3,876

(6 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

I would have suggested no public visibility as to who received extra points. It could upset an author's other reviewers who may not get extra points, either because the author doesn't have them to give, or because their reviews don't merit extra points. I have on multiple occasions received a very large number of thoughtful and detailed reviews from more experienced authors, all in one day. It would be nice to be able to reward that extra effort. (Looks sideways at K)

I may be one of just a few people accumulating an obscene number of points, so this may not be worth the implementation effort.

3,877

(212 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Would it be possible to change the default for the little checkbox on new posts so that the author of the post doesn't accidentally forget to subscribe? I wouldn't be surprised if I've forgotten to check the box on at least some posts. I would imagine most people want to be notified if someone responds to a topic they posted. Those who don't want to receive an email can always uncheck the box.

Also, what is the default subscription behavior for the quick reply? If I'm not already subscribed, will it default to making me subscribed? It probably should.

Thanks as always.
Dirk

3,878

(6 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Sol, do you have plans to implement a mechanism that would allow authors to give points to others? I have a bazillion points, and it would be great if I could give some of my best reviewers points beyond what they earn by default. It might encourage even better reviews.

Dirk

3,879

(4 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Which poem is it? I can check if I see it too.

3,880

(39 replies, posted in The Aurora Mission)

I suggest terraponics. Simple and easier to pronounce (and read) than if it has the extra y in the middle. Few people know what sero is (me among them). I wrote it lowercase as if it had already become a common term by the 24th century, like hydroponics or terrain.

3,881

(39 replies, posted in The Aurora Mission)

I know I wrote something about topsoil today, but I can't remember if I posted it. Based on current topsoil erosion, we have only about 60 years worth left. Mother nature creates about one inch of the stuff every one thousand years. From some preliminary research I did, I found a scientist in Alberta who is trying to speed up the creation process. If I remember correctly, they hope to speed up the process to get it down to 5-10 years, so it can be created in the timespan necessary to support ongoing feeding of humans. I'm sure the process will just get easier with time, so you should have all the topsoil you need for your farms. In addition to crop rotation, farmers sometimes will grow something on an otherwise empty field, and then plow it under solely to serve as nutrients for the next year's crops. Same concept.

I cheated in my book. I was using topsoil from Earth to "seed" new colonies, then assumed that soil formation would spread naturally after that. Don convinced me to use nanobiology, so I combined the two. Seed topsoil from Earth, followed by nanobiology to replicate the original organic matter across a planet's sand, silt, and clay.

That Como Zoo Conservatory is spectacular. Now how to put something that breathtaking into words. :-)

G'night.

3,882

(39 replies, posted in The Aurora Mission)

Understood. The Mayans and Romans both used crop rotation for that reason. However, are you using soil in these farms, or just a nutrient bath? If crop rotation works to put nutrients into the bath that you want to reuse, then great. I think it might easier though to change out the nutrient bath from one floor to another, rather than changing what's grown on each floor each "season". I envision automated machines on each floor specialized for whatever is growing on that floor. Regardless, the nutrient baths will probably still need additional outside nutrients.

3,883

(39 replies, posted in The Aurora Mission)

I don't see crop rotation as necessary as long as you have the right nutrients in the water needed for the plants to grow. The question then is, what nutrients are needed and where will they come from.

3,884

(7 replies, posted in The Aurora Mission)

Also, frequent cloud cover from snowstorms would limit the effectiveness of solar panels, althoiugh Tesla has just started marketing home-scale batteries to power a home if the power goes out. Presumably, energy storage would be very efficient in the future so as not to waste any available solar energy.

3,885

(7 replies, posted in The Aurora Mission)

I hadn't thought of putting solar arrays around the sides of the buildings, but it's a great idea.

I was thinking of covering the whole roof with panels, with sufficient access for workers to keep them free of snow. If you eliminate glass on the rooftop, you have room for more solar arrays to power the building, without the risk of the roof collapsing from snow, although that does happen in some poorly reinforced buildings. I think they would design their buildings to handle the weight.

Cracking solar panels from freezing probably isn't an issue. I've seen plenty of homes powered by solar panels. I assume they're either in a warmer climate, or the panels don't crack from cold. Even modern windows don't crack in -40 degree whether, so panels would be encased in glass.

Wet snow could stick to the side panels, so even those aren't foolproof. Lots of good reasons this is challenging, which is what you want.

3,886

(7 replies, posted in The Aurora Mission)

Would hydroponic farms use direct sunlight? You can already get grow lights in our era. I would think the farms would be entirely inside well-constructed buildings, with a farm on each floor. What I would see as a limitation is the amount of available space for solar panels to power large farms. The solar panels could easily be covered in snow on a regular basis, requiring constant maintenance. Also, I'm not sure if such panels can crack in freezing cold weather.

3,887

(39 replies, posted in The Aurora Mission)

I like your idea of it snowing for the first time at the Panama Canal. It's more interesting when the reader experiences something new along with the MC. Better than flashbacks or telling.

