jack the knife wrote:. My question to you - who admits being a reader, not a writer - why do you pony up the yearly fee just to read WIPs, some of which will never be completed? Your post puzzled me, so I felt compelled to respond. Besides you, there have been a few, I guess, though I can only remember one - Porgy - who only read and reviewed and didn't post. So why do you do it, William? This inquiring mind wants to know.
To more concisely answer the direct questions you pose.
Why does an audience watch a band perform? Is the drummer baffled, wondering why the audience are not all at home in their garages playing the drums themselves?
Is the author whose novel I purchased in the bookstore on Saturday wondering why the hell do all these thousands of readers buy my book rather than write one themselves?
I am an avid reader. I’ve read everything classic, contemporary and commercial on every ‘top ten’ ‘top fifty’ and ‘top one hundred’ books you should read list, which I’ve ever read.
I don’t think that a writer should be surprised to discover that readers exist and are out there eager to consume good writing.
I think that several writers here on tNBW need to learn how to write for a reader rather than for another writer.
My bad, William. I assumed - wrongly - that you were a paying member.