151

(78 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Amen.

152

(15 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Dirk B. wrote:

Based on examples from other writers, when I shortened it, I kept caps: "The Guard stands with you, Imperator." as opposed to "The guard stands with you, Imperator."

You had it right.

153

(20 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Good to hear, Marilyn and Temple! We here in the U.S. tend to ignore the devastating storms that occur on the other side of the globe.

154

(20 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

I' was without power for two days but now back on line. Still raining, though, and speaking of that, did the dam hold, Marilyn?

I assume you're looking for an agent because you want a Big-5 publishing contract. You should research agents carefully re their track record in that regard. The only advantage of snaring an agent is to get that elite contract. Medium-size publishers usually don't require an agent middleman; in fact, some prefer you don't have one. Several years ago I did the agent research thing, narrowed them down by expressed interest in my genre and proven track record. I sent out dozens, if not hundreds, of queries. Less than half bothered to reply at all. Of those that did respond, they did so with boiler plate rejections. Occasionally, I received a reply that addressed the actual query, explaining the reason for the rejection. Those were my favorites. Eventually, I gave up looking for an agent and went directly to publishers. Goodness knows I wouldn't mind having an agent that could get me an advance with Putnam or the like, but until then I've got a publisher who is author-friendly, is sticking with me, and has offered to renew the  contracts for my earlier books. Good luck with your search. You might get in touch with GPyrenees- who did find an agent back in the day - for tips.

156

(4 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

I agree with Vern about #5! Consequently, that makes #6 moot. #25 is priceless!

157

(5 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Congratulations, Janet!

158

(14 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

I'm surprised Temple wants it spelled out. One writes, "Poverty claimed another victim," and the reader can make the interpretation -  helped, perhaps, by the description of the victim when discovered, but not necessary, since we should already have a context in the story.

159

(10 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

I would add a #6 for Ms. Marsh's consideration: Don't overuse hyphenated words, especially when the words don't get hyphens. (Heavyset, not heavy-set, Ms. Marsh.) Doesn't she proofread her posts?

160

(16 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

The Getaway in Space

161

(8 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Marilyn Johnson wrote:

Another thing that annoys me:  classified ads.  I read one this morning in a newspaper:  For Sale:  White woman's purse.

I wonder what happened to that white woman. And how about those headlines like, "Springfield school needs to be aired."

162

(8 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

I used to like Clive Cussler's books. I still like the imaginative stories, but I find it hard to read them as literature anymore. His dialogue tag and POV errors, as well as his penchant for adverb modifiers,  distract me from the story.

163

(11 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Basic)

Now that's what I call perseverance! Congratulations.

164

(9 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

When I started out, I thought I had what it took to be a writer. I knew how to put words together to make coherent sentences, I had a decent vocabulary, I knew all the rules of grammar and punctuation (not quite all, it turned out!). So when I started posting chapters here ten years ago, the critiques surprised and humbled me. But I learned and didn't become discouraged, because reviewers gave me positives along with the negatives. Ten published books later, I'm still learning. I'd like to think that each new novel I write is better written than the previous one. I still get the occasional scathing review here, but now I have the experience (and confidence) to consider such critiques as opinions - some on point and worthwhile, others not - rather than gospel. It takes time to find one's stride in this pursuit. Those with the writing bug, and you seem to be among that number, should stick with it, regardless of how gloomy the path ahead appears at the moment. Otherwise, one will always wonder about what might have been.

165

(15 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Congratulations, Randy!

166

(62 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

dagny wrote:
Deckland Oz wrote:

So why is it okay for him to so obviously disobey the sacred rules and overuse said in such a blatant way? Well, because that's his style.

And he has a fan base.
My advice to writers: don't break rules unless you have a fan base that support you no matter what.
smile

Absolutely right. Clive Cussler has a huge fan base, and I'm among that number - but for the stories, not the writing. He breaks dialogue and POV rules all the time. But, to the point others in this thread have made, I didn't notice that in the beginning of my fanship. It was only later, after I learned the "rules," that his writing bothered me. But I still like his stories.

167

(62 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Useful points, except I disagree with #4. People do use hesitating words like "uh" and "um" in conversation, so I don't see why they should be banished from written dialogue. And, in fact, the use of these words often in a character's dialogue can distinguish their speech pattern from that of other characters (#6).

168

(36 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Until someone can give me an example whereby putting in that last serial (Oxford) comma confuses the meaning instead of clarifying it, I'll be an Oxford comma writer! There's no reason not to use it, IMO, other than a determination to avoid commas at all cost. And then the onus would be on the anti-Oxford comma writer to make sure the sentence doesn't give the reader the pause he was trying to avoid in the first place.

169

(14 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

C J Driftwood wrote:
jack the knife wrote:
j p lundstrom wrote:

Wow, Marilyn--you do pack a punch!
I was just thinking, and I wondered: is an ellipsis one set of three dots, or would three dots, being plural, be ellipses? JP

One set of three dots is an ellipsis. More than one ellipsis are ellipses.

Not sure what Marilyn meant by an ellipsis symbol (other than dots). I tried looking it up and got nowhere. And to my mind, using a symbol of some sort instead would confuse most readers, so why bother?

Some keyboards these days have the elipse as a single key- that may be the "symbol".

Ah.

170

(14 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

j p lundstrom wrote:

Wow, Marilyn--you do pack a punch!
I was just thinking, and I wondered: is an ellipsis one set of three dots, or would three dots, being plural, be ellipses? JP

One set of three dots is an ellipsis. More than one ellipsis are ellipses.

Not sure what Marilyn meant by an ellipsis symbol (other than dots). I tried looking it up and got nowhere. And to my mind, using a symbol of some sort instead would confuse most readers, so why bother?

171

(14 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Congrats, Don. Nice to see you again!

172

(3 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

smile

173

(3 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

I suspect a bias from Sol in letting this thread - with no responses - last this long! It's been up for over a day! What say you, Sol? Like seeing  strokes in the Forum? smile

174

(3 replies, posted in This is US!!)

Stay the course, Mike.

No problem, Stephen. I just wanted to make sure you knew the importance of feedback to reviewers, something new members on the site have not been aware of in the past. As I said in my review, I liked the start of your story and plan to continue with it.

Regarding the difficulty you found combining chapters in your book, another writer had a similar problem. It's easy to remedy: All you have to do is go to your profile page, click on your book, then click on + chapter. Then you paste your manuscript copy and the chapter will be added to what you've posted. If that wasn't your issue, then never mind. smile And you don't need to dismantle a chapter every time you make a revision in it. You can edit in situ. The original reviews will still be there, though the revision might make them irrelevant. But I don't usually read other reviews, anyway.

It's a nice reminder to reviewers of your book to see a new posted chapter in the list, but it's not essential. Good thing, since posts only last a few days before being pushed off the list by new posts. I keep a list of those books I'm reviewing, and when I don't see a new chapter posted, I go to the author's profile page, click on the book, and click on the next chapter in line.

Cheers!