3,151

(1,217 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Kdot wrote:

- I agree that Apollo's arc is more dramatic. I'll see if I can further amp up the tension in Joseph's chapter.

I don't believe that's possible within the desired structure. I also don't believe it's warranted. I did not suffer a disconnect between the two stories (Sorry, Amy).

The increased tension seems like a good idea. Most of it is already swirling in my head - the hidden assassin, the homophobic decisions he makes that kill Andrew and his cadets, him truly despising Adam, as opposed to simply being mad at him (boo hoo), etc.

Kdot wrote:

My disconnect, as you know,was Caligula.

He'll get more nuanced screen time (setting up the Caligula chapter), plus he undergoes a miraculous change of behavior after the blast to his head. I want there to be enough clues that something's not right, right up to the reveal. I didn't care for him as a character until I came up with his hidden plot. Now I love him, which is the main reason he survived the battle. I want to do more with him. I could see putting him, Lady Kay, Leonardo, and Aussie in a book on the edge of settled space.

Kdot wrote:

- As I mentioned in my response to Amy, Act II needs work. There isn't enough animosity between the MCs, fur flying, etc. I do have to stop a couple of times in the book to actually allow Joseph to define the Christian Heresy, beginning with the New Commandments, which slows the pace. His thoughts that lead him to unify the Essence, reincarnation, and evolution need trimming, but I think they're more interesting than the commandments.

This is the basic premise of the story. Why are you trimming that part?

No plans to get rid of them. Just expressing a preference for the stuff in Act III. I was thinking of trimming the chapter with the Essence. I crammed in too much stuff. It drags.

Kdot wrote:

. His scheme mirrors that of the Imperium's founder, which is a nice connection. I also needed a chapter from his point of view in order to hide the surprise that Apollo is still alive.

Why hide it?

There are other ways to write it, but there's not much point to the Caligula chapter unless he gets an enemy. Who better than Apollo?

Kdot wrote:

Stage 3:
After the mumbling stage he should start to see furtive mevements from the car of his eye. When he randonly turns to look, people are staring at him quizzically. He's not sure if they're doing it to unnerve him. He finds muddy footprints in his room when he wakes up. Security assures him no one was in there. He starts imagining Aphrodite is cheating on him. He can suddenly no longer write straight - he hires a scribe.

Stage 4:
He starts to worry about poison (specifically of the exploding bowel nature). Hires a tate tester. Hires a second backup tester. Aphrodite grows distant. He thinks it's a conspiracy. He randomly has her arrested and searched for evidence (comes up empty-handed). Good time to throw in an exploding car bomb from the Heresy.

Need more? Amy and Seabrass are also good at this.

Very nice stuff. Is it copyrighted?

Kdot wrote:

S: Joseph needs a burning bush encounter. It's kind of a Judaic staple.

Awesome idea.

3,152

(1,217 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Kdot wrote:

that would be like trying to ignore the sun

The sun? Giver of life?

3,153

(1,217 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Janet, I added "mate" to the chapter, as you suggested. It's hilarious. I only use it once at the end when the AI is pissed off about the lack of respect. It says: Listen, Mate, I've asked you repeatedly to refer to me as Queen Aussie...

3,154

(1,217 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Amy, I left out the smilies in my post. I assumed they were implicit. Sorry about that. I've been emulating Kranky with his unique wit, so let's blame it all on him. :-)

As for God being real or not, I walk a fine line like a staggering drunk. Just when the reader thinks they're real, I do something that makes them sure they aren't. And vice versa. That's intentional since it adds a little fun, I think. One is the things God says whenever the two MCs are together: he says things about the non-POV MC as if he knows things about him that only God could know.

There are a number of other examples scrambled somewhere in my head. For example, when Apollo begins to trust God at the end of Act III, he gets arrested on New Beth. God tells him not to worry because that's exactly what's supposed to happen. Another is when God tells Joseph to volunteer at the haven hospital. He saves Anikh from the fire, only to have her die in his arms, which triggers his decision to create the Christian Heresy. Also, there are the muscle urges that allow Apollo to beat the shogun, as well as the urge to pee and his head jolting. For obvious reasons, there are always other explanations, even if the odds are very slim.

I'll be adding another one in v3. Joseph's God will use some expression regularly and Apollo's God will use it at least once in some obvious place in the story to create a WTF moment.

I've had reviewers tell me they were sure one way or the other about God, which suggests I'm achieving a reasonable balance between the two possibilities.

Again, sorry for the missing smilies. :-) :-) :-) :-) :-)

3,155

(1,217 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

So, Australia goes for Windsor. You do realize, Janet, that I named her after the Queen, don't you? Windsor-Mountbatten, I believe is the correct spelling.

3,156

(1,217 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Kdot wrote:

Sounds like a bit of excessive force

Huh?

3,157

(1,217 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Group Think:

What do you think of my putting Admiral Windsor in Joseph's head (he's her grandson) for the whole story? Her appearance in chapter two, having just died in chapter one, would strongly suggest to the reader that she is real (in storytime, it's actually 11 years after her death, which I'll mention). Windsor is one of several ties to chapter one (Lupus and Aussie being the others). Naturally, I'll include the bit about mental illness, so there will still be some doubt from chapter two onward, just less so.

I'd have to reduce God's role in Joseph's half of the story. It also means the admiral would be the one to give Joseph his spine, rather than his deceased mother. The mother would die and disappear, so there would be no happy appearance by the mother in his head to assuage his guilt.

Similarly, Emperor Nero will appear in Apollo's head once Nero dies, but not until the end of act II.

Thoughts?

Sol, I was wondering if you plan to update the print function in the chapter view. It's missing the closing comments and the author's reply. I'm using Google's print function as a workaround.

3,159

(1,217 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

Janet (AJ) Reid wrote:

How many words Dirk?

4500

3,160

(1,217 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic & Sci-Fi)

amy s wrote:

I really like the sympathetic pain thing, BTW. That is an awesome complication for both MC's.
A

Now you tell me, when I've written a complete draft? <insert grumble>

Six months ago, you had kittens because there was too much of a link between their lives, meaning that God must have been real:
- They both hear God when they are young (though not at the same age/year).
- In v3, Apollo will hear multiple (2) voices in his head, just like Joseph does (3).
- Young kid dies at the same time in both their lives (Andrew and William); William will be Apollo's best friend in v3 to create more anger/hatred in Apollo.
- They were both deeply affected by the first attack on New Bethlehem, causing each to accept their destinies.
- Things keep happening in Act II where God comments in such a way that strongly suggests he knows about/is the other God.
- Joseph accidentally kills his mother; right after that Apollo's father is killed.
- The shogun appears in both their lives, abusing each MC.
- Apollo is almost killed by Lupus; Joseph is almost killed by the shogun.
- They both leave Earth at the same time.

Nevertheless, your point is well taken. I haven't causally linked the two MC's events. It's two stories that only coincide in Acts 2 and 4. However, the sympathetic pain between them doesn't seem possible, since that definitely demonstrates God is real, doesn't it?

3,161

(1,217 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic &amp; Sci-Fi)

Quick poll. Is it okay that my opening chapter is 18 double-spaced pages (roughly 3.0 points)? I usually try to keep my chapters between 10 and 15. It grew by a couple of pages because of the return of the loony AI. I'm not finding much to trim. And no, K, I'm not ripping out the AI again. It's a recurring character.

3,162

(1,217 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic &amp; Sci-Fi)

Janet (AJ) Reid wrote:

I've left additional comments on your replies Dirk. I ignored K of course! tongue

Thanks, Janet.

3,163

(2 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Thanks, Don.

3,164

(1,217 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic &amp; Sci-Fi)

I already wrote the cameos for Amy (Dr. Ess) and njc (the Professor and founder of Acmy, Inc.). They'll both appear in Act I.

Thanks for the review, Your Majesty, Aussie Reid. Just think, you almost became Jangaroo, but it was a little too silly for the battle.

3,165

(1,634 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

LMAO (apologies for all the cursing)

3,166

(1,634 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

WTF?

3,167

(2 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Hi. Can someone please tell me if there is a way to hide an entire book (not just the chapters) without losing the book and all of the associated chapter reviews. I can't afford to lose those.

Thanks.
Dirk

3,168

(354 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic &amp; Sci-Fi)

Try these two name generators:
http://fantasynamegenerators.com
http://www.behindthename.com/

3,169

(23 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

It works again.

Thank you.
Dirk

3,170

(4 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

murderers, not murders. Hope you caught that before going to print. :-)

3,171

(1,634 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Huh? (That's the first word that came to mind.) :-)

3,172

(23 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

The default browser in Android is still blocking access (9 PM ET).

3,173

(1,217 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic &amp; Sci-Fi)

Okay, on to Kdot's post. Same disclaimer as with Amy. What follows is mostly planning. Not all of it is in stone yet, otherwise I wouldn't have asked the questions.

- I'm not surprised that you think Joseph is ambling along. He's caught up in a whirlwind that tosses him from one place to another (cadet massacre, Central Haven riot, slavery, prison, battle, etc.). However, he believes it's all part of God's plan and doesn't question how insane his actions are until his crisis of faith.
- Apollo scheming? Apollo is also caught up in events beyond his crontrol. In his case, he's fighting God every step of the way, and the more he does, the more he fails. Only when he grows a pair and follows God is he able to gain control.
- I agree that Apollo's arc is more dramatic. I'll see if I can further amp up the tension in Joseph's chapter.
- As I mentioned in my response to Amy, Act II needs work. There isn't enough animosity between the MCs, fur flying, etc. I do have to stop a couple of times in the book to actually allow Joseph to define the Christian Heresy, beginning with the New Commandments, which slows the pace. His thoughts that lead him to unify the Essence, reincarnation, and evolution need trimming, but I think they're more interesting than the commandments.
- Is the end of Act II the neutral phase you refer to? If so, I'm confused, because that's where both the queen and emperor die. Most of Act II drags, except for the deaths at the end. Acts I & II need quite a bit of rewriting.
- The introduction of a smart, scheming Caligula was too good to pass up. His scheme mirrors that of the Imperium's founder, which is a nice connection. I also needed a chapter from his point of view in order to hide the surprise that Apollo is still alive. It also served as a place to flesh out battle chess, which first appears in v6 of chapter one. It will also come up during Nero's sham invasion of New Bethlehem.
- Joseph's descent into madness continues throughout Act III, so I assume you refer to where Apollo stops fighting God. That change to him relying on God should be more gradual. Will fix.
- I'll need to keep the animosity going between the two MCs.
- The madness for Joseph continues right until the finale. Joseph still hears God, although I could bring up a conversatiion between Apollo and God in the finale, although the main conversation between Apollo and God has already happened (God led Apollo to the decision to conquer the galaxy, but through colonization, not violence). Kind of weak reasoning. I'll have to think about that.
- The cult will truly go nowhere in book one. I've decided that in v3 he has at best a few followers, which is why he assumes the role of Messiah.
- The world that got blown up included scenes in palace, the senate, the parade ground, the church/graveyard, and the havens. Amy had me rip out a nice short description of the world's rings and moons, which I'll be putting back in.
- I'll have to think about your suggestions for the battle chapters. The new Caligula would never run from a fight. And he has the (lukewarm) support of the governors and the fleet, so he needs to be gone to trigger the cascade of defecting governors declaring for Apollo. If you recall, the battle began with Apollo+Realm vs. Caligula+Imperium, then morphed into Apollo+Realm vs. Lupus+Imperium, then Apollo+Imperium vs. Lupus+Imperium, then Joseph+marines vs. Lupus+classiarii, ending with Joseph+Realm + Apollo+Imperium.
- I don't see any way to bring the Christian Heresy into play in book I, since it takes more than a week to build up millions of followers (unless you're Pokemon). Plus, Joseph failing miserably with his religion adds to his sense of failure, hence the reason he declares himself the Messiah. The timeline within the books will be about four years apart, so 4017, 4021, and 4025. The Christian Heresy will catch on in a big way and will go head-to-head with Apollo's new empire.
- Personally, I found the lightsaber duel with Palpatine very enjoyable, were it not for the fact that Yoda looks CGI. The emperor hurling pods down at Yoda and cackling was fun. And who doesn't love Force lightning? The stupid leaping about by the CGI Yoda was a bore. I digress...
- I don't understand your suggestion that I was shelving Apollo. Caligula gets his chapter, then Apollo, then Joseph (with Apollo's revival within it). The post-battle is also Apollo's chapter.
- I agree that Apollo should continue to fear discovery, although it's going to get tedious at some point. There's only so many ways I can shake an arm. Amy's idea of having them mumble their dialogue with God is a good one. I also think I'm going to change Apollo's illness a little from Trembler's Disease to something a little more flexible. I was thinking once his trembling arm is amputated, he might start to laugh at inappropriate times. Or neck twitches. He'll also be a drug addict in v3 because that's the only known way to manage for his disease.
- There will be more to Caligula in the next draft as I mentioned in my response to Amy.

Thanks again for your detailed summary.
Dirk

3,174

(42 replies, posted in Fantasy/Magic &amp; Sci-Fi)

Except on Fridays. We used to get fish on Frdays in summer camp. It was a Catholic thing, although the camp wasn't.
And all stores were closed on Sundays. Day of rest, etc.

Boy the way that Miller played,
Songs that made the hit parade,
Guys like us we had it made,
those were the days.

3,175

(1,634 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Einstein–Rosen bridge