Here's a 500-word review of the prologue to "The Rise of Connor". Note it misinterpreted the "location" at the top of the prologue as the title.


"The Holy Land — Israel" is a gripping and action-packed short story that masterfully blends the sacred tranquility of its setting with the visceral horror of a demonic assault. The narrative functions as a high-stakes chapter in a larger supernatural saga, dropping the reader directly into a world where faith is not just a belief system, but a tangible weapon against the forces of Hell. The story's greatest strength lies in its potent sense of place and its well-paced escalation of tension.
The author opens with a beautifully rendered depiction of the Sea of Galilee, appealing to multiple senses to create a landscape that is both historically resonant and spiritually charged. The "soothing scents of water, fish, and flora" and the view of a land that was a "silent witness" to the life of Christ establish a serene atmosphere. This initial calm makes the subsequent intrusion of evil all the more jarring. The sudden stillness of nature followed by the "buzzing like a bandsaw" of the demonic locust swarm is a classic and effective horror trope that shifts the tone from contemplative to terrifying in an instant.
At the heart of the story is the protagonist, Connor, a compelling figure who embodies the classic archetype of the young, burdened hero. At only fourteen, he wields immense power but is also tainted by a demonic poison from the "Antichrist's dagger." This internal conflict is the story's thematic core: the struggle between divine power and demonic temptation. His use of the holy cross to erect a protective shield is a powerful visual, but the moment he is forced to draw the dagger, "fighting hellfire with hellfire," introduces a fascinating and dangerous moral ambiguity. His shifting eye color, from a divine blue to a demonic red, serves as a simple yet effective visual cue for his internal battle.
The supporting cast, including the devout Father Romano and the sardonic ghost Antonio Benevi, provide a solid framework around Connor, representing faith and skepticism, respectively. The action is relentless and well-choreographed. The locusts are not mere insects but terrifying entities described as "horse-drawn chariots rushing into battle," and their ability to shatter bullet-resistant glass establishes them as a formidable, supernatural threat that conventional defenses cannot stop.
The story's resolution, with the flock of pratincoles descending as a form of divine intervention, functions as a satisfying, if somewhat convenient, deus ex machina. However, it is cleverly foreshadowed by the bird's initial appearance and Father Bianchi's explanation of its "locust bird" nickname. This conclusion reinforces the central theme that while human and even supernatural efforts may falter, ultimate salvation comes from a higher power. As a standalone piece, "The Holy Land — Israel" feels like a thrilling excerpt, successfully building a world rich with lore and leaving the reader eager to discover the next chapter in Connor's perilous journey.


Makes your want to rush right out and see the movie, doesn't it? :-)

They're pretty easy to spot. Very formal, organized into sections, tries to interpret what it read or simply parrots bits of it back, often refers to the "reader" instead of himself or herself (e.g., the reader is transported...), reads like an online book review from a literary critic, always a regular review, never an inline. Unlike anything you get from human reviewers here.

53

(9 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Your browser will eventually catch up with your chosen image/avatar, both in the forums and elsewhere. Not sure how nor when, but it will refresh everything. CTRL-F5 helps, but if that isn't sufficient, see if your browser has the ability to delete all of your cached images.

Looks like someone else used AI to generate a review. I'm guessing they didn't see this thread.

My suggestion for anyone who receives an AI-generated review, especially one that the reviewer doesn't even admit came from an AI, is:
- let them know that the site policy (as articulated by Sol earlier in this thread) is no AI-generated reviews
- let them know that you (the author) are looking for thoughtful, constructive feedback from humans who have actually read your work
- remind them that the AI almost certainly keeps a copy of the work the reviewer submitted to the AI, and if that copy of your work gets integrated into the AI going forward, then the reviewer has violated the author's copyright

- most important, tell them you don't reciprocate in response to AI reviews

55

(21 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

J.R. Geiger wrote:

Do I really need an agent then? A proofreader/editor? Those things are expensive.

Keep in mind that, although an agent or publisher may become interested in your book for publication, some of them may ask you to shorten your book, maybe substantially so. Unless they see the value of your epic in its current form, they may not want to take on the extra risk associated with publishing a book that long from a first-time author. Have a look online for how long the average story is in your genre.

J.K Rowling had a lot of trouble getting her first Harry Potter book published, in part because many publishers felt a 90,000-word children's book wouldn't sell well. Needless to say, she didn't have much trouble getting later books published at whatever length she needed to tell the story. Her longest in the series ended up at 260,000 words. It set a new record for first-day sales, selling an estimated 5 million copies in the United States alone within the first 24 hours.

