Rachel:

I'm glad my comments were useful. Sword and sorcery is not my first choice of reading and I haven't read so much of it (I recently read Fritz Leiber's Swords and Deviltry and Swords Against Death because of you, but that doesn't make me an expert on the genre), so, sometimes, I'm afraid I might be advising against the genre standards and cannon.

By the way, Ioseff has a strong point when he asks his wife to be accepted within the privy council: he claims she's the leader of the Witches' Guild, or some confederacy of the sort. So, rather than suggesting her wife's name only because she's somebody who can be trusted, he suggests her because she can be a powerful ally, AND somebody trusted. My point is, I fancy trust cannot be the sole decision-making criteria. I read between your comments' lines that it's important Rosalyn is appointed. My guess is she will contrast Heather who, in the end, will show is not trustworthy as it is evident she has her own agenda.

I also fancy that the peeing thing is because Zusana is marking her territory as wolves, dogs, cats, and other mammalians do. However, the images results too gross. Either you explain she's marking her territory (if that's actually the case) or else the image loses all its punch.  Again, those into the genre may be familiar with the fact, in which case there'd be no need to clarify anything assuming 95% of the readers will get the idea--no clarifications are requiered for the 5% left. That said, and even if the fact is well known to the readers familiar to the genre, I'd recommend Zusana to perform some other  "gesture". Moreover in conjunction with her afterwards comments about visiting the loo to defecate. The combination of both is either totally goofy--belittling Zusana's character--or absolutely gross belittling Rhiannon's character and even the council itself.

Okay, the thoughts of somebody who has read little within the genre, so I might be absolutely wrong. Like tequila, drink my comments with a grain of salt.

Kiss,

Gacela

277

(25 replies, posted in Close friends)

Suin:

I saw you're publishing a second part of Being Fifteen. Wouldn't it be better to consider it a second book and publish it under a different title even if it's a continuation of the same story? You know, like these trilogies so common in YA. It's three books, each one finishing a story arc, even if the story continues.

Just a thought.

Kiss

Gacela

278

(7 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Basic)

I also suggest you publish in the Premium group using points, otherwise there might be less interest in reviewing your work. I see you're into YA. You can check T. W. Cave, Suin, and my own work. We all write YA.

Kiss

Gacela

279

(13 replies, posted in Close friends)

I wish I could take that kind of breaks, forgetting about work, phones, and family.

Kiss,

Gacela

280

(13 replies, posted in Close friends)

Glad you're back, Suin. Just the other day I was about to send you another note asking when were you planning to publish another chapter, because I was missing you.

100% off line? Where did you go? To a convent? 

Kiss,

Gacela

Rachel:

Sometimes I'm afraid I'm being harsh with my observations. If so, please accept my apologies. I never intend to be so. I just raise my hand trying to cooperate.

Kiss,

Gacela

282

(9 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Congratulations! Great job!

Kiss,

Gacela

283

(19 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

I had all of them correct except number 3. It might have been because of the missing comma, it confused me.  wink

Kiss,

Gacela

Where can this short story be read?

Kiss,

Gacela.

285

(63 replies, posted in Close friends)

Dear CJ:

I told you, you're a wonderful editor, or however you call the person who checks a manuscript and discusses it with the author pointing at weaknesses. Thanks a lot your willingness to discuss my story. I'm really, really grateful!!!

Lemme elaborate a bit further: I switched chapters 1 and 2. Because of this, the reader will have no clue what's going on with the red man until the reader reads chapter 2. That's okay. The confusion will last only one chapter, two the most (until the reader reads chapter 3). So, no biggie here. What I've just realised is that I need to put a stronger accent on the fact Athens and Helga are connected. They're both on high towers (Helga on one built by Mephisto and Athens on one built by men. Okay, okay, a ten storey building is not exactly a tower, it's not the Empire State Building, but for Athens is high enough) and they connect for a second. You're right, when Athens sees him, Mephisto should be flickering or something. He mustn't be completely solid so the reader is hinted there's something amiss.

Indeed, he cried "bitch", but again, he wasn't addressing Athens. He was addressing Helga. This is not clear nin chapter 1 and the reader will assume he addressed Athens. In the next chapter, readers should be able to grasp what really happened. Well... not the way it is written now. It's sorta vague, so I'll rewrite the last scenes of both chapters 1 and 2 to make it absolutely clear.

You've just been amazingly helpful!

