No.

Big issue about making Alina be the primary villain throughout the entire Anver thread is that they need the crypt open to find Faulter's hidden room, as well as Zyrtec's prank jar.  If I made Alina a common thread for both books, she would have to be undead and aware, messing with Anver as he chased Maalok into the lower levels.

Did Maalok animate Alina and the two murdered students? Yes. But bring them back to a semblance of life and capable of using magic? Ooooo, dunno. Gotta think about that one.

My brain is all twisty now. Maalok is wearing a Horror. That much is revealed in the Shadowbook that Zyrtec left for Anver to find (in Acts). I've just revealed that Horrors are a piece of the Defiler (in Dictates). I've also stated that no one but the Defiler can raise someone from the dead (in Dictates).

Unlike Kenny, I like to follow my own rules. (had to get that jibe in, sorry K). So the question I need to answer is whether or not Maalok can raise the dead. I'm going to say that it is unlikely. Maalok's Horror is based on pride, while Charm is based on vanity (or lust-never commited to that decision). I don't think that Maalok would have the power required, even if he used the death energy of the murdered students.

Don't worry, New Jersey. I'll keep the pace going if Kenny's idea is worth my time. As to a book that intercuts all the threads as they happen, that is the way I used to write this story. I would do one chapter of each book at a time, syncing the stories. It just became a bloated monster, (Acts alone is more than 150K words). I haven't given the synchronous story idea up, but like you said, I have to finish the story first.

You are saying that I need to keep Alina alive for the entire length of Anver's story?

The thing I'm facing is that Ernie's reaction isn't a surprise. It has happened once or twice before. There have been a few others that felt kind of betrayed by Acts. Almost as if I'd wasted their time by making them read a book and not resolving the necromancer issue by the end. I'm writing a first draft so things will have to be added as I realize their importance (like mentioning that it isn't possible for someone to have read the entire library), so I think that this is a doable solution to my quandry.

I'm not being vulnerable. I'm just trying to wrap my head around how to finish this story in a way that satisfies. The visual I get is Lucas' ending of the 4th Star Wars segment, with everyone standing around at an awards ceremony and everyone laughing a a cute R2-D2. In other words, the main plot kept running in the background, but the first movie wrapped up with HFN (Happy for Now) satisfaction. (yes, Kenny, I learned that one from you)

I've always been good at telling a story, but finding the ending of a book is something that I've only managed once (with Acts). Ernie's reaction (which I consider valid) could be described as irritation. He has called it the never-ending story more than once.

While I know that I'm not going to satisfy every reader, this is still a valid critique. Largely because of Ernie, I've realized that I need to break Acts into two parts. The first will use the conflict with Alina as the driving action and end near or around the duel. The second book will pick up afterwards and deal with the necromancer presence as Anver figures out who is responsible and then explores the crypt after Alina's death. That way, I'll have a focused villain and a tighter plot line. I'll also have the ability to end each book with the HFN resolution.

I am thinking of adding more irritation on Jaylene's part as a way of helping the reader realize there are changes in store. Behira's mysteries are changing the way Jaylene thinks of her religion. Her Goddess has a few warts and these are becoming visible. There should be more outrage as Jaylene discovers these exceptions...kind of like writing Ernie's reaction into the character.

When I decided to make this the point where Jaylene gets a clue about Alda, it was me making the attempt to start a reveal without having everyone hit themselves (or me) in the head with a brick at the end. i'm still on the fence as to whether or not I've succeeded.

Kenny, I like the idea of having Lewellen mention trying the same feat as Alda and how he could never have that much time. That will be added.

Any thoughts?

In the second or third chapter, the guard who ran away from the resurrection was questioned. He said he was alone while on guard. He wasn't aware that Alda was there. He was the puppy who got killed instead of Jaylene during the assassination attempt.

Oh, and holding every job except fixing the roof means that Alda might have been both Voice or Hand at one time or other. Just so y'all know.

She can see into the hearts of others (and knows that Elston loves Jaylene) Note that Jaylene mentions that the Defiler used to look into the hearts of his followers and use that knowledge to destroy them.

As to the fighting with her spear and never casting spells, I think I may have to go back and edit so that Alda doesn't even cast a light spell on the spear she carries. Or I may make that the one spell she is capable of. Not sure. But that is the thing about misdirection. You have to notice what ISN'T happening as well as what IS happening. I never go into Alda's POV when they are fighting the mar, so no one realizes she is following the person in front of her. She never sees the footprints that lead the priests along the waterfall. That part is assumed because all the other priests can do it.

The first use of the shield wall was under the cover of the waterfall mist. No one knew that Alda was landlocked at that time because they all ran into position and braced.

I'll add to the library and her boast about working every job in the temple...Someone will need to scoff and say that isn't possible. Simple fix.

Did you get the wave file? I wasn't delaying or ignoring. We've been fighting off lethargy from the recent respiratory bug. I've done nothing but sleep for days.

857

(520 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

I like the twist of having C find a clue rather than letting men be the answer. Nice.

Don't know what you mean by 'declaiming' other than breaking down this piece into component parts. It isn't in Greek or Latin, and it doesn't cover a legal situation or advice on how a hero should act.

Have to admit, I'm confused. Do you want me to break it down by consonant hits? Because that is what we were talking about before.

I get that you hear meter and rhythm in words. I hear speech differently and don't analyze it. It's like the rhythm just IS. That's why I imitate accents really well.

Will read this part before I revise that chapter. Still in overload after putting out these three chapters.

Just an update. I've been putting shirt blurbs on my Facebook site. Figured that most of what I was seeing there was regurgitated material that people forward and family scrapbooks with an occasional infomercial and blogs about personal depression and hemorrhoids.

Fresh material...I can do that. After all, I'm a writer, right?

So I started giving updates about my autistic son. Then I started pointing out landmarks on the Ohio turnpike.  The writers conference told me to pick one source of media and do it well. So I don't post a lot of family photos. I try to skip forwarded material. Notable exceptions are things that make me laugh, geek moments, and pictures of things or places I want in my books.

Today, for the first time, someone friended me who I don't know. She is a friend of C's teacher from last year. I don't know what to think of this, except to say that I think what I am writing is of value to someone who is a stranger. Does that mean it has more value? Dunno. However, I think this is a milestone.

(Pats self on back)

I lived through the experience. Feel free to whack away at the next one, too. I'm trying to figure out what the characters (especially Jaylene) are going to do now that she is closer to understanding Alda.

862

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Just make it so that he has the pain whenever he tries to activate his sorcery. That way, he is locked in one dimension similar to the girl who Merran's mother landlocked (Pengrit). So his suffering is solely caused by himself. If he doesn't try to use power, then he can eat, drink, and move around. That would drastically extend the length of the spell and keep him under control for a longer time.

It makes sense that Merran would use a similar spell that was a combination of what her mother taught her-with the pain being a little detail that got tagged on just for spite.

863

(520 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

I owe you more than one review and will look at the pace. Since you are in doubt, suggest that you go ahead with the story and add the other combat later once the first draft is done. That way, you can get M back to the keep so he can treat C like a prize of war:-)

I have to say that yacht troubles has never been listed as problems with viewing my work. Poor stressed out yacht guy. And in the winter, too!

Thanks for the heads up and will enjoy whatever time you can spare!

865

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

I agree that hallucinations would help him break from a locked spell by forcing his brain on another track. As to the water, I was willing to suspend belief. I don't take a hallucinating man's estimate of time as reliable. And he was right next to a stream, so he might have had a drink without realizing it.

I've seen people live more than three days without fluids. Mind you, they weren't walking around, but the outside temp makes a difference too. If they aren't sweating much, they can last a while.

OK, another chapter of Dictates is up. "Eyes That Can See".  I'd toot my own horn, but this one was already mostly written and just needed revision once I knew the specific situation.

To anyone interested, I'm going to the Chicago Writers Conference again this year. The invitation is open to any and all. This conference doesn't concentrate on science fiction or fantasy, but I've found it useful. They have a pitch-fest with publishers present for finished works. They recommended a variety of things that I'm using now, like a great site on twitter under #mswl (manuscript wish list) where I've been searching out possible publishers that might not throw my work in the trash.

I've gotten more out of this conference than just these two things, but I think it is wise to diversify…our site is a classic example. Having people who specialize in romance and history (rather than fantasy) means an impartial reader base. If these guys say they don't understand, then I know there is something I need to patch or fix.

Anyway, I'm gonna be there again. Kenny, get your damn passport. The dates will likely be in September or October again. Janet, if you fly out, I'll buy the wine!

http://www.chicagowritersconference.org/conference/

868

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Review is up, then.

I could pick on you for being awake right now, but I'll give you a pass for a change.

869

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Did I review the Chaplerette in B2 that you wanted? If not, then give me the number and title, please.

Rub it in, you Hawaii-living-the-dream guy!

Didn't know that about JJ. Thanks.

872

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Surprised you didn't take up the new chapterlette in B2.

Good point. I'll get there next.

New chapter is up. Boy, I'm tired. I don't think there is much I can get done tonight, but I have the next two nights off. Will try to recip then. I owe you guys a million reviews.

Getting the ending written down (even though I know it will change) made a huge difference. I know I said it before, but I can't emphasize it enough. I had somewhere to take my characters. It doesn't make the process of writing any easier, but it helps aim you in the right direction.

I'm not worried about having my material poached. I'm worried about plot spoilers and sequel information splashed over the internet. I'm working on multiple books at the same time. My forum posts reflect this.

This site is based on the concept that one of us…many of us…somewhere…sometime…are going to make it big. Most of us plan on self-publishing if no agent shows interest. We will see our books in print. For these people, this isn't that big of a deal. However, if any of us ever want to work with a publisher, this is a REALLY big deal. You can bet they will google our names and the names of our characters/ title of our books. They will search out our websites. Finding the plot laid out on a public forum would be cause for dismissal.

Not that I ever expect to follow in JK Rowling's footsteps, but her example is pertinent. She kept the plot a secret for seven years. The release of those books was a world-wide event. I'm not like her because I can't write in a vacuum. I need to unlearn bad habits and polish my writing style.

So I'm in a bind because I need the internet.

I need people. In my hometown, I never found a group so fine as the one I've found in this community. However, our group forum is full of plot discussions. My fault, really. One of my cohorts calls me the 'plot killer' because I read and remember. He has his characters do or say something and I retort, "Um. No. Remember when you said…" He throws food at his computer screen and howls, but he knows that I improve his continuity.

So, as I said, this is a big deal.

Sol, can you weigh in?