Dune is 190,000 words and was rejected by two dozen publishers until it was finally published by Chilton Books, primarily known for car repair manuals. It was published at a time when the average sci-fi was just 60,000 - 80,000 words.

I've been working on Archangel (my epic "demented" space opera) for years. It grew so long that I felt certain I would have too much trouble getting it published as a single book, so I first tried to rip out a lot of content. I quickly realized, though, that it would have decimated the story. So, I decided to split it into four meaty novellas and eventually self-publish. Funny thing was, that gave me the freedom to further flesh out some of the lighter chapters that I'm keeping.

If you go the route of publishing professionally, the publisher will pay for the editing. You can try using an AI to suggest edits ahead of time; the cleaner the book, the more likely it is to get picked up.

I finally have a few answers about Gandalf. He still has penile barbs, which means he still has some amount of testosterone circulating in his system. For now, they're monitoring the barbs (I see the shelter's vet every 2 weeks). Although his ear has a tiny notch from a previous vet, suggesting he's been neutered, the barbs prevent the current vet from clearing him medically for adoption because they have no history about Gandalf prior to his capture (the vet is waiting for the barbs to shrink). I don't recall if I mentioned it, but the reason they're having trouble with this is that neither of Gandalf's testicles ever descended from his abdomen, so you can't tell from just looking. And counting. :-)

That probably explains the nighttime caterwauling. And I changed how I "scratch" his head and cheeks, which is to offer my knuckles rather than my fingernails, and I just wait for him to rub against the knuckles, which he does, especially after I've washed my hands, which I do a lot. The handwashing could explain why he keeps doing it. I'm pretty sure at this point that he's not itchy but is simply marking me as one of Tolkien's 13 dwarves. He no longer rubs his cheeks/head against furniture either, which is probably because he already has his scent everywhere. tongue And he doesn't scratch his cheeks with his back paws even though I know he can. He still bites a little but never hard, gets startled easily and is cranky about it, is still somewhat restless, and isn't eating much, ignoring several varieties of Sheba wet food, which is the one the shelter wants me to use for now. Normally, he jumps at the food.

I can get him to eat soft Churu treats, which I know he loves, but he's hesitant about accepting it unless I show him the tiny pouch it comes in, let him taste it, and then squeeze it into a bowl. I'm wondering if I served him a bad can of salmon at some point, which might explain why he won't eat much Sheba at present (it's mostly salmon mixed with other animal protein). I ordered their all-chicken and all-beef varieties this morning to see if he'll eat either of those. For what it's worth, he has yet to upchuck a hairball (3 weeks so far).

I just sprinkled a little catnip on top of his wet food, and now he's eating all of it. Yay! Progress.

Tamsin Liddell wrote:

I know this isn't fantasy, but I think I just found a new toy.

Piscau cover

We have no hard rules about following the genres in this forum. At one time, it was just medieval fantasy/magic, but the forum, having been one of the few that was thriving, attracted a rather eclectic group, including writers of sci-fi, steampunk, and romance. Since many of those folks helped me by reviewing and brainstorming for my demented space opera (Archangel), quite a few ended up as characters in the novel.

Thank you, Tamsin. The image for your book looks fantastic. Connor on the lower left is close to one I posted here the other day.
https://i.postimg.cc/mPBdBbcs/1758443730385.png

I'm definitely going to shift my image generation off Gemini for now. Fairly buggy and way too restrictive.

I use red as well, but that represents pure evil (eg the demonic "corporeals"). I hashed this out with Gemini a few hours ago:

Once Connor's been stabbed by a supposedly demonic dagger, his eyes begin to turn increasingly intense shades of yellow, accompanied by ever-increasing burning pain in his irises, bleeding from his eyes, and he's incrementally losing his sight. That'll require changes to the prologue, but it's a more complete consequence of him trying to use his powers for good: the poison surges back, resulting in the aforementioned consequences. It isn't until he "loses" his battle against the poison that his eyes go red, his sight is restored, the burning and bleeding cease, but he is now lost to evil.

The other alternative I'm considering is to use black as the color of evil. It's less derivative. So, when a corporeal attacks, its eyeballs would go completely black. In Connor's case, his attempts to use his powers for good still nets a glowing blue color for the irises. In extreme cases, like when he fights the locusts, the glowing blue extends to the entire eyeball.