Kiss,

Gacela

A.T.Schlesinger wrote:
njc wrote:

Hmmm.  What happens if you drop all the proper nouns NOT linked to your protag?

Well, I tweeked it a bit--eliminated a few of the dreaded proper nouns.  Still a bit heavy on the adjectives, but within tolerable limits:

Demos Azari, an advisor to a militant order of crusading knights, has captured an ancient evil within an enchanted box. By extorting the fiend’s vast knowledge, Demos longs to release mankind from their obsession with absent gods. The immortal he imprisoned, however, has an agenda of its own and schemes to unleash a legion of brutes eager to rain devastation on the world. Hope resides in Aaron, a magician who searches for a way to prevent this evil from carrying out its sinister plans.

Caught between these men is Shadyia, a passionate and daring courtesan of the Silver Rose palace. Concealing both a forbidden romance with a fellow sister and a vengeful past, Shadyia must choose which man to favor. Her madam demands she appease Demos to keep their sorority safe from the wrath of his order, but Shadyia’s integrity requires she aid Aaron. Will she follow him beneath the Silver Rose and face the shadows of death, or betray him to preserve the sisterhood she cherishes above all?

A coupla comments:

1. This is way, way better than your previous attempts. Now it's more clear what the story is about. Now it kindles interest.
2. It's still unclear why Shadyia must chose which man to favour, and why she's caught between them.
3. The romance with a fellow sister doesn't seems relevant.
4. It seems the MC are the two magicians.
5. I would not end with a teaser. I will explain what will happen. If I were an agent, I wouldn't want a teaser, to to be able to judge if the story is worth my time. Something like: "Shadyia will start a journey where she'll face the shadows of death while struggling to ultimately remain loyal to the sisterhood she cherishes above all".

Kiss,

Gacela

A.T.Schlesinger wrote:

After some feedback from my editor, father and the folks here, I have rewritten the blurb. I would be curious if this hits the spot:

The great city of Anderholm dangles at the edge of ruin. Demos Azari has bound a devious evil inside an enchanted box. As a fanatical advisor to the Innocenti, Demos longs to release mankind from its obsession with absent gods, but the imprisoned fiend has its own agenda and the slaughter of humanity is but the least of its goals. Hope resides in Aaron, a magician who searches for an enchanted ruby which holds the knowledge to prevent this evil from escaping the box. Between these men stands Shadyia, a passionate and daring courtesan of the Silver Rose. Concealing both a forbidden romance with a fellow sister and a vengeful past, she must choose which man to favor. Her madam demands Shadyia please Demos to keep the sisterhood safe from the wrath of his order, but Shadyia’s integrity requires she aid Aaron. Will she follow him beneath the Silver Rose and face the shadows of death, or betray him to preserve the sisterhood she cherishes above all?

Dear:

I'm not a query expert and I have never written a query in my life, but I'd like to provide my two cents. I've read a good deal of the posts in the Query Shark. Using the little I've learnt reading them, here is my advise:

1. Start focusing on the MC. I'm assuming it's Shadya, so focus on her and start the query stating who is her. Rather, you started with scenery ("The great city of Anderholm dangles at the edge of ruin"). Is the fact the city is in ruins important for the story? It doesn't seem so because you don't touch the fact again. Hence, forget about the city.

What makes Shadya a compelling MC? Why should I care about her? Your first lines must indicate the agent why any reader would be interested in her story, because that's what will drive the book's commercial success, which is exactly what interests the agent and ultimately the publisher.

2. What triggers the story? I.e., what is the event that puts everything into motion? Otherwise, Shadya would have been an expensive, classy prostitute for the rest of her life and nobody would have written the story of her life because it'd have been dull. You mentioned a magician and a zealot.  How did they enter her life? What exactly happened that she has to chose one of them?

By the way, you have to explain what is the Silver Rose. If it's a prostitution union, then explain it in plain English. If not, rather than rising my interest, it increases my confusion.

3. Introduce the background, the scenery, etc. only after it is cllear what is the story about and why it's interesting. The best world building shall not suffice if the plot is poor.

4. Do not post open questions (like "Will Shadya fulfill her mission and save the world?"). I don't think an agent would enjoy them. He/she wants to learn, at a glance, whether your story is worth reading. Close your query with something like: "Shadya will start a journey of (whatever) where she will decide (whatever) and will learn (whatever) etc. You may splash it with "risking her life" and/or "risking the life of those she loves" etc to indicate the risk, and some more background and scenery, but at very little doses.

