Completed reviews for Cobber, Mat, and Randy, yesterday.

377

(69 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

vern wrote:
C J Driftwood wrote:

And Vern,
I don't see anything wrong with the point system. It satisfies my goals: improve my craft as I improve my story.


Take care, CJ

If you read my posts instead of getting misinformation from someone else I won't mention, then you would know that I also support the point system AS IS, and not any change being suggested. That has been the whole crux of this discussion.Take care. Vern

Edited for clarification

I was agreeing with you. smile

378

(281 replies, posted in Alpha to Omega - Review Group)

Jube wrote:

I'm running late with this belated add-on, I know. I'll leave it up to each author to decide if they want to continue reviewing Ann during her absence or not. I'm going to continue reviewing her and also because I'm interested in how a romance novel is constructed, having never read one before.

On a completely different subject item--as I work through my skeleton bones plot outline and try to put more meat on it, so I have a firmer grasp of what to aim for in each chapter, I begin to feel a smoldering anger building in me at Stephen King. His creative writing book says don't work with a plot, just wing it like he does. I'd like to chew him out over that but I don't feel like being looked down on, if I actually were to bump into him, since he's 6'4"? 6'5"? Grrr, stork!

Keep in mind, Stephen King's method works for Stephen King. It might not for you. I'm very confident there are well known authors that work differently than Stephan King.

379

(69 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

I'm new to this discussion- sorry to see it degenerate.

I don't think (unless I missed it mentioned) anyone spoke of the free groups. As far as I know, there are only two groups that require the point system. Maybe someone should compare the amount of reviews one receives from a free group against the number from the group with a point system. People who just want to post their work and not offer thoughtful feedback can post away on one of those groups.

Points or no points, it comes down to developing relationships with other reviewers and putting in the necessary time reviewing each others work in order to give valuable feedback. And that takes a while. I personally like the long chapters, but not because of points. Longer chapters give you an opportunity to see more of the story arc as well as get used to a writing style different than your own.
And I've said it many times, I (as a not-yet professional author) learn from others' writing (mistakes and gems). I've improved as a writer as much by reviewing as I have by being reviewed.

And Vern,
I don't see anything wrong with the point system. It satisfies my goals: improve my craft as I improve my story.

And Charles,
Why are you so angry?

Take care, CJ

380

(7 replies, posted in Dynamic Dialogue)

looks like I'm last to post sad

I have given this lesson a lot of thought.

One of my key flaws as a writer has been punctuation (and spelling but thanks to spell-check its not as big an issue as it could be), but the rules applying to dialogue make far more sense than punctuating prose. Commas are my downfall, ask anyone who reviews my work. So punctuation was easier than I thought. It’s hard and fast rules- whereas the rest of my wish list is more subjective.

One of the many key things I need to work on would be: when to use on-the-nose and when not to. I think there is a need for it (on the nose that is)- my current novel is already  205,000 so beating around the bush in every scene can get tedious, esp. when dialogue is a natural fit for backstory. I also have characters that just speak their mind- so on the nose would be good fit in some instances. What I need to do is finesse it. Look for those moments when subtext fits better and use it when applicable. I've also noticed that subtext could be used to misdirect the reader- and that sounds like fun to me! Another point for improvement is to avoid editorializing by my characters.

For me the most eye-opening moment was when you took the dialogue from the last lesson and broke it down - (esp. when you used neener-neener!) No reviewer has ever done that for me and it instantly demonstrated the point. Going forward I’m going to do that to my own dialogue and see if distilled, it goes where I want it to go and packs the same punch. I may also employ that method when reviewing others work on this site (get ready Wyatt and Randy), it was  that enlightening. Also going to read it out loud- I hear that helps.

The class was very useful and I’ve printed out the toolbox from both Lesson 4 and Lesson 5 and they’re pinned to my builtin board. I normally write “stream of conscious” style (sometimes 1-2 glasses of wine are involved) but now  I’m going to be more critical during the editing phase and keep these lessons in mind. Also going to cut many tags- that should help get that word count down!

I’ve thoroughly enjoyed the class and thank you for providing it.  I’m in the middle of my third re-write of my first novel, and applying these tools will fix those problems I’ve noticed but wasn’t sure what to do about. That "there's something wrong with that, but I can't put my finger on it" moments. Now I know what to do thanks to this course.

I’ll invest in some more books (I see Randy has a  nice list going, as well as your suggestion) and I’m a current member of the Atlanta Writer’s Club, but have been lax in going to the meetings. They have really great workshops as well, perhaps I'll sign up for one or two.

Thank you again for the course and your guidance,

CJ

381

(7 replies, posted in Dynamic Dialogue)

Can we post here on the forum, that way we can comment/learn from each other's questions and postings without having to review several separate postings. Might result in a great discussion.

382

(22 replies, posted in Dynamic Dialogue)

I've posted lesson 5- Old version goes first, followed by the revised version. I've also added some character info at the end- I'd like to know if after reading, does the dialogue sound plausible between these characters. And is there any thing I can do to strengthen it?

http://www.thenextbigwriter.com/posting … sion-22032

383

(22 replies, posted in Dynamic Dialogue)

LA,
I was thinking, would it be helpful to post both a before and after version?
I'm going to work on a completely different scene than what I posted in lesson 4, and I think by doing a before and after will help show (whether or not) I mastered the lesson. sad

Completed Randy's revised chapter 1.

385

(17 replies, posted in Dynamic Dialogue)

Everyone- My example is much longer that everyone else's, so just pick a section to review.

386

(17 replies, posted in Dynamic Dialogue)

Hey LA,
revised and reposted:
http://www.thenextbigwriter.com/posting … sion-21994

Boy that was liberating- using your lessons I think the updated version is 100% better! Thanks for the class!
I'm excited to do the rewriting now.

CJ

387

(16 replies, posted in Dynamic Dialogue)

Hey LA,
The lesson was great. There is one thing I get dinged on at review time is staring a chapter with a quote and no tag. Personally I like the affect of blurting in the reader's face, then catching them up with subsequent tags and action tags. The effect is pealing away layers of storyline.
I've read many other books that do that and like it as a reader. Maybe I'm weird that way. Is that really a no-no from a professional writer/publisher standpoint? Or am I just doing it wrong?

CJ

388

(281 replies, posted in Alpha to Omega - Review Group)

Hi Ann,
I've been AWOL from the message boards, myself and didn't see your post. Sorry about the issues. That is scary stuff.
As for reviewing you- I'm not skipping you. Once I get back on track, it will be business as usual- I don't care if you fall behind reviewing me!

Good luck with the master's classes, hope you ace them (know you will if it pertains to writing).

take care,
CJ

389

(10 replies, posted in Dynamic Dialogue)

Okay- now I've done all my homework. smile
http://www.thenextbigwriter.com/posting … usty-21936

390

(10 replies, posted in Dynamic Dialogue)

I should say the exercises- working on the examples now. smile

391

(10 replies, posted in Dynamic Dialogue)

Posted the homework- http://www.thenextbigwriter.com/posting … work-21935

392

(11 replies, posted in Dynamic Dialogue)

Hi all,
Didn't see this or know how to do the links. Hope this works
Homework
http://www.thenextbigwriter.com/posting … w-l2-21907

Sample exercise.
http://www.thenextbigwriter.com/posting … mple-21908

393

(8 replies, posted in Dynamic Dialogue)

I am having the work week from hell and also running behind- sorry!
Major presentation for Walmart due- $$$ for the company and have been missing lunch breaks and working from 7AM to 7PM- that said, I'm trying. Going to do my homework this lunch hour- but the writing assignment may be a tad late as I'm off to a press check in Omaha tomorrow and playing catch the plane all day. So might not be able to post the writing examples until Friday.
CJ

394

(16 replies, posted in Dynamic Dialogue)

So the writing sample is in addition to the homework. Do you want us to do the same sort of thing, using our own examples, then break them down by character driven or plot driven dialogue- tagging them as such?
Or just write them and let others tag them?

Finished review for Stephanie and one for Cobber.

396

(17 replies, posted in Dynamic Dialogue)

Hi LA,
I'm a Graphic Designer by trade, but have been writing since college and looking forward to self-publishing my first novel (once it is as close to perfect as it can be."
My struggles... It seems things have changed since I've been in school- I hear  now we need to just use "said" as tags and I find that boring. I write stream of consciousness and try to hear my characters in my head in order to decide how and what they should say. I'm looking forward to working with a professional. The story lines I've been posting here I've been working on for...years. Many years. I'm up to a 4 part series- but nothing ready to go to print yet.
I think what I'm looking forward to learning is:
1. Keeping the dialogue natural, while still furthering the plot.
2. Finding ways of characterizing the speech itself.
3. PUNCTUATION, PUNCTUATION, PUNCTUATION.
4. And effective dialogue- how to get a character to speak volumes, while saying very little.
Thanks for the class- hope we get more members, though!

Finished Alkemi's Souring Seas Chapter 2.

Finished Jube's  "The World Of Phyries" Chapter 2.

Reviewed Ann's Novel- 9/9

Completed Randy's Chapter 3 on August 20th.