Once he's done using his powers, the poison's effects surge back, enlarging his pupils, and causing the other effects noted above. As the poison gains more and more control over him, his pupils will continue to enlarge, pushing the irises back until the entire whites of his eyes are black too, like the corporeals. Anatomically possible? Of course not, but I had Gemini do a few images of a young adult male with black irises vs black eyeballs. The later was definitely more scary looking.

Funny thing, though. Gemini choked as I got too specific with the details because it was bumping into its safety rules that disallow it from creating anything potentially offensive (eg scary depictions of teenagers). That led me into a  lengthy discussion about the stupidity of its current rules. It admitted for example that it could not even produce a picture of a kid with severe acne for a medical paper or news article, although I don't know if the same applies to a chat session that didn't include my earlier requests to create hideous corporeals vs an angelic-looking teenager with black eyeballs. tongue

i actually got the idea from my cat. When he gets the zoomies, he typically spends a lot of time running around in my basement, where I don't normally have lights on. When he gets back upstairs, he looks downright demonic because his black pupils have grown so big in the dark.

I'll have to include an acknowledgment to Gandalf the Beige for the inspiration.

Three plush cat beds spread over two floors, and this is what he likes best:

https://i.postimg.cc/XrgPkFSt/Nap-Time.jpg

I could have gotten three of those for the price of one cat bed. tongue

J.R. Geiger wrote:
Tamsin Liddell wrote:
J.R. Geiger wrote:

How about Spot?

This is actually a very very traditional name for a pet.
The Greek translation for Spotted One: Cerberus

Cerberus means spotted one? Holy spots, Batman!

I'm going to have to Google pictures of Cerberus to see if there are any depictions of him with spots.

If not, you can always ask Gemini to create a spotted Cerberus. :-)

Transferred from Premium thread:

George FLC wrote:

The halo glow on the first image is better. I don't know if it's the eyes, but the second image is more zombie-ish.

It just occurred to me that once Connor is in the Holy Land, not only his eyes can glow, but the halo can appear when he uses his powers too. It can start out as something faint and eventually grow to look like the one in my first image. However, he's also supposed to have a demonic poison flowing through his veins, so he can't look too powerful, at least not at the beginning. I'm also wondering if his irises should turn to yellow as the poison slowly takes over his body. But then I'll be bouncing between blue and yellow, which is rather weird.

Zombie-ish is good. Connor is supposed to be, increasingly, in "harmonious communion" with Christ throughout the first book, so when Connor uses his powers, he is in those moments, a conduit for God.

It may not be your account, but the simple test cases I suggested earlier will help narrow down what account bug or feature bug may be doing this. As I noted above, I was unable to reproduce it using my account to review J.R.'s short stories.

If your reviews saved properly, there's a possibility that they're still in the database.

I tried out the latest version of Gemini's image generation, which now includes iterative editing. Although it's still a lot of work to get exactly the right image, the enhanced functionality is amazing. It had a difficult time correctly editing my previous AI image of Connor (the first one, below), so I created the one below that from scratch, which I thought came out perfectly except the cross is too thin and bland. Gemini gave up trying to improve it, but it said if I keep the chat session used to generate the new one, it may be able to make the changes after more functionality is released.

Freelance cover artists may go the way of the dodo in the not too distant future.

Click the images to enlarge them.


Original Version:
https://i.postimg.cc/vgkqsfnq/Connor-21.jpg

I lucked out that it created the original as well as it did many months ago since editing existing images didn't work at the time. I had to tweak the prompts for this and kept rerunning image generation until it surprised me with that one.


New Version:
https://i.postimg.cc/mPBdBbcs/1758443730385.png

I think the halo on the original is better, but the eyes on this one are exactly what I had in mind. Naturally he doesn't look like that all the time. His eyes glow like that mainly when he uses his powers such as in the prologue when he fights the demonic locusts.

I can't reproduce it. I had no trouble leaving a regular review against The Goat, and I started writing another regular review for Hair Club but abandoned it before submitting to see if it would show in my "saved" reviews that hadn't been submitted, but as expected, that only works for inlines.

As a test, please try to leave another regular review for J.R. on The Goat and on one other of his short stories that you haven't yet tried to review. Just throw some random gibberish into the text fields, so there's something to save. Please make a note of the results and then try leaving a test inline review against those same two stories (you'll need to leave at least five comments and closing comments to be able to submit those).

I assume there's no question you scrolled down and hit the button to publish the regular reviews that went missing? If in doubt, blame the user. :-)

If something doesn't work right, please try to do the same tests (regular review and an inline review) against one of my short stories. That's to determine if the issue is with J.R.'s account or yours.