Please check the closing lines of a query praised by the Query Shark. I also think it's the right way to summarise the rest of the plot without going into all the details and actually teasing the agent to ask for the whole manuscript:

"She risks reconnecting with the outlaw underground to prove it, and learns the hard way that she's not nearly as tough -- or as right -- as she thinks she is."

I'd suggest you to rewrite your second attempt. Considering how tough agents are, I don't think it may interest an one of them or stand out amid the many queries agents receive every day.

Kiss,

Gacela

288

(63 replies, posted in Close friends)

Dear CJ:

I think it’s a great idea that I don’t mention the reason why Athens is up there to kill herself. Indeed, as I said, it doesn’t matter. The important thing is that she’s up there at the right time and place—I can hint the reason afterwards if it’s needed. In that way the reader will concentrate in the fact and the action, making this first chapter more compelling to read.

However… If the people think the character had been bullied, it might create more sympathy towards her, don’t you think so?
I’d be thrilled to change to change the time to midnight but then I’d need to figure out what the hell was Patrick doing at a construction site that late. Lemme thing of it, I just fell in love with your idea.

By the way, she never changed her mind. She was gonna jump but then the strange, red, naked man appeared behind him shouting “Bitch!” and that called her attention. He wasn’t shouting at her but at Helga, but the border between the spiritual and the material world became so think she could see him.

Kiss,
Gacela

289

(8 replies, posted in Close friends)

Why do I write? That’s quite a question.

The short answer, the one first coming to my mind is: “because I have a story (stories) to tell”. From that point onwards I can elaborate explaining how I create stories in my mind when I drive home from work every day. It’s as simple as seeing a man waiting at a bus stop, carrying a large conspicuous bag for me to start imagining he’s transporting incognito a device core to a time-travelling machine. And so on, and so on.

The long answer—and this might be the reason why Paty, AKA Flowing Pencil, says she feels my writing too intense—is that I have MY own story to tell.

The MC’s story in Amber Eyes is certainly not mine—I’ve not even been in a trailer park in my whole life, even though I’m a girl scout and have gone camping a gazillion times. That said, I did experience some of the MC’s angst when I was a young teen.

Helga’s story is not mine either—even if we share the same first name. Well a coupla events in Helga’s life did happen to me, but names were change to protect identities, LOL!

What I mean is that I wanted to reflect what I felt when some of the things that happened to the characters actually happened to me. In that way, it’s not that I write because I have stories to tell, but because I have my own story to tell.


Kiss,
Gacela

Ronald:

That's an amazing analysis! You've just taught a very useful lesson to anybody reading your post, not only to A.T.Schlesinger.

"Agents are on the lookout for something fresh and new."

I wonder if there is really something "fresh and new" in the world. Even bestsellers like Harry Potter and Twilight aren't exactly new stuff. One of Harry Potter rejections stated that so much fiction has been written around witches and wizards that JK Rowling's story lacked of originality. Moreover, by the time JK Rowling sent her first query letters, this ITV (and afterwards Disney Channel) TV series "The Worst Witch" was airing. It's exactly about the misadventures of a student at a witchcraft academy much like Howards. So, an agent rejected JK Rowling story claiming it was just a copy of ITV's idea.

Twilight is yet another vampire story mixed with a lady-in-distress plot. How many stories about both topics have been written? Hundreds. Millions. Ad nauseam.  However, both HP and TW turned into bestsellers, despite their pointed-out lack of originality.

My question is: what makes a story attractive to an agent, and ultimately to the public, in a world where it seems everything has been written? If I'm writing a query letter, which are the points I should highlight that make a difference? What should I search for in my story that opens the gates?

Kiss,

Gacela

291

(186 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Charles_F_Bell wrote:
Mariana Reuter wrote:
Charles_F_Bell wrote:

(2) just because British English evolved in some ways away from English spoken in the rest of the world does not make it the correct English;

I just wanna tell you people I sooo very impressed.

This discussion about “sneaked vs. snuck” leaded (should I use “led” instead?) by this awesome bloke with such a very, regular American name (you guessed it right! It’s Charles F. Bell!) has been sooo totally constructive. I’ve just learnt a bunch of stuff—Gosh! I need to stop using this Brit. grammar that has evolved away from the English written elsewhere in the world. LOL! It’s like I’m writing another language.

