101

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

Mine is culture, and the sense that culture shapes everything.  The sorcery-tech is easy to introduce, by comparison.

102

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

@Janet: Nay... you're still ahead of me in reviews. I've just been buried with work (boo! hiss!) and can't read as much as I'd like

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

njc wrote:

I'm trying to introduce a lot of background stuff so that it doesn't feel like asspull.

This has officially been bookmarked and I will continue to cross my fingers, hoping none of these fantastic terms ever apply to my work. wink

Janet, take your time. I'm rewriting my beginning chapters, anyhow.

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

njc wrote:

Janet, you can start at B1 Ch20.  There's a lot to rework, but a lot that should come through.  There will be a lot of resequencing between the threads, and I haven't changed the spelling of Mamma's name yet in most of them.

B1 CH20 - on it like a bad rash once my chapter is up (not tonight, though, it's me and the American tax system at the moment - I'll tell you about all the fun I'm having, but I'm trying to stop swearing).

njc wrote:

I'm trying to introduce a lot of background stuff so that it doesn't feel like asspull.

You say this as if it's a bad thing! tongue

kdot wrote:

@Janet: Nay... you're still ahead of me in reviews. I've just been buried with work (boo! hiss!) and can't read as much as I'd like

I feel your pain! Work always interferes sad

Elisheva Free wrote:

Janet, take your time. I'm rewriting my beginning chapters, anyhow.

I'm so going to try and keep up this time! smile

It will help heaps if you could write slower?! <---- just kidding of course! big_smile

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

Janet wrote:

it's me and the American tax system at the moment - I'll tell you about all the fun I'm having, but I'm trying to stop swearing

It could be worse. As far as I can tell, if I want my disability benefits to continue, I have to let the IRS tax me as a resident of the U.S. even though I'm now living in Canada. That means two "resident" tax returns every year until I flatline. It wouldn't be so bad, except you have to declare all of your foreign accounts to each taxing authority every year, with fines that can bankrupt you, even for honest mistakes. So I have to tell Canada about all of my U.S. accounts, and I have to tell the IRS about my Canadian accounts, even though both idiotic organizations get this information electronically from the banks in both countries. Futuo!

106

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

And you wonder why we want to rip up the income tax system?  I'm not sure it's a comfort, but it's ten times worse for businesses, who often have to pay tax on money they haven't received.

Ever wonder why game shows that give away merchandise always give some cash with the jackpot prizes?  It's because the IRS has to be paid, and that 'spending money for your trip!' is there so you'll be able to pay it and collect your prizes.

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

Janet (AJ) Reid wrote:

It will help heaps if you could write slower?! <---- just kidding of course! big_smile

Ack! I honestly feel like I'm writing far too slowly. tongue I just had a fantastic plot idea on my commute home today, but it means some serious renovations to the Dragon chapters. There is now a war going on in my head as I try to convince myself that the effort will be worth it and contemplate which pieces of the current chapters I can keep. Brain... hurts...

Of course, it doesn't help that I've been working the past 9 days straight. One more day and I finally get my four-day weekend! ...which will likely be spent catching up on sleep, laundry, groceries, babysitting, and hopefully writing.

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

Elisheva, consider deferring retrofits until your next whole draft. I tried going back to keep the beginning of my story up to date but found it impossible the further along I got in the book. The way I do it now is to treat all future chapters as if the change had been made. I then add a chapter note that an important continuity change has been made and describe it briefly. For example, Caligula's secret scheme will require changes across numerous early chapters. I've also made changes that I subsequently refined or even punted without having to go back and fix the whole book.

109

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

I agree. Don't lose the momentum. When I started on this site, the initial chapters were SO bad. I revised them once but then needed to revise again as my learning curve improved. I ended up duplicating work.

Just plow ahead with your work. Get the story out of your head. Then go back to revise at the end.

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

-twitch, twitch-

Eek! Well, in that case, I still need to reorganize it so I know where things are supposed to be. So close to the weekend... so close...

