1) There are a lot of repeat words now that you are adding more adjectives and going over the same thing for elaboration. You need to get used to using synonyms. Ex: A sorcerer might be a close friend, but never a close neighbor...At the Academy, she and Caneth had many friends-(friend)
I'll go with Strunk and White (unbowdlerized) on this one
Another example: By reflex, she windmilled her arms for balance. By reflex, she used control of the Elements (by reflex).
The problem is not the repetition of the word, but its use without a strong frapping to create the unity that I'm trying for.
2) Avoid using the word 'it' whenever possible.
Above you don't want me to repeat a word, now you deny me pronouns? I'm guessing you're inveighing against constructions like 'it was his good fortune that ...'
3) Incomplete sentences due to fragmented revision. Ex: They had traveled and adventure awaited the traveling sorcerer. (note this also repeats travel in the same sentence)
The sentence is quite complete, but a comma or semicolon after the conjunction would make the parse clearer. The second use of a part of 'travel' gives purpose to, and fulfills, the first use.
4) Order issues. I believe these would shake out with more revision. Here is a big one. Even late bloomers like Melayne had male friends. Friendship led to interest. Later, interest led to friendship (First she has male friends. Then she has interested males. Then she has friendship. Huh?)
The logic is clear. Before Melayne blossomed, friendship preceeded interest. After she blossomed, interest preceeded friendship. The inversion is important, not contradictory.
Okay, it's not clear enough.
5) Logic issues: A sorcerer might be a close friend, but never a close neighbor. (They are essentially home-schooling Merran in a remote area with few sorcerers, surrounding her with normal people who respect/ fear their abilities. Logically, Merran would have few friends, yet Melanyne hopes for this to just happen. Then she says later, With no society to mingle in, Merran had no chance to find her own circle of friends. When she bloomed as a woman, she would have no experience to draw on. (What you are telling us is that Merran is stunted by her home and abilities, and has had few if any friends. Give a reason why this isolation is needed. The Academy isn't being set up as a trouble spot. Make it clear that Merran is better off with few friends than going to that hole. Start parcelling out clues. This is where you hook someone with curiosity. Ex: Rapunzel wouldn't work if you kept Mother Gothel a secret from the reader for forty chapters and just had Rapunzel living the day-to-day. If you're going to bring up the Academy, then by golly BRING IT UP!)
Needed? It's not an existential or ontological necessity. It was an unforseen consequence, and one that they've delayed dealing with.
I can guide the reader better to that point.
And the backstory can unfold. You don't tell us about the Mage Master in you first chapter, and when you mention the Age of Magic you don't give us the full history right away.
6) adding 'her' as an extra word when not needed. Ex: Her hair worked loose as she straightened up and she pulled the rag off it to be sure the knots were tight. Her hair fell halfway down her back, a bit darker than her daughter's but still shiny without sorcery. Possible revision: Her hair worked loose as she straightened up, pulling the rag off (eliminate it) to be sure the knots were tight. (Synonym to avoid repeat) The whole mess fell halfway down her back...
First example possible. As to the second, Melayne's hair is not a mess, not in whole, not in part! (There, how's that for repetition?)
7) If Merran were here instead of practicing, she'd be asking why they were fooling around with vinegar instead of finding a spell for the job. (Add a clarifier here. This was a sign of her daughter's inexperience.)
What, I'm not showing it with the tender boiled laundry?
8) LOTS of 'was' added to your verbage. Ex: Someone was moving (moved) out front.
Eowne was falling (fell) against a wall and buckling.
First example, maybe. Second example, no. It announces a sudden change and contrast in the (perceived) speed of the action.
You and I will probably disagree on this for a long time.
9) Gone ... Barris ... Caneth ... they're gone ... dau-COUGH-ghter." She looked past the standing brick Hearth, past the charcoal bins (I dispute that Eowyne would know this. She is concussed, reeling from the explosion, and then the air was full of ash. All she knows is 'where is my baby? He's sick!)
If she trusts what she saw about her son, she has to trust what she saw with the others who were there. That was the last thing she saw before the air turned to mud.
I should probably have her describe it. She didn't hit her head against the wall, by the way. She slumped down as she watched in horror.
This continues to improve. You writing isn't static and the kitchen scene does a good job of setting the stage instead of leaving a blank curtain for me to guess about the surroundings. You explain that Merran was wearing house shoes (or mocasins) and is feeling the rocks through her soles. I didn't get that before.
You are relaying Melayne better. I have a better sense of her size, appearance, and disposition. Her training matches her upbringing. Now start adding this to Merran and Jamen. Ex: Most sorcerers wear those bracelets. You and your father don't. (Jamen knows exactly four sorcerers. Goran, Melayne, her husband, and Merran. Three of four wear the bracelets. Correct these little details because Jamen doesn't see bunches of sorcerers travelling through this hick town)
You are doing better on power descriptions, clarifying how Fire works in this world and letting us know what happens around Melayne as she puts out the chaos.
I'm still spending 8 words where I should spend five.
Oh, Jamen has come in contact with other sorcerers. He's not that isolated. Compared to Merran, he's practically cosmopolitan.