Re: Wishlist Cont.

njc wrote:

Now there's another possibility: a field for the author's requests to reviewers, which will appear over the review buttons and at the top of the review page.

That's what the chapter notes are for. If people aren't even reading those, another text field isn't likely to help much.

In general, I hope we don't keep adding review-related buttons to the top. There are already five buttons up there. Sol has to support tablets and handhelds too, so space is at a premium. He expanded chapter notes specifically so people wouldn't skip it. If they do, you can ask the reviewers in your replies to start reading them. That's what I did and the problem went away.

If we do need more review-related buttons, I suggested changing the existing Leave Inline Review button to a Go to Reviews button at the top, and have that jump to the start of the reviews further down the page. From there, it's just one more click on the existing buttons to leave either an inline or regular review. It's more consistent and we can then group any new review-related buttons directly above the reviews.

Full disclosure: I'm hoping for a Bottom button at the top of that page to jump to the tail end of the reviews. Then I don't have to keep scrolling all the way down to see the latest reviews. I can scroll up. Any long page, like forum threads, should also have that. My joints are too old to constantly scroll from the top of long pages when I really want to be at the bottom.

Thanks
Dirk

152

Re: Wishlist Cont.

Not a request, a question: Does the new site have the 5,000 word/chapter limit?

Re: Wishlist Cont.

njc wrote:

Not a request, a question: Does the new site have the 5,000 word/chapter limit?

No

Re: Wishlist Cont.

As Temple said, NO, njc.

155

Re: Wishlist Cont.

Thanks.

Re: Wishlist Cont.

Norm d'Plume wrote:
njc wrote:

Now there's another possibility: a field for the author's requests to reviewers, which will appear over the review buttons and at the top of the review page.

That's what the chapter notes are for. If people aren't even reading those, another text field isn't likely to help much.

In general, I hope we don't keep adding review-related buttons to the top. There are already five buttons up there. Sol has to support tablets and handhelds too, so space is at a premium. He expanded chapter notes specifically so people wouldn't skip it. If they do, you can ask the reviewers in your replies to start reading them. That's what I did and the problem went away.

If we do need more review-related buttons, I suggested changing the existing Leave Inline Review button to a Go to Reviews button at the top, and have that jump to the start of the reviews further down the page. From there, it's just one more click on the existing buttons to leave either an inline or regular review. It's more consistent and we can then group any new review-related buttons directly above the reviews.

Full disclosure: I'm hoping for a Bottom button at the top of that page to jump to the tail end of the reviews. Then I don't have to keep scrolling all the way down to see the latest reviews. I can scroll up. Any long page, like forum threads, should also have that. My joints are too old to constantly scroll from the top of long pages when I really want to be at the bottom.

Thanks
Dirk

This! Great suggestions that also keep other limitations in mind. This will solve most of the navigation "issues" for me too.

Re: Wishlist Cont.

Sol, I was wondering what the ETA is for being able to jump to the next unread chapter of someone's book. Ideally, any time we click on someone's book, it should default the chapter in the posting view to the one we should read next. If you also make it possible to jump directly from the Regular Reviews Posted and Inline Reviews Posted tabs, that would cut down significantly on clicks/scrolls.

I'm not sure about anyone else, but I rely on those two tabs to tell me where I left off reviewing someone else's work. Currently I go to the two tabs, find where I left off, click on the author's name, find the book, click on it, then use the chapter selector to go to the next chapter, and then I'm ready to review. All that could be reduced to one click.

If there's currently a better way to do this, please let me know.

Thanks.
Dirk

Re: Wishlist Cont.

I particularly like to read the reviews left by other reviewers I know, or the reviews of my reviewers' own works. It's to get their perspective and to avoid repeating nits. Sometimes I'll reinforce an opinion given by someone else. I vary as to whether I read other reviews before or after I've left my own.

Re: Wishlist Cont.

I know who that reviewer was who said it should be "rearview." And he was right! He set me straight about that, too. Since then I've read scores of novels that had it as "rearview."  Even Sandford's novels, as I recall, Dags. Sorry. See what your editor says.

160

Re: Wishlist Cont.

Not sure this is the place, but ...

It depends on what I'm thinking about writing.  Sometimes I prefer to start cold.  If I see a couple of nits and no more, I'll generally check to see if the nits have been caught.

161

Re: Wishlist Cont.

It might depend on the period.  Most compounds start as two words, get hyphenated, tnen lose the hyphen.

162 (edited by j p lundstrom 2015-03-05 20:07:20)

Re: Wishlist Cont.

I checked my O.E.D. and found high-school and high school, but not highschool.  Definitions were given for North America and the UK.  Where are you? 

As for rear view, I think it depends how you use it.  Adjective: "Bob looked out the rearview window."  vs  noun + descriptor:  "The window was so dirty there was no rear view."

But now that I write it, I'm not so sure.  Leave it as is.  JP

163 (edited by Janet Taylor-Perry 2015-03-05 20:05:03)

Re: Wishlist Cont.

Excellent point about location, JP. Something to remember when reviewing is that American English and UK, Canada, Australia, etc. often spell words differently, especially -our/or endings and the use of Z/S in spellings.

But I think I'll put this in the writing tips forum, since it's not anything Sol can add to our exhaustive wishlist.

Re: Wishlist Cont.

Janet Taylor-Perry wrote:

Excellent point about location, JP. Something to remember when reviewing is that American English and UK, Canada, Australia, etc. often spell words differently, especially -our/or endings and the use of Z/S in spellings.

But I think I'll put this in the writing tips forum, since it's not anything Sol can add to our exhaustive wishlist.

I use Word or OEWriter.  Sometimes, when I finish a chapter/story, I change the dictionary from English-US to English-UK and run the spell-check again.  The words are flagged that I might want to take a look at and make more 'international'.

This is from my 'for what it's worth' department.

~Tom

Re: Wishlist Cont.

j p lundstrom wrote:

I checked my O.E.D. and found high-school and high school, but not highschool.  Definitions were given for North America and the UK.  Where are you?

Obviously not in that period in the future in which high-school will have evolved into highschool.

Re: Wishlist Cont.

For you Aussies, Canadians, and Brits - you have to decide which market(s) you want your book in. I've read Higgins, Forsythe, Follett, Le Carre, Greene, and let's not forget about Ian Fleming. I might have glided over it, but I can't recall their using UK, as opposed to American, spellings for their words. Obviously, their target was the American audience. "Highschool" and "storey" might be fine in London, but "high school" and "story" are what New York expects to see. I let these separated-by-a common-language examples go when I review, but any authors seeking an American publisher should keep that in mind. Or not, and let the American editor worry about it. smile  Now, "bonnet," and "lift," and "bangers" are appropriate terms for English characters to use; the American eqiuivalents wouldn't be appropriate.

The O.E.D. is quite a tome - wish I had one, JP - but it has a British basis. Give me Merriam-Webster any day! This has started an interesting thread, and I hope to see more of it.

Re: Wishlist Cont.

Jack, depends on the genre. Regency romance novels and historical novels are two exceptions that come to mind where you shall not use American spelling that didn't exist yet ... But I agree, this is something for an editor to sort out.

And we do have a group that covers writing....

Re: Wishlist Cont.

Ah, yes, Janet - good point. Before the American colonies developed their own lexicon, the British dictionary ruled! I already feel kinda bad about chiming in on what is supposed to be a "Wish list" forum, but it was here, so what can I say? No telling where these threads will spin off to. smile  So, