I presume this is in addition to him no longer trying to save an innocent boy... I think this is the kicker.
Example. [J e n n a] lies cheats and steals from her lover in order to get the guns she needs to abduct Inga. Then lies to the child that she's her mother back from the dead in order to comfort her. Reviewers were still willing to give J a passing mark.
It would appear that there's nothing a villain can do wrong when he's rescuing children. I think I'm committing the same reader error when assessing Cain vs. Andrew