As my post in premium describes, I'm trying to find a way to tone down the violence of the murder mystery half of my book.
Why are you trying to tone it down? Has your target audience communicated unease?
If the violence is excessive, I'll lose my target audience.
Who is this audience? The promotion company I used would immediately ask me to rattle off books my audience reads. If I couldn't name at least a dozen, they're kind of giving me the Internet side-eye
if the deaths are too repetitive, they lose their impact.
Valid... but there are only so many ways to brutally murder an innocent priest. By about murder 7, it'll be death by crayon consumption. Ah, but what is "impact"? Is it not measured by how much pathos we have for the victims?
If we're meant to feel an impact then we must feel loss. If we're to feel loss, we must grow to care for the victim.This isn't possible if the victims are dropping off faster than we can learn their stories. Consider having 3 of those victims pop out of the chain and ask the detectives to save them. Them immediately kill one, so we can care for the remaining two. Bonus points if you can make 7 victims meaningful then kill 6 then the 7th gets killed anyway.
I can also add a look of horror frozen on their faces.
I would save that for a horror story
