely drive the story.

Except in your stories, of course.

Or Insatiables?

2,795

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

This is the smallest of things on which to hang that question.
I'll give this more thought, but I have other things to do.  I've got a scene in my head that won't happen the way I'm seeing it, but I might put it up anyway.  I have some revision on Nikkano and Erevain.  And I have to get back to Nikkano today.

2,796

(520 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

And yet he played well with Matthew as a child.  Impatience could explain him not 'playing well' as an adult.  That, and not being able to live out adventures as he did when he was playing.

2,797

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Janet, I yield to your superiority in chemistry.

2,798

(520 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

See Matthew training and wiping the floor with people--and schooling them, so it's clear they are not toadying.  (Maybe he walks in, then interrupts where necessary.)  Then have Black John critique Matthew privately, leading to a training session where Black John schools Matthew--soundly.  And the discussion turns to strategy, politics, and the human element, and it's clear that Black John is the eternal student who nonetheless asks hard questions.

(Maybe Black John lacks the patience to instruct the lesser students?  Or presses them to learn faster than they can?  He asks others to do things when he wants to husband his patience?)

For 'chosen': elect, select

For 'reaper' you might consider 'soldier'.  It focusses on position and organization function rather than mission function.

For the bottom level: brutes, swine, appetites, insatiates, ... I'm not really satisfied by any of these.

KH's words are address.  Amy's are titles.  Not sure these guys would call each other 'brother'; they are just too cut-throat.  'Master' addressing upwards sounds right insofar as they are apprentices.