It was either Ayn Rand, or Nathaniel Brandon, or maybe one of her characters, who said that if someone attacks a man of low self-esteem, the thinks less of himself, if someone attacks a man of high self-esteem, the thinks less of the person who attacks him. Constructive criticism could be defined as the kind you'd do yourself of yourself, if you were outside of yourself to do it. If one of my characters is acting the way another would, but not her, that is worth pointing out. If in a POV change, one character, who should be talking about guns the way a primitive would, and not the way a sophisticated gunslinger would, then pointing that out is a blessing. You can't catch everything. If I'm writing pseudo-scientific gobbledegook, the way they did so well in Star Trek: TNG, I need to know whether it works or not. A bad review, one intentionally mean, is an expression of the person's own insecurities (Well, at least I'm not *that* bad.) But the proper response to being surrounded by bad writers is Edgar Rice Burroughs--"Hey, I can write as bad as those (best sellers.)" And he was right, died rich and with a section of Los Angeles named after a character of his. The proper response to a harsh but fair critic is "What does not kill me, makes me stronger." (Yes, I know that's a cliche. So hurt me. Beat me. lol)
426 2017-08-17 21:55:33
Re: If you can't say something nice ... (72 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)
427 2017-08-15 04:49:57
Re: SOL HAVE WE BEEN HACKED??? WHAT IS CYCO? (23 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)
I got it too. And I can't access anything from my computer when it's on. I'm using my phone to post this.
428 2017-08-11 23:49:34
Re: Do sales = good? (12 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)
But vern--Oprah recommended it. She also recommended Obama. How could she be wrong? Erm.
429 2017-08-11 21:36:25
Re: Any interest in a collaboration project? (6 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)
I'd be interested, but I doubt if I have the time, given that my book has fissioned twice, and is now four books (not counting the one that has the same characters and background but is a different novel). Now, if it were someone who could guarantee I was a best seller? Sorry, Justin, but James Patterson, you're not. Love you anyway. Rhia
430 2017-08-11 21:33:01
Re: Do sales = good? (12 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)
Do sales equal good? Hmmm. All time best sellers are The Bible and Atlas Shrugged. In the '90's, the Turner Diaries sold 100,000 copies and was only not on the New York Times Best Seller List for ideological reasons (which I agree with, btw.) I think we all know the answer to the question. A book (or any work of art) is subjectively judged. A best seller means that, in the sum total of individual decision making (known as the free market), enough people decided that they preferred it that it makes lists in newspapers that the sum total of decision makers decided were worth reading (e.g., The New York Times). Objectively, is a low selling book good, and a high selling book, bad? Ask God, the World Historical Spirit, or their representatives on Earth--the Pope or Napoleon. I only work here. lol
431 2017-08-11 16:05:19
Re: WIP Rhiannon the Nude, Vol 2: New Fairy by Rhiannon (123 replies, posted in Close friends)
As my writing is ongoing, I continue my research. I found out, interestingly enough, there are people who actually have Rhiannon's handicap. They aren't cursed by a witch, but they have an irrational fear of clothing; some can't wear clothes at all. It is thought this may be brought on by extreme allergic reactions to common textiles, or by their parents dressing them in ways that made them objects of ridicule by kids. There was a forum on phobias where one woman wrote in about her lifestyle adjustments; she was ridiculed in the forum as a man getting some fetishistic joy about pretending to be a vestiphobe. Whether this is true or not, it did plausibly show how one might lead one's life, given this phobia: homeschooling, online college, and I presume, as she ages, online jobs. (I wonder how in the olden days, someone might make the adjustments. They'd have to have a supportive family, go to nudist colonies, and probably end up in a job that requires nudity. Oh, there is a union of sorts for professional naked people--models, exotic dancers, etc--so that is possible. Just thought I'd pass on this interesting phenomenon. Rhiannon's nakedness was symbolic of handicaps and overcoming them--we are all powerless against nature and others and are thus handicapped. In the fourth story, the depth structure centers on a character who has amazing powers and abilities (far beyond those of mortal woman), and, due to her insecurities, lands up almost alienating the woman she loves and is facing possible permanent exile or beheading. The third book deals with culture clashes, as one kingdom is dominating a kingdom that used to dominate it. Anyway, thought I'd pass on these insights.
432 2017-08-11 06:57:43
Re: Hi All, My name is Lauren (2 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)
Glad you came back, Lauren. Your story reminds me of Isaac Asimov. He wrote popular, and some say, genre-changing stories back in the '50's. He inspired George Lucas, who based his technology in Star Wars on Asimov (Asimov loved Star Wars). Then, in the middle of one of those genre-changing narratives, he stopped writing science fiction entirely. A trilogy of robot stories lacked its third book. He did move on to popularizing science, and was good at that. A lot like you going from poetry to story writing. Then in the 'eighties, he wrote the third robot novel, found a way to tie together the robot, empire, and foundation series inspiring the other dean of science fiction, Robert Heinlein, to do the same for his books, and wrote more in the foundation series. He referred to his muse as his daemon (after Socrates). Your daemon expresses your creativity, but it also takes care of you. Glad you've found it again.