Please post the results of your tests here.

Thanks
Dirk

Mitch, check your billing info (click the "whatta" menu on the upper right of your screen, then Billing). See if the renewal took place. The most likely reason is that it didn't auto-renew. In fact, I just had to enable auto-renew in my account. I thought it was, but I can't be sure anymore.

68

(21 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Bill, does KSP allow you to sell through other booksellers like B&N at the same time? Or are you locked into KSP? If so, for how long?

Thanks
Dirk

69

(3 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Do they have a restriction on how many agencies you can approach simultaneously? Naturally, there are countless agencies and publishers. One way to gauge them is online reviews, although I assume you've done that.

Good luck.
Dirk

I settled on Gandalf the Beige, although he still moves around like a ghost, hence Phantom was a possibility, and he still likes to nibble on me, hence Jaws was a contender.

Welcome to the site. If you have any questions about the site, feel free to post them here or send me a connection request (I do volunteer user support here). Also, if you haven't already come across it, there's an article pinned near the top of this forum with tips on how to maximize the number of reviews you can get here. Hope it helps!

Dirk

FYI, this newest member is impersonating the real Suzanne Redfearn (including the fake picture), a very successful author. I've asked her to remove the impersonating info, otherwise we'll close the account. Oddly enough, we just had another imposter try the same thing a few days ago with another well-known author whose books are being adapted for Netflix. I suspect it's the same person. If the imposter put as much effort into writing as they do impersonating others, they might one day produce something worth reading.

Gandalf playing gently with his toys:
https://photos.app.goo.gl/QzTrgvgZqehazCuZ9

That nasty brown thing your see in parts of these videos is a toy mouse that just refuses to die (it vibrates) despite Gandalf's best efforts.

The game he's trying to destroy normally comes with three balls inside about the size of ping pong balls. He conquered that game in a matter of minutes when I first gave it to him. He knows exactly how to get them out, so I made it a little more challenging by putting an electronic spinning ball inside that's bigger than the holes to get it out.

That's a little mean but it's meant to help him work off excess energy to reduce the frequency and intensity of his almost-nightly zoomies. I eventually pop the ball out for him and let him smack it around the house. A+ for effort.

If you think those are wild, you should see him go after a laser pointer dot on the floor. I haven't filmed it yet because each time I play that with him I can't stop laughing.

It should fall under unpublished since this is a private site behind a paywall. As long as you don't post your writing here with visibility set for the internet (i.e., widest exposure), you should have no trouble. If you want to go the extra step of only posting it to a private group to limit the number of members who can see it, that's even more secure as long as you again exclude internet when posting it.


From Gemini:

In most cases, yes, publishers will still consider a work that has been posted to a private, paywalled workshop site to be unpublished.

The key distinction for publishers is not whether a handful of people have seen it, but whether the work has been made widely available to the general public and thus lost its "first rights" value.

Here is a breakdown of why a private workshop site is generally not an issue:

Limited Audience: A private site with a membership or paywall is not considered a public venue. The audience is small, and the work is not discoverable by search engines like Google. A publisher is primarily concerned with the work having been put into the public domain where it can be widely read, which would hurt its marketability.

Purpose for Feedback: Publishers understand that writers need to refine their work, and they know that workshops are essential to that process. The purpose of these sites is to produce a better manuscript for submission, not to act as a public library.

The Free Trial Period: The short free trial period for new members is unlikely to be a problem. The audience is still limited to a select group of people who have signed up for the service, not the general public.

The most important thing to do is to be honest with a publisher or agent if they ask about the manuscript's history. You can simply state that it was circulated for feedback on a private, members-only workshop site. This is a very common and accepted practice in the industry.

Sol, we're now seeing spammers creating groups on the site. Four very recently, plus an old abandoned one. I renamed all groups to be deleted Obsolete 0 thru Obsolete 4.

Is it possible for you to easily disable the ability of trial members to create new groups? That would likely eliminate most if not all spam groups. I added a new group tonight called "READ ME BEFORE CREATING NEW GROUPS!" specifically to provide guidance for legitimate members thinking of creating one.

Personally, I think trial members should have to wait to create new groups. We haven't had a single successful group created by a trial member since they don't know anyone on the site, don't know if anyone else would be interested in a new group, don't know that they need to advertise new groups, don't know that most current members generally don't use non-Premium groups (especially not the non-Premium forums, with one or two exceptions), etc.

Thanks
Dirk

Thanks, Tamsin. I flagged them for deletion and deleted the spammers' accounts.