Hi Rhiannon, it's not clear exactly what you mean. You mean an extra description or something that seems superfluous but is really important to the story? I guess I've had people wonder about a certain phrase or character who seems unimportant to the story but does play a role later on. Although I wonder if this is a positive. I kind've feel the reader should be kept guessing about some things but never purposely made to skip over important descriptions of characters.

I generally review at least one person every 20 days according to the schedule although I try to do more. I don't always post about a completed review in this forum just because I'm short of time. I think as long as someone is staying active and adhering to a reasonable schedule (once every 20 days seems reasonable) I'm okay. Just my opinion.

I think your suggestion is also fine Jube. If anyone has time pressure and needs a quick read, let me know and I'm happy to quickly go through.

It was pretty awesome! I have to give Elon Musk credit for pulling this off. Much more impressive than his car in my opinion.

The current belief is that the universe will expand until all energy runs out and the universe is a cold, black place. From what I have read, dark matter is the material which is pulling the universe apart.

Congratulations! I have to say you put a lot of time and effort into the book because each version you posted kept getting better and better. Now you are inspiring me to work faster on finishing up my book.

56

(4 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

After over ten years of writing, one false finish, and many wrong turns, I have finally finished my book State of Vengeance. When I started it in 2003, I never  thought it would take so long. So, I can kick back, enjoy the moment, and then start going through all of the comments you have left and begin editing the final version. Thanks for listening to my personal victory.

Good points. Characters are the heart of the story. I do think that plot is the brain. I like both in my stories. The best books take interesting characters and put them in challenging circumstances.

I have posted an update on completed reviews in some time but yesterday I did a review of Suin's book, chapter 1.

Yes, in Lord Foul's Bane, author Stephen Donaldson has his MC, Thomas Covenant, sort of go with the flow of the new world he finds himself in for quite a while reacting to events as they unfold.

Yes, but realize that Covenant entering this new world and finding himself worshipped is a major event. This is what propels the story at the beginning. Just not sure you need all of the character interaction you have developed in the first six chapter. This is obviously just my opinion. I do tend to favor fast starts. I just want to be helpful.

Funny you mention Lord Foul's Bane and Shannara. Two of my favorites. It's been awhile since I read either so need to go back. In case of Lord Foul though we were pulled in very quickly by this leperous guy who is magically teleported into another land where he is considered a hero because of his ring. He then goes on to rape the woman if I remember correctly. This is tue point at which the story takes off. I think you need something significant to grab rhe reader. Some inflecrion point. It has to happen soon in my opinion if not sooner.

Sorry for typos, am on my phone.

Thanks! This will be helpful. I believe of you have two independent clauses without a coordinating conjunction this is when you use semicolon.

I spoke to Suin and she is excited to join. I will send the link to the group so she can apply.

How about Suin as a new member? He/She writers and reviews well. I'd be happy to reach out. There's also another member d a reynolds who I think might be a good addition.

Hi Jube,

I wanted to respond to your review response comment regarding the narrative voice in Chapter 3. In general, I found the shift in POV to be something that I didn't like. But I didn't comment on it because you specifically said you were going to shift POVs. I know a lot of authors like to do it and it's a stylistic preference. Once I got over the fact you were going to head hop, I really didn't have a problem with each character voicing their thoughts. What is the alternative? A narrative in which each character's thoughts aren't explored? That seems pretty sterile.

I may be thinking about this the wrong way though since I generally don't write multi-character POVs within a chapter.

- C

Completed a review of CJ's Raven's Curse, I believe chapter 4.

67

(0 replies, posted in Alpha to Omega - Review Group)

I got pretty busy towards the end of last year but have a bit more time now so I'll be back to reviewing. Apologies to those I owe.

Chapter 2, Aloha Spirit by Ann Walters.

69

(2 replies, posted in Alpha to Omega - Review Group)

I just wanted to thank Jube for taking the time and effort to put this group together. I'm enjoying it so far. Thank you.

It shows that the group does not pay points. Did it ever?

The way I understand the system is that even if the group is not points, as long as the book is posted to a group that pays points, it will still pay it.

71

(3 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Welcome back!

72

(6 replies, posted in TheNextBigWriter Premium)

Cool site! Congrats.

Seems to me that the community is fine. People came and went from the old site all of the time also. I think issues with the forums are vastly overblown. If you want to post something, there are plenty of places to do it. Some people are getting tied up in the changes to the site when the functionality is the same, or even better. On the old site, you needed to go to a totally separate tab to view the forum, here it is on the homepage. Now if I want to send someone a private message, I can. If I want to communiate with a broader group, I can.

I realize some people define community as having every communication and conversation out in the open where all can see. I think this was more a limitation of the old site than a benefit. The site has matured. Not everyone likes it. Oh well, when did everyone like a change?

Isn't it the same five people talking about forums all of the time?

Completed a review of Randall's revised Chapter 1.