Amy, I apologize for reanimating this topic.  Just call me Ennis Pyburn.

Some ideas are just too toxic ... .

3,403

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Depending on the family, putting the tree up and decorating it can be a real family party.  Taking it down is more of a chore, but with everyone together it's doable.

Per your review--YOU have the blouse wet.  The brief reaction says that Jaylene has earned more respect with the guards--and with the prisoners.

3,405

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

I was working on the Erevain chapters and had a small problem to fix.  I found a solution that turns me back toward a hard question that I had avoided, even in my thinking.  Now I'm thinking.

I think I may be fighting off a bug.  I've needed a lot of sleep for the past five days.

Further thought on 'Distrusting Alda ...'

Without retracting my new mantra ('Don't Fear the Copula') I'm thinking this could be turned positive: If she trusted Behira, she had to trust Alda.  It does change what goes unstated, but it might better expose the vulnerable part of Jaylene's faith.

FYI, I got the email notice on Judy Goodwin's new chapter before it showed up on my home page.  It took at least ten minutes, and probably more, for it to show up.

I really hope you do the bit with Jaylene's hand going to the scar, and her murmuring thanks.  That act showed a kind of courage in Tazar, call it courage of the heart--courage and greatness.  I'm not qualified to call it a masterstroke, but it belongs on the dais with them.  Having Jaylene acknowledge it will help the reader understand why she treasures this friend so--and what the Wolves were about.

Of course, you might be saving that for a later chapter.

I think that she should start out like that.  Not grossly so, but noticible if you are attentive, but it should fade with time.

You know how someone from work, or the supermarket, or the bank, greets you somewhere on the street and it takes a moment for you to place the person?  That's what the shift should do.  She's just done the amazing super-Alda, Jaylene trusts Behira stuff, and she's a little surprised.

I wonder if that duality would tap into any other part of your story.  You don't have to answer that.

I'm surprised you're still talking to me after I shredded your narrative style twice smile

"I lifted that" -- "The dead don't puke" ---

I wonder if The Other Side of Alda is coming out.  You know, Brekin/Charm has two sides.  Melody/Adalaya were two sides.  Alda has two sides.

Right here I can image Alda back in the "I don't know, ma'am.  Out of mojo," mode.  Instead of bragging how she lifted Tazar, she is sharing her wonder.  Instead of asserting 'The dead don't puke', she offers it ... not quite a question.

Just a quasirandom thought.

There is so much incredible stuff in that chapter, Amy.  You just need to tease it out.

Kiss the pain => sneer, snap, bark, scoff, jeer, rebuff, snub, rail, mock, rag, chaff or chivvy.  Or she could coo it--but not for long just then.  Or  ... snort.  Just enough quick mockery, without cutting deep or wasting time.

I won't claim that Roget's 4th International always comes through, but it usually does.

3,412

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Cellphones won't keep you Christmas tree fresh.

3,413

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

I'm not prepared to do the extensive patent search.  I have a much simpler gizmo that might be patentable.  Too bad Ron Popeil died.  That's the kind of marketing it would need.

3,414

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

janet reid wrote:

ps - So you still have work on the pigeon flasher/pilot too.  Sure you don't want to reconsider any of our (amy and me) other ideas?

I'm rather proud of that extra mosfet in the flash driver.  Even with the bright flash, once I get low-leakage caps in there the -average- current draw will be under 10 milliamps.  Four C cells should be able to keep the flasher up over 900 hours.  Maybe even past 1200.

And I've got a half-decent third-order low pass filter integrated with the voltage transient protection.  Not theoretically elegant, but quite effective.

American culture is deeply bifurcated right now.  Read Huffpo and Townhall.com to find out how much.

American culture is still highly regional, though cities act as melting pots.  (A bad metaphor, by the way.  The right one is a stew, the very source of the motto 'E Pluribus Unum'.)