With sincere appreciation,

Helga Marianne Reuter

That's quite lovely.  Have you considered entering a Trump beauty contest?

Not yet, but if you share your experience when you participated in one, I might consider it.

Kiss,
Gacela
(The nick is not either a regular American one. It's not even English. Just for the record)

292

(186 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Charles_F_Bell wrote:

(2) just because British English evolved in some ways away from English spoken in the rest of the world does not make it the correct English;

I just wanna tell you people I sooo very impressed.

This discussion about “sneaked vs. snuck” leaded (should I use “led” instead?) by this awesome bloke with such a very, regular American name (you guessed it right! It’s Charles F. Bell!) has been sooo totally constructive. I’ve just learnt a bunch of stuff—Gosh! I need to stop using this Brit. grammar that has evolved away from the English written elsewhere in the world. LOL! It’s like I’m writing another language.

With sincere appreciation,

Helga Marianne Reuter

PS. Just in case there’s a bloke here who hasn’t bothered himself reading my bio and thus thinks my name’s American, allow me to clarify it’s not—just in case somebody might Donald-Trump a stupid comment about my name not being “a regular American name”.

293

(31 replies, posted in Close friends)

Suin:

It's not that I want to be pushy, but... are you planning to publish the next chapter soon? Your story is totally interesting; I'm on tenterhooks!

Kiss,

Gacela

PS: the above semicolon is my humble homage to Rhiannon, who has mastered the art of using them.

294

(33 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

rhiannon wrote:
Mariana Reuter wrote:

A horror short story? The title of the conteste might be: A Horror Short Story Contest: Make Us Pee in Our Pants.

Kiss,

Gacela

Heh.  I once submitted a short story to an online horror e-magazine (Yes, I know online e-magazine is redundant.  It's a holiiday in America so, tongue)  Their stated criteria?  "Make us think that this had to be written by a psychopathic serial killer who would kill us if we didn't print it."  I didn't get published.  Oh, well.


But you slaughtered the full editorial team afterwards, didn't you?

Kiss,

Gacela

295

(186 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

If you meant my name, Mr Charles F. Bell, I'm not American.

Kiss

Gacela

296

(186 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

I can't believe that somebody wants to turn a regular verb in an irregular verb. Regular verbs are easy to learn and remember. Irregular verbs are the opposite. Why complicate life ourselves?

Would you like to have different conjugations for each person like in French or Spanish? I bet you wouldn't!

English                             Spanish                                 French
I walk                               Yo camino                             Je marche
You walk                           Tu caminas                           Tu marches
He/She/It walks                 El/Ella camina                       Il/Elle marche
We walk                            Nosotros caminamos              Nous marchons
You walk                           Vosotros camináis                  Vous marchez
They walk                         Ellos caminan                         Ils marchent

Why complicate things for free???


Kiss,

Gacela.

297

(33 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

A horror short story? The title of the conteste might be: A Horror Short Story Contest: Make Us Pee in Our Pants.

Kiss,

Gacela

298

(33 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

How about giving the authors an idea around which everybody must elaborate? The idea doesn't need to be literately quoted, even though authors are free to do so. However, the idea must be present in the story. For example:

"When John arrived at his house, the fact all lights were on called his attention. It was quite late for everybody to be up. Besides, why were the lights downstairs on as well? And even the backyard? Was his wife throwing a party?"

And that should be it. The idea doesn't need to be the start of the story, it can be the middle, or even the end. The character's name doesn't need to be John, and the authors can turn him into a woman if they prefer to do so. But the underlying idea, the fact that somebody arrived home late at night and found an unexpected situation there--one of which signs was all the lights turned on--must be part of the story.

It'd be interesting to see how creative the participants are, moving away from cliches and from the obvious.

Kiss,

Gacela.

PS. Please don't do the erotica idea. It's a very particular genre not all of us cultivate.

Karin:

If you receive any advice from ceridwen about Black Rose, would you be so kind to share it with us? It's not that any of us have already been contacted by Wild Rose publishers, but I've heard so much about publishers scamming writers, that it's important for all of us to be aware.

Kiss,

Gacela

300

(31 replies, posted in Close friends)

Oh, Suin! You made me laugh.

Read the books, I mean GOT. They're far superior than the TV show. Just like Harry Potter books are way better than the movies.

Kiss,

Gacela