433 2017-08-10 18:44:36
Re: Dilemma (10 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)
I would honestly and objectively review the book, but start with the positives. I've lived in Puerto Rico, and that's how they begin criticism. They hate to say 'no,' there and by the time they get to it, you have to blink before you realize it wasn't a 'yes.' After you do the positives, go into the negatives, saying things like "This isn't up to your usual standards," or "I couldn't believe that this was you writing--were you possessed?" Offer to make it into an edit session (pointing out you usually get paid for that, but as he's a friend, etc.). And remember (perhaps remind him) that true friends are honest--that's the only way you can be sure that the dress you picked out for the evening isn't as hideous as you suspect it is. (Just never ask a man, "Does this dress make me look fat?" No matter how good a friend they are.)
434 2017-08-09 01:45:44
Re: Writing Advice: Realism and Ikea instructions (5 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)
j.p., there are men who don't grunt, swear and claims his partner as mine? As far as clothing, there's a happy medium, and in fantasy, you have to go in detail, at least the first time, as people want to know--what are they wearing? i sometimes just say a golden kirtle or a purple jerkin. But you can fail to mention clothing too. Kathy Reichs had an inadvertently hilarious scene when she had Tempe strip, go to bed nude, get up the next morning, realize that something was wrong, called the CSI's, and stood around as they checked. She had gone to bed the night before nude, right? No mention of her putting on clothes, so I imagined a scene where's she standing around naked, chatting with her colleagues while the investigation was going on. A simple, "I threw on my house robe" would have done, but then, I wouldn't have chuckled for half a day after reading that scene.
435 2017-08-09 01:40:21
Re: Contest Winners Announced (23 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)
Congratulations Seebrass, Marilyn, and Graymartin! A job well done. Oh, I'm afraid, Seabrass, that I make the same mistake. I keep track of those who review my stuff for my C4C, and yep, there you are--Seabass. lol But congratulations all around to everyone!
436 2017-08-07 23:33:15
Re: The agony of waiting for acceptance or rejection (21 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)
Hey, Doug. Thanks for the warning on the ProWritingAid. Some times, the old-fashioned way (doing it yourself) is the best. As to time paradoxes, tell me about it. The characters are also concerned and fear they might lose their minds tracking their own comings and goings. I put in the latest astrophysicist theory that there are fourteen constants that have to be in exact relationship for life to exist. Try a factorial analysis of that, it's a 1 in a lot of zeros possibility for us to exist. So have a time traveler tramp around and if he changes the littlest thing the smallest way, and...
There is also the possibility of backward causation, and you bringing about the very thing you were trying to avoid (like Skynet bringing about John Connor's mother meeting his father, and...).
437 2017-08-07 22:41:33
Re: The agony of waiting for acceptance or rejection (21 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)
Doug: Inspired by your story, I submitted to Fiery Seas. I did do a little research on them, and as there was some possible scandal in their past, I was particularly interested in the review by one of their published authors, which was favorable. So far, it's been over thirty minutes since I received my 'thank you and we are looking forward to reading your manuscript,' so your record is intact. Dagnee, you gave me hope when you said the ones they accept have blurbs that show logistical nightmares. Mine is a mystery/time travel story, and by the time I was done with the first draft, my tenses were all messed up. It's hard to keep track of characters who arrive in places before they do and have to kidnap their younger selves. It's just to see what their response is, as the manuscript has only gone through my first review to take out obvious structural errors, make the pieces, written separately, fit together, punch up the dialogue, make sure the sentences are in logical order, that sort of thing. The confirmation letter said it will take ten to twelve weeks before a decision. It might even be worth publishing by then. lol Good luck with your other submissions.
