vern wrote:Okay, I'm going to get a little nit-picking here as far as the subject of moving the story forward is concerned -- any good thread always seems to veer from the path somewhat. That being said, if we're going to move forward, it just as well be logical. My concern is the use of "he paused" as a speaker tag as presented above. I bring this up only because it has been used in more than one post. It seems to me rather impossible to speak a pause. You can certainly have a pause after speaking, but you can't speak that pause; therefore it is not an effective speaker tag imho. Thus a period rather than a comma would seem more appropriate in the sentence "'I have terrible news,' he paused." ("... news." He paused.) Just a thought. Take care. Vern
Vern,
No. The "he paused" is not a tag as we use them in dialogue. Let's try "froze" instead because it's getting confused as a dialogue tag. Consider this example.
John walked into the room. He froze.
As a reader, I am wondering why. What's in the room? What does he see? What made him stop?
And I'm not going to give the answer in the next sentence. I may describe some sweet foul odor and an unidentifiable figure bundled in the recliner first. Then I'll reveal to my reader that there's a dead body in the room and it's John's father.
Sherry
You are correct in that the example you use here is not a speaker tag because there is no dialogue as written. If, however you wrote it as "he paused" was used in the opening of this thread i.e. "'I have terrible news,' he paused" then it would be a speaker tag because "I have terrible news" is written as dialogue. By the same token if you had written, "'I have terrible news.' He paused." then that would not be a speaker tag and this discussion would never have happened. As I've stated, you are of course free to write it any way you wish, but the way the original is written is a speaker tag which makes using "paused" illogical. Still, it is your call to do whatever you wish with your writing. I'm merely pointing out the problem with the way "paused" is used as a speaker tag. The ultimate choice is up to you and any future editor, etc. you may wish to work with. As stated previously, best selling authors may get away with ignoring a lot of technical grammar stuff, but even James Patterson, who was given as an example of one to break the rules, uses the speaker tag correctly in every instance I've seen. Take care. Vern