Alda isn't a character.  Alda is a mask worn by Aldamurisse.  (Have I misspelled that?)   So you can't show that in the ordinary way.  Her 'development' turns out to be important to the Quest--the key to its success, at then end.  And, at the end, Aldamurisse chooses to act when she could hide.  Play that up.

From the beginning, your base story has Alda/M moving from choosing to hide to choosing to act.  She cares about stopping Ghen (though we don't know who he is yet) (and she isn't sure of herself--uncertain depths in the character behind the mask--cue Angel of Music).  Bit by bit, Mask Alda comes to act with more knowledge. Aldamurisse lets her knowledge out because she cares about Tazar.  He's such a good soul, innocent not of knowledge but of ill-will, that she has to care about him.  He's a puppy with the wisdom of a sheepdog and the power of a war-dog--and the humility always to listen and learn. Tremendous character--and your original intro, in the prison, was perfect..

By this time the reader knows that something is going on inside Alda.  But we should discover it when mask-Alda comes to learn who she really is.

You can't show Alda's development from the inside, because the inside is Aldamurisse.  And Aldamurisse is a secret to be hinted at, then glimpsed, and then finally revealed when only she can clear the field for Behira's forces to survive and win the battle.

I'll be trite: Think how Marvel Cinematic would handle Mask Alda/Aldamurisse.  Not the smash, bash, and crash, but the reveal and the eucatatrophe.  Jaylene:  She has saved my life!  I, the Lance of Behira, have vouched for her.  Founder: You cannot vouch for what you do not know.  This is the cowardly sister who betrayed Behira!  There is your story, juices dripping from the red meat.

As far as the Catacombs and the rest, you and I both need to embrace de Saint-Exupéry's maxim: Perfection is achieved not when there is nothing left to add, but when there is nothing left to take away.  (More on my forum.)

(de Saint-Exupéry's introduction to The Little Prince is one of the most beautiful paragraph's I know.

To Leon Werth

I ask children to forgive me for dedicating this book to a grown-up. I have a serious excuse: this grown-up is the best friend I have in the world. I have another excuse: this grown-up can understand everything, even books for children. I have a third excuse: he lives in France where he is hungry and cold. He needs to be comforted. If all these excuses are not enough then I want to dedicate this book to the child whom this grown-up once was. All grown-ups were children first. (But few of them remember it.) So I correct my dedication:

To Leon Werth,
When he was a little boy

)

Oh, and I think The Hero's Journey is the wrong template, IMO  This story is The Quest.

Is your audience a lit-fic audience or a magic-and-mystery audience?

Alda will be an everlasting problem to write in first-person because she's half person and half marionette.  It can be done, but the skill needed is very high.  You had the right balance earlier.

If you've got two wheels in the right lane and two in the left, someone could say you're too far to the left; move right.  But rhe problem might also be that you are too far to the right and you need to move left.

You gamed these characters and the storyline out.  That gives the story its life.  Trust that.

I'll do that review this afternoon.  I don't think you'll like my dislikes.  sad

It's her journey, but the story is about destroying ancient dangers ... and Jaylene has a story as well.

You can move to Alda's PoV and back, and if you do it for wry moments, you can hide things or expose them in the moments.

The business with the knots in the library is the Veiled Alda trying to live up to her new rank.  Her dawdling with the diaries is the Old Veiled Alda leaking back out.  Alda is not going to be competent until the Veil lifts, and even then Aldamurrisse has scars that make it hard for her to be a responsible person.

You got so much right, so much rich nuance that makes sense once we know the whole story, that you don't ned to add.  You need to condense, to turn the Catacombs trip nto more dramatically purposefull steps.  Turn the Antlion ino a a few glimpses that tell the story.  (Yeah, what I need to do all over the place.)

Tazar gives her someone who will accept her, who will accept her help, without asking too many questions.  (He asks them, but he can keep them to himself.)

With the Mar, have her treat Tazar when other people's backs are turned.  Show the alert reader that he knows she helped--but chooses not to ask or comment

You got it all right--except for the diluted length of the presentation.

You can keep the comedy.  Use the comedy to hide clews.  But by putting Alda constantly in the spotlight, you're telling us 'This is Alda's story'.

When the stage musical =A Chorus Line= was in tryouts, the wriers and pruducers, not to mention the performers, were disappointed that one of the songs fell dead flat.  It had everything--a story, a happy ending, a painfully funny truth, and a slightly risque punchline.  But they gave the punchline away in the title.

So they changed the title--to -Dance 10, Looks 3-:

Dance 10, looks 3, and I'm stll on unemployment,
Dancing for my own enjoyment.  Dance 10, looks 3 is like to die!
Left the theater and called the doctor for my appointment to buy
Tits and Ass!  Bought myself a fancy pair
Tightened up the derierre.
Did the nose with it, all that goes with it.
Had the bingo-bongos done.  Suddenly I'm getting national tours!
Tits and Ass won't get you jobs
Unless they're yours.

I think you can see the original title.  But with the new title, emphasizing the immediate dilemma rather than the ... existential ... dilemma, the song became one of the show's signature numbers.

Let the weight of Alda's circumstances be developed through the eyes of others.

In the end, Alda's wish to be free of the weight of her past is Aldamurisse's wish, shrouded by the Veil.  I'd say it's a guilt that would rather leave the past behind, but will step in to fix things when there's a clear choice between letting things go and stopping future disaster.  Otherwise why did she revive Jaylene, and why did she step in to stop the poisoner?  She could have let things go, and nobody in the order would have been any wiser.

482

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Some wimd.  An hour or two of slow, large-flake snow on Friday.  Mostly a little warmer than usual (unlike last year, which flirted extensively with Farenheit Sub-zero.

Just read Paul Halter's =Seven Wonders of Crime=.  As the author intended, I got the whodunnit solution before the detective, at about 90% of the way.  (I added the culprit to my list of suspects at around 70%).  And that has me thinking of Alda.

If you put her front and center, the reader may see too much too soon.  As a reader, I'd like to see the mystery of her creep up.  One of tge strengths of the Fishing chapter is that the humor distracts from the magic that surrounds this comic distraction.

To my taste, the best thing would be for Alda to take over the story sneakily, creepily, so that the reader isn't sure whether the central mystery is the Evil or Alda.

Should I be looking for something?  I don't see it yet.

485

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Musing:

I just watched a performer who trained at a now-closed clown college, and who just attended a reunion in Orlando.  I didn't ask, but I'm pretty sure it was the one run by the recently-defunct RB,B&B Combined Shows.

"Ladies and Gentlemen, Boys and Girls, CHILDREN of All Ages!"  I was never a circus habitue, but the words give me goosebumps.  An adult without a child inside is hollow.  A child forbidden to grow into an adult becomes a monster.

And our present political climate makes it shameful to keep a child in the right place inside .. and even more shameful for a child to grow up as a fully responsible and accountable moral agent.

486

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

When it is within seven leagues of ready.

487

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Finally getting pen to paper on the 'prequel' chapter.  I've got about 2100 words down.  It's the easy part, it's about 25% too long, and it's about a third--or maybe a quarter of the thing.

I'm going to suggest a book that I think very valuable--so valuable that I'm struggling to turn the clearly correct advice into my work!

The book is Matt Bird's The Secrets of Story.  The author starts by explaining that his expensive Columbia MFA was worse than useless, because it taught all the wrong things--things not to do.  Then he boils his experience down to 13 rules so obviously right your only problem is the skills to do them.  But you know what you're working towards.

489

(1,528 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Too good not to share:

https://static.pjmedia.com/user-content/1/files/2018/02/11053045_10204540991385312_1501555514551811227_n.jpg

What is the story?  Does Izzy face challenges that ready her for The Main Event?  Do those challenges start (perhaps) with things that mirror ordinary-but-difficult experiences?  Do they come to include experiences that define her?  Mustakes and consequences?

Declare the pennies on your eyes.

Is the thing to be overcome the antagonist or the character's own flaws and limitations?

I once read a humor essay in which the 1st person narrator told his new college advisor that his life's goal was to shoot a world-champion moose.  Have your characters any ambitions, anything that gives their lives meaning, no matter how trivial?

And contaminates the feedstock.  Which book is going to explain how this blows up the whole city, and leads to the civilization's death-by-senescence?

Lynne Clark wrote:
amy s wrote:

K just writes to kill off his characters. I've learned not to care about anyone. He also writes about 30 mph horses and has his MC ride bareback in freezing cold weather wearing nothing but a sheet. Did I say the character was bareback? Naked except for a sheet? In the freezing cold when she had availability of clothing in the castle where she just killed everybody? OK, moving on.

This is why he needs me around. I scream and stick pins into his voodoo doll when he pulls that kind of crap.

He must think some people don't feel the cold.

I think he has one of them swim after his love in a river of cryogenic fluorine fuel.  The Hellespont is not enough.

Linguistics, huh?  You know about McWhorter's hypothesis--or belief--that English's uses of the auxilliary 'do' in its various forms came out of the Celtic lamguages?

"The great Gaels of Ireland are the men that God made mad/For all their wars are merry and all their songs are sad."

There are books to ease the terror of existential despair.

There are also books to inspire the terror of existential despair.

Acts, Mandates, Dictates run more or less in parallel; Amy has a fourth book to bring the threads together.  IMO, Acts is the masterwork.

(runs screaming from the Prologue)

I believe he means the 'ensemble' of characters.

Warning: K's stories resemble Mickey Spillane's =I the Jury=.  Everyone gets killed off.  Sanguinary, not sanguine.

https://www.sunnyskyz.com/blog/2412/20- … cs-Arrived