Your reference to hydroponic farms reminded me of a thought I had earlier. It should be possible to stack these farms as high as you want to go, with the only limiting factors being how much solar energy is needed to power the farms and the source of the nutrients. That would make food production a "manageable" problem. It comes down to humans deciding to dedicate the right number of resources to the problem. In fact, I think it would be easier to feed the world under those conditions than it is today. The source of the nutrients is the part I'm unclear about. Perhaps one of you can blow a hole in my logic to keep mankind from solving this problem too easily in the 24th century. :-)

3,888

(39 replies, posted in The Aurora Mission)

Wow! I read six chapters and thought I had only read three. You'll have to get used to my memory gaps, I'm afraid. I also tend to repeat myself at times. Same reason.

I look at the end of chapter 3 and at chapter 4, where father and daughter are together. The argument starts late in chapter 3 and continues through chapter 4. That's plenty of time to establish her anger. Turn up the heat in chapter 4 and you can relate her anger through dialogue. It'll also help increase the tension I thought was missing from chapter 4.

Dirk

3,889

(39 replies, posted in The Aurora Mission)

mikira (AKA KLSundstrom) wrote:

Think about the Little Ice Age that began in the early 1800's and ended when we finally started warming out of it in the 1900's, it correlates to a very low ebb of the sun spot cycle. We in fact had another period before the recent cycle we are in right now where it is starting to show we could be entering another period where we could experience another period where there won't be any sunspots for a long period of time. So I extrapolated on that.

Thank you. Now, I've got it. Did I miss this explanation in the book so far? Sometimes I can't see the forest for trees with all of my nitting. If it's not there yet, I highly recommend putting in the first chapter. As I mentioned, the sea storm would be a great place for such reflection. It wouldn't take more than a few paragraphs (pretty much what you just posted for me) and would help ground the story.

Your call.
Dirk

3,890

(39 replies, posted in The Aurora Mission)

Karen, I apologize if I'm being dense, but what is the reason for the cooling? Is it just that the sun is cooling for unknown reasons, was it a cataclysmic event on Earth? That's an important thing to make clear up front. I didn't see it in the first three chapters, or I missed it.

Tom, an asteroid and/or supervolcano wiped out the dinosaurs, and another cataclysmic event (even bigger) almost wiped all comnplex life several hundred million years before that, so it should be enough for hell to freeze over. :-)

Given my current focus on Biblical topics for my book, it would be interesting to know at some point to know what happened to religion on the planet. With billions dead, I would think people everywhere would turn to religion and that Christians, in particular, would view this as the end times.

Lastly, as I alluded to earlier, wars over food would be endless. By the 24th century, there would also be many more nuclear states, in part to protect themselves from agressor nations. Some of those nukes will no doubt have been used.

Dirk

3,891

(9 replies, posted in Spirituality & Religion)

I am among those who appreciate your feedback, Mike. You've already impacted my story in important ways.

3,892

(39 replies, posted in The Aurora Mission)

Having reread the chapter and my review, I realize I missed this in your reply to me: As for the science I use in here it points to the biggest source of what creates the warmth on this planet and that's the oceans reaction to the amount of sun's energy that it absorbs. And the sun is dimming and giving off less energy.

Are you suggesting the sun is dimming and therefore the oceans are freezing up? If so, that wasn't clear to me in the chapter. I suggest spending at least a paragraph explaining the science in chapter 1 (you can have your MC mulling over that in her head). You can always go into more detail later.

As for the opening, I suggest removing the yoga exercise. It greatly weakens the opening paragraphs, where you want to grab the reader with the ice being where it shouldn't be, and then the heavy seas. Riding out the storm would be an excellent place to have her thinking about the cause of the freezing Earth. Those events/thoughts would be a powerful hook into the story. I read somewhere that the opening sentence and paragraph are very important to a potential reader of your book. If you stop here for yoga, you lose that impact.

As for the ending, having read the later chapters, there is repetitiion of Delana having an argument with her father about him pulling strings to get her on the mission. Therefore, you don't need the argument with her father in the first chapter, so I suggest simply cutting that part out completely and let the chapter end as she hangs up the phone with the President, having been told that he needs her to join the team that will be searching for habitable planets to save the human race. That's a stronger ending than her anger at her father.

Hope that helps.
Dirk

3,893

(39 replies, posted in The Aurora Mission)

I'll reread the chapter later today to refresh my memory, but my first thought about the canal is that they would try icebreakers to attempt to free up the canal. If that's not possible for some reason, then, aside from the problems Tom has already mentioned would be some increase in shipping costs for goods that have to travel around the southern tip of South America, unless everything is solar-powered by then (probably). Also, more danger travelling that route since the winds down there can be severe. If planes are also solar powered, then the canal becomes less relevant, since good can be shipped via Fedex. :-)

My biggest question is how the world came to be frozen over. I think a reader would really like an answer to that to be able settle into a good sci-fi story.

