I have a question about how to represent my ghosts in the next draft. Currently, they are a presence in the mind of Joseph and Apollo, and they "radiate" emotions. The ghosts are not physically visible. I had to do that because God currently appears to both Joseph and Apollo. If He were visible and the two versions of Him looked different, then the reader is likely to assume they are not real. However, if both versions of God look the same, then they almost certainly would be real. But, since I'm replacing God with the archangels Michael and Gabriel in the rewrite, I have the option of making all the ghosts visible as if they were real humans travelling with Joseph and Apollo.
This raises a couple of tricky issues. First, when Andrew or Joseph's mother use Joseph's own hand to smack him upside the head, should they temporarily jump inside Joseph and force his hand to act as described, or should I simply have the visible ghost smack Joseph with the ghost's own hand? I'm leaning toward the latter. In Apollo's case, God currently creates in him strong urges to pee at the worst possible times, and I want to keep that. I'm debating whether Apollo's archangel can simply cause the urge without explicitly "jumping" into Apollo long enough to do it.
A big issue is communication. I can't usually have Joseph and Apollo talk out loud to these ghosts when they're around other people, otherwise they'd both be locked up. So communication would generally remain as thoughts. That then begs the question whether the ghosts use their mouths for anything. Should I have the ghosts actually speak, but make it only audible to Joseph and Apollo?
What about the case when Joseph's mother chews out the Imperial guard for not letting Joseph into the palace to see Apollo? In that case, the ghost would probably have to jump inside Joseph to force those words out of his mouth. The other alternative to jumping inside would be for her to tell Joseph exactly what to say and he stupidly obeys, as already happens in a scene in v3 where Joseph and Paul accidentally board the slaver and Joseph tells the ass next to him, "I don't say sorry to an idiot."
Thoughts?
Dirk