Okay, now for Amy:  I've put an even longer critique up for Chapter 11.  All the stuff I write there describes what I saw in the chapter when you put it up what, two days ago?  Well, not the vector force stuff around the transfer lift (probably not the right term).  Playing that out (pardon the pun) might take the art of Clancy, but it could be done.

You probably won't want to hear from me for a week.  (I'm good at shooting my own feet.)

3,416

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

The change in the network topology is the wye-delta (or tee-pi) transform.  Contrary to the article, I'm going from wye to delta to save a circuit node.  I should have done it long before (and a practiced circuit designer would have) but I can do it now, and then drop one of the resistors and save some current (like a practiced circuit designer would have).  The power rail edge of the circuit board will get even hairier, but I'll have room for the zener.  Before I order any, I want to fake a zener with a bjt and two resistors.  I'll have to jury-rig the connection off the circuit board, and temporarily  change a resistor, but with a little bit of luck I'll have both low and high transition hysteresis back.

And then I can order a dozen low-current 2.1V zeners, and go back to work on the pilot/pigeon flasher.

Amy, your Ch11 is next.

Virtue in prose consists in the words saying what you mean.  Virtue in poetry consists in the words meaning more that they say.  That's a paraphrase from Chesterton, and probably a poor one.

But we proseists use little poetry techniques constantly.  Using a beat instead of a tag tells us the speaker, but uses the 'said' slot to tell us something else.

Your last pass over Ch 11 doesn't go far enough in this direction, IMO.  You need to go for terseness, speed, and imagery.  Again IMO.  I'm going to do another review pass, and hope it helps you.

3,418

(66 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Not really.  Titles do get re-used, though I wouldn't suggest The Nine Tailors or Gone With the Wind unless for a short story where they were particularly apt--or humorous, as for example, The Nine Taylors.

One of the most valuable (and painless) lessons I ever got was when a very pretty sophmore (no chance, sigh) asked me for help with a problem from her thermodynamics class.  I'd taken it the year before, but it wasn't a core course so I passed it and let it go.  Well, she provided all the thermo knowledge.  What she didn't see was the structure/pattern of her solution.  It was an obvious blind-spot type error -after- the solution was set up, and showing it to her taught me most of what high-school geometry was supposed to teach me, but didn't.

3,420

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Well, making the changes in the output 'instrument' circuits brings it to a point where I understand its behavior just about completely.  Now, the low-level hysteresis circuit isn't being activated.  If I move that mosfet to the battery rail, it will activate properly, but I'll have to clamp the output, which will require an extra node and a low-level zener diodes.  The diodes I would need are several days away by mail order.  I can make the topology more efficient to save a node, but the zener I don't have.

I can fake one temporarily with a bjt and resistors.  That will have to be jury-rigged because it takes another node--unless I can be godawful clever somehow.

3,421

(66 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

That's one of the titles used for John  Dickson Carr's The Three Coffins.

You left a few typos.  There are a couple of places where I'd like to prod you again.

I have to thank you for teaching me my own rules.  When it comes to repeating words, I don't believe in avoiding it at all costs, but there are circumstances when I like to do it, and circumstances where I don't, as you have just taught me.

In the scene where Threckesrom pours for three people with increasing difficulty I am please to use 'pour' three times,  for three repititions of the same action.  But if Kirsey had poured out his soul two paragraphs later, I would have looked for a different word because the action is different.

YMMV.

Arrant pedantry, up with which I will not put. ---WSC

The rule applies in formal English.

In dialogue, your speaker's rules apply.

In ordinary composition, be guided by your style and ear ... but do be aware of the choice.  Aware, not of, not consumed by.

3,424

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Problem in part is in the indicator circuits I'm using to watch what's happening.  I'm still thinking BJT current-operated, and I didn't move the voltage reference to the battery rail.  I'll take care of that after more sleep and a trip to Home Depot ... and maybe some work on Erevain.

The occupation/specialty you want is actually called 'rigger'.