My other question was where the world is growing food if it's close to freezing over. There would be massive wars around the world fighting over scarce food-growing land. Most the human race should be dead or dying. Come to think of it, if the Panama Canal freezes over, then even the Equator (one of the warmest places on Earth) has frozen over, so most of the rest of the world, both north and south, would have frozen over as well, including most freshwater lakes and rivers.

Even if the Equator is still warm enough for food growth, then everything will be clearcut for farmland, unless food growth moves underground. The scale of engineering for the latter would be astounding, although I use it on one of the worlds in my own book. It's doable in my case, because I don't have billions to feed, just millions. For underground food growth, here, too, I suggest solar power instead of oil to power the hydroponics, since oil reserves are probably gone by the 24th century.

Given all that, you may want to leave the Panama Canal clear of ice, to allow for food growth on land around the Equator.

I did quite a bit of research for terraforming worlds, since I have about 60 inhabited planets so far in my galaxy. It turns out, the vast majority of Earth's oxygen came from microorganisms in the oceans (farting oxygen). So, to really terraform a planet, life should already have a long-established foothold on your prospective planets (hundreds of millions of years, if not billions; I don't recall the exact number). You also need a way to rapidly grow organisms for soil formation, since natural soil formation on Earth takes 1000 years per inch (doublecheck me on that one too). Obviously, if microscopic life already exists, then you risk all humans and human food crops being unable to survive on those planets. My book is more space opera than sci-fi, so I glossed over some of those problems, since that level of detail would slow my book's Star Warsian pace.

Obviously, you don't need to answer all these questions in chapter 1, but I think it would really help to give us the cause of this worldwide disaster up front, otherwise you're asking us to accept a premise without explanation. A supervolcano might be able to do it. Or, an asteroid. In the latter case, humans would probably have excellent asteroid detection and deflection technology by the 24th century, although something kicked out of the asteroid belt by Jupiter would come at us so quickly, deflection may not be possible in time.

Dirk

3,894

(6 replies, posted in Spirituality & Religion)

Thank you, Karen and Janet. It's easier to accept the prayer as one made out of anguish.

Dirk

3,895

(6 replies, posted in Spirituality & Religion)

Verses 1-6 don't change the fact that this prayer to God is totally inappropriate, especially if it's coming from one of God's annointed kings. If the authors of the Bible had included it under a heading of how NOT to pray to God, then it would make sense.

3,896

(6 replies, posted in Spirituality & Religion)

While reading about curses in the Bible, I came across Psalm 109, believed to have been written by King David.

    7 When he is tried, let him be found guilty, and may his prayers condemn him.
    8 May his days be few; may another take his place of leadership.
    9 May his children be fatherless and his wife a widow.
    10 May his children be wandering beggars; may they be driven from their ruined homes.
    11 May a creditor seize all he has; may strangers plunder the fruits of his labour.
    12 May no-one extend kindness to him or take pity on his fatherless children.
    13 May his descendants be cut off, their names blotted out from the next generation.
    14 May the iniquity of his fathers be remembered before the LORD; may the sin of his mother never be blotted out.
    15 May their sins always remain before the LORD, that he may cut off the memory of them from the earth.
    16 For he never thought of doing a kindness, but hounded to death the poor and the needy and the broken-hearted.
    17 He loved to pronounce a curse— may it come on him; he found no pleasure in blessing— may it be far from him.

Whoever wrote this, whether David or not, this prayer itself ought to be condemned. Leaving aside that the author is asking God to utterly destroy someone, verses 9, 10, and 12 ask God to bring suffering on the man's children.

Naturally, I would stumble upon the very verses that reinforce my doubts about the Old Testament.

Dirk

3,897

(9 replies, posted in Spirituality & Religion)

I keep forgetting to Google first. The Bible includes over forty verses against cursing, including:

I tell you, on the day of judgment people will give account for every careless word they speak, for by your words you will be justified, and by your words you will be condemned.

He loved to curse; let curses come upon him! He did not delight in blessing; may it be far from him! He clothed himself with cursing as his coat; may it soak into his body like water, like oil into his bones!

Dirk

3,898

(9 replies, posted in Spirituality & Religion)

Thank you, Karen. I figured dammit was probably the most questionable of the list, since it's historically short for 'God damn it.' I don't have that much cursing in my book but was interested if I was crossing any obvious boundaries.

Dirk

Several of my sci-fi characters come from a religious world, New Bethlehem. They're teenagers, so I do have them mildly curse occasionally. For example, one of the teens says, "I'd resist it like hell." Is there anything in the Bible that addresses cursing, besides the obvious of not taking the Lord's name in vain?

Also, are any of the following considered taking the Lord's name in vain:
Good gracious
Holy cow
What in Heaven
Dammit

Finally, if my characters are in a life-and-death situation, is it okay for them to cry out, "God, help us!" without violating the commandment?

Thank you.
Dirk

3,900

(3 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

It's called the Path of War by Anthony Harris.