111

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

Alternate new chapters with revisions, then

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

Sometimes the change is so big though that it's just better to start over. Yep, that's me. But so we learn and hopefully don't repeat the same mistakes.

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

njc wrote:

Alternate new chapters with revisions, then

Pfft! A far too logical approach. tongue Honestly, this seems like a good plan. Then I won't completely lose momentum and I might not pull my hair out revising recently revised revisions.

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

Norm d'Plume wrote:
Janet wrote:

it's me and the American tax system at the moment - I'll tell you about all the fun I'm having, but I'm trying to stop swearing

It could be worse. As far as I can tell, if I want my disability benefits to continue, I have to let the IRS tax me as a resident of the U.S. even though I'm now living in Canada. That means two "resident" tax returns every year until I flatline. It wouldn't be so bad, except you have to declare all of your foreign accounts to each taxing authority every year, with fines that can bankrupt you, even for honest mistakes. So I have to tell Canada about all of my U.S. accounts, and I have to tell the IRS about my Canadian accounts, even though both idiotic organizations get this information electronically from the banks in both countries. Futuo!

We're setting ourselves up to ensure that when we leave, we'll be cutting all ties. No property, no 401k, no investments, no anything.

njc wrote:

And you wonder why we want to rip up the income tax system?  I'm not sure it's a comfort, but it's ten times worse for businesses, who often have to pay tax on money they haven't received.

Ever wonder why game shows that give away merchandise always give some cash with the jackpot prizes?  It's because the IRS has to be paid, and that 'spending money for your trip!' is there so you'll be able to pay it and collect your prizes.

I have no idea why anyone would start a business in the US to be honest. The booklet explaining personal income tax is almost 1000 pages, so I can't imagine what the business version looks like. This is batshit nuts.

115 (edited by amy s 2016-06-23 08:27:29)

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

Have you found an accountant or are you navigating this yourself? Oh, you poor thing. I'm sorry this is getting so irritating.

Let yourself fall into your book and write a section where C and M have a rip-roaring fight. Then you get to write the make-up sex :-)  You go girl!

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

amy s wrote:

Have you found an accountant or are you navigating this yourself? Oh, you poor thing. I'm sorry this is getting so irritating.

Let yourself fall into your book and write a section where C and M have a rip-roaring fight. Then you get to write the make-up sex :-)  You go girl!

I think I mentioned before, but DO NOT forget to file FBAR/FATCA forms by the end of the month.Nasty nasty nasty forms.

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

amy s wrote:

Have you found an accountant or are you navigating this yourself? Oh, you poor thing. I'm sorry this is getting so irritating.

Let yourself fall into your book and write a section where C and M have a rip-roaring fight. Then you get to write the make-up sex :-)  You go girl!

Part of my relocation that an accountant will do it and the company will pay the cost. Next one is on us if we can't figure it out on our own.

Norm d'Plume wrote:

I think I mentioned before, but DO NOT forget to file FBAR/FATCA forms by the end of the month.Nasty nasty nasty forms.

These are done, FBAR forms have been submitted. Thank you for all your advice and checking my back! I owe you one gallon of your favourite poison!

As for my writing, work isn't helping. I just need to self-check my chapter and incorporate the changes and then I can post it, but I'm dog tired. Hoping tomorrow I'll get to it!

118

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

Janet (AJ) Reid wrote:

I have no idea why anyone would start a business in the US to be honest. The booklet explaining personal income tax is almost 1000 pages, so I can't imagine what the business version looks like. This is batshit nuts.

Batshit is sane and rational compared to the US tax code.

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

njc wrote:
Janet (AJ) Reid wrote:

I have no idea why anyone would start a business in the US to be honest. The booklet explaining personal income tax is almost 1000 pages, so I can't imagine what the business version looks like. This is batshit nuts.

Batshit is sane and rational compared to the US tax code.

Can't agree more!

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

Next chapter is up! This weekend it's going to be me and catching up with all the reviews I owe everyone. smile

121

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

Janet, is this your first 4th of July? I'm looking forward to your impressions of the chaos. Or are you going to miss it because you are in Canada?

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

amy s wrote:

Janet, is this your first 4th of July? I'm looking forward to your impressions of the chaos. Or are you going to miss it because you are in Canada?

Second 4th of July. So far a few odd instances where people are just shooting fireworks for the hell of it, but last year was more look and see. I'm not sure we'll be going to any celebrations this year, but it would be a good experience. I'm 5 miles south of the Canadian border, so still on US soil! No Canada. smile

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

Based on a review, I'm thinking about altering Peter's motivation just a tiny bit. He's reason for not killing Catherine was questioned, and I have to agree, it doesn't make a lot of sense. So the change I'm considering will have him actively trying to get rid of her for her interference the night of the failed raid as well as for supporting Matthew, and specifically for proposing the idea of having a fair with a archer comp. I have a way to make it work - instead of leaving to leave, he'll just be 'leaving' to get his crossbow - I'll also clarify his preference is to kill people from afar and not so much with his own hands (sword/dagger) unless he HAS too.

Any thoughts?

Also, njc, I've left a few replies on your review. Couple of questions to try and understand your thoughts better. Thanks for all your support!

124

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

Peter's belief in his moral superiority as a leader and a Lord is contradicted by events.  Matthew has earned loyalty.  We see him earn the loyalty of Anthony (and it would be good to see Anthony risk his life for Matthew after that humiliation) as well as the loyalty of the common boy he interrogated, then took in.

Peter, on the other hand, cannot earn loyalty and fails when he tries to buy it.  He destroys his tools.  Even if Peter does not consciously recognize the contradiction between his jealous assessment of Matthew's character and the Matthew he is fighting, his inability to fight on level ground with Matthew must rankle at every turn--and he must be evading and hiding from the measures of character.

I think if you keep this in mind, you won't need to add any additional seasoning.  Jealously becomes the deadly sin of Envy, and that progresses to raging, irrational anger.  Just let us see that, in microcosm, and let us see how Peter uses the Anger to defend against the truth.

If you can't have Anthony strike the killing blow, can you show Isaac (is that the name) risking his life in loyalty, and, injured, still showing more concern for Matthew?

Death by sepsis for Peter would open the door for more character moments between your other characters.  It would let him rage a bit in nominally lucid moments.  And, in the end, he might slink away to die, to 'escape', leaving Matthew to drive away the animals feeding on him, in order to give him a decent burial. (Driving an animal from its meal can sometimes only be done by killing it.)

Re: NorthernSkies or NS - Janet

Interesting given that Peter has said gaining the title is a side-benefit, i.e. it's not his aim/end-goal - he simply sees Matthew unfit and anyone but Matthew will do pretty much. Peter has also never thought or mentioned that he thinks he is better than Matthew at all. And to some extent he has forgotten in the whole process he's going to have to fill those shoes. But adding that Peter thinks he will be better than Matthew won't hurt either.

Not sure if you can remember, but Matthew is actually struggling with this exact same problem, just before Geordie's funeral in the family's burial vault there was a scene where he was questioning whether he deserves the title and are doing his parents/brother proud. It's been a while since I wrote the scene where he and Catherine were talking about growing up - but I'm pretty sure that Catherine has noticed the growth in Matthew over the years she didn't see him. Matthew still needs convincing though that he is worthy (and I might need to do something that helps him along the way, because Catherine herself won't be able to convince him probably) whereas Peter is a lost case still stuck in the past.

You make interesting suggestions I haven't considered. I'm against a tight deadline to get Matthew and Catherine married before everyone else knows she's pregnant which complicates things but I'll definitely keep it mind. Not sure, but having animals feed of Peter's corpse might also get really dark for Romance!

Once Peter is taken care of, this will be the next play and then the dreaded 'standard issue' Romance trope where the MC's go their separate way before they end up together for ever after. And then it's on to the next book finding Black John a wife and giving the scullery maid a central role for a change instead of just being a background character to make readers hate a noble lord.