438 2017-08-06 16:59:07
Re: WIP Rhiannon the Nude, Vol 2: New Fairy by Rhiannon (123 replies, posted in Close friends)
OK, folks. I have a dilemma. I've sent Book II off to a publisher; rather than wait for the yea or nay, increasingly aware of all the flaws, scenes I would have done better, sentence reorganization needed, etc., I wrote Book IV. (That was last week's project; don't know what will happen this week. lol). Book IV is a murder mystery, and I think a rather good one. I'd like to get your comments, but if I do, it will spoil the ending of Book III. Before you reply, 'that sucks,' Book III has the following in common with Dorothy Sayer's "Busman's Honeymoon," in that it is full of description and the relationships, and the part of the ending that overlaps with Book IV, although providing the organization of the book, is a relatively secondary part. Book IV fairly well ends the tetralogy, but not the Rhiannon saga. Norm is right, the motive force of the stories is friendship in the most exotic of circumstances. The characters are what is going to motivate the reader to move on to the next. There will be more Rhiannon stories. But the saga that began with her being sent to New Dyved to marry King Ferrell and ends with (now, *that* would definitely be telling) is over in Book IV. Book I through IV is actually one long (1600 pages) novel split into four parts. So what do you think? Should I post it and get your feedback, or just edit it myself for a while, until most of you have gotten to the end of Book III? I suppose I can always send it to Fiery Seas; things often happen backwards for me. If everyone else sends a polished manuscript to Fiery Seas and gets a rejection in nine minutes, I could send a rough manuscript and get acceptance. And heck, I've had nine-minute encounters that have been extremely pleasant. I await what you suggest.
439 2017-08-05 01:25:25
Re: The agony of waiting for acceptance or rejection (21 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)
When I was seeking work in philosophy, I'd get my share of rejections (and acceptances). One employer rejected me. Both the university and I forgot I applied to it, so at the Convention (where the preliminary interviews take place), the university accepted me for the preliminary interview they had rejected me for, and chided me for not applying. Then, I got the rejection letter from them. Oh, well. The rejection letter I will cherish the most was the one that began, "employment decisions are arbitrary, capricious, and subjective. Ours is no exception. We can't tell you why we rejected you, as you were highly qualified and would have been a fine addition to our faculty. Good luck in finding a suitable position." Like my character, I refrained from writing a reply suggesting they perform an anatomical impossibility. As somebody said, anyone can, in this day and age, form a publishing house. This is the era where ultimately, the readers will decide. I don't always use marketing, but when I do, I use all the master keys and persuasion techniques I can remember. Stay Hungry, my friends.
440 2017-07-31 03:34:27
Re: WIP Rhiannon the Nude, Vol 2: New Fairy by Rhiannon (123 replies, posted in Close friends)
Well, as Norm observed, one of the master keys of my writing is friendship under the most exotic of circumstances. Another key is personal development. We first meet Rhiannon as a superficial girl who wants to fit in with her new friends at court, is interested in fashion, and has a girl's crush on a middle age, exotic, alien marine By the end of Book II she is risking the space-time continuum to protect her country, barking orders. As Gacela observed, she has adult conversations. Book III has her taking command of her life and her kingdom. Book IV, in the second draft, she hasn't really appeared yet--it more showcases Heather and her friends. And the backdrop: a technologically advanced society is exploiting a less advanced one, rationalizing it by thinking they are uplifting it (really making them depended on foreign technology). But the advanced society has destroyed its environment and is merrily doing the same to the new planet. A woman who comes from a more natural society, with magic, not technology, as the means for survival falls for a man from the techno-society. Talk about star-crossed lovers. There is economics involved as well--the Terran exploitation is a blend of neocolonialism and the Great Leap Forward. There's culture clash. The sex in both Book I and Book II is way into the developing plot and is more diversionary than anything else. Not to say it isn't a significant point. And Rhiannon herself is a mixture of 'Everywoman' and Wonder Woman. Glad to have you join the party, John. And that goes for all the close friends here.
441 2017-07-31 01:46:51
Re: WIP Rhiannon the Nude, Vol 2: New Fairy by Rhiannon (123 replies, posted in Close friends)
Well, one thing about Book IV, which takes place right after Book III (nee the second half of Book II), is that it is written from various POV's, although mainly Barbara Carruthers, of all people. She and Heather (young and old) are the main POV's. The narrator is a Dorothy Sawyers style one, I'll call her Rachel. The first book might be the first book, although I've sent the first three chapters of the second book off. The first narrator of any of these stories was Rhiannon, I did so to associate the reader in, make her feel engaged, and it seems to do that. What is interesting from my experience at tNBW is that you can also do that in 3rd person, although not as easily. 3rd person does allow the various POV's. I just noticed how effective that is in the section I just finished. The reader knows who the black, hooded figures are, as she sees them plotting, and know that Heather is not in any real danger from them, but it was still startling and scary (I thought so, at least) when they abruptly burst in on her when she is exhausted and helpless after a tantrum.
I'm also probably going to take out more chatpers from Book II, as one that shows Rhiannon at her heroic best also doesn't advance the plot one bit.
And yes, if I get a publisher and they like it but want it written from various points of view, I will change it. Otherwise, I'm the first reader to please, even though I'm glad you and everyone else are around for the ride.
Hugs.
442 2017-07-29 03:20:09
Re: WIP Rhiannon the Nude, Vol 2: New Fairy by Rhiannon (123 replies, posted in Close friends)
Could be right, Gacela. I was thinking of some continuity, sort of like "Death" in the J.D. Robb series: You know, "Naked in Death," "Famous in Death," "Do Wah Diddy in Death." Back Home? I don't know if that has the punch that "Exile," "Out of Exile" have.
443 2017-07-28 06:35:24
Re: WIP Rhiannon the Nude, Vol 2: New Fairy by Rhiannon (123 replies, posted in Close friends)
OK, given the interest in my Rhiannon series, and given how well "Out of Exile" tested, I'm redubbing it "The Exile Series," and retitling the books accordingly. "The Loves of Rhiannon: Vol. 1 of the Exile Series; "Out of Exile (nee The Sword of Rhiannon) Vol. 2 of the Exile series, and the reorganized third book, "Exile's End," Vol 3 of the Exile series. This is Part iI of The Sword of Rhiannon, with a different beginning, and additional sections to give it a tighter plot structure. A lot of the subplots from before are now distractors, but give a sense of her life, which was their original purpose, there are now three red herrings, and I'm hoping to pull a Sue Grafton, although I won't say in what sense, as that will undermine the project. Enjoy the new format.
444 2017-07-26 03:25:43
Re: Changing Profile Picture (9 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)
Justin, that worked. Thanks. And yours changed too. lol
445 2017-07-26 03:19:41
Re: Changing Profile Picture (9 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)
Thanks, Justin. I"ll try that. Doesn't matter that much. It's not like when the only real life picture I could use was a nude one. A very tasteful nude one, but still...
446 2017-07-25 16:57:18
Re: Another Review for The Kurdish Connection (10 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)
Congratulations, Randy. That's why you're my favorite thriller writer (in fact, my only thriller writer, as I usually don't like that stuff.)
447 2017-07-24 17:43:43
Re: Road of trials (2 replies, posted in Close friends)
I ended up writing the first two books of the Rhiannon series by asking myself, each chapter, what reversal can there be here? The reversals actually determined the plot structure. I took the idea of trials to heart. Less so, the idea that there should be a conflict, even if a minor one irrelevant to the main plot, every four pages. I didn't count the pages, but I kept that count in mind. This is how, when she escapes in the forest, she is in constant struggle, when she finally gets home, she is abandoned by her childhood friend, and ends up in jail. Why she faces an insanity hearing. Why she has to take over the kingdom. Why that results in a civil war. Why she gets betrayed by a former lover. Why...well, you get the idea. lol
448 2017-07-24 17:34:39
Re: WIP Rhiannon the Nude, Vol 2: New Fairy by Rhiannon (123 replies, posted in Close friends)
I'm reorganizing The Sword of Rhiannon. It now ends at chapter 43, with chapter 44 (v. 2), the epilogue, so one ongoing mystery (who is the hooded figure and what does "Beware the Duck" mean) will be partially resolved. (With a hook to the next Part, which sees the full resolution. In Part II, amystery will be emphasized. Now, the emphasis is on Rhiannon's running the kingdom--she deals with prisoners of war, her coronation, and her upcoming marriage. As you can see from the prologue to it, there is trouble ahead. But right now, it reads too much like "A Busman's Honeymoon," which had twenty pages of mystery and 350 of lifestyle. If you do decide to wade into this swamp, please let me know if that bothers you. It will be helpful in the re-write. Another note here. There is the Saga, as I call it. Goes from Book I (the prequel), which goes from Rhiannon's betrothal to the human king Ferrell, to her escape into the forest, to Book II, which goes from where Book I left off to the end of the war. Now, there will be Book III, which starts right after the war, but centers on the mystery of who killed Rhiannon's mother, briefly mentioned in Book II, against the backdrop of the coronation, the marriage, the return of the offworlders. Book IV is more a mystery story, as Modrin's murder remains unsolved by the end of Book III, although, it looks like it's solved. Book V is a mystery that can be read independently of the Saga, as it isn't mentioned when it takes place, although it still might spoil Book IV for you. Never fear, it won't be posted for a long while.
The reason for this reorganization is that a publisher asked me for a synopsis and the first three chapters, but was firm that my book couldn't be more than 120,000 words long. (With Part II, it is over twice that.) They said, "Well, if there's a natural break, just send us the book up to the break." Wish me luck on this, but, as so often happens, publishers are right. These days, a 1,000 word epic doesn't sell. George R.R. Martin may have experienced the same thing, as all his volumes are really parts of a larger book.
449 2017-07-24 01:40:06
Re: Changing Profile Picture (9 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)
This is something like the 3rd time I changed it; don't recall it taking so long the other two times, but then, I don't commit time frames for picture changes to memory. lol
450 2017-07-24 00:24:07
Re: Changing Profile Picture (9 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)
vern, I was afraid of that. Well, I have one, as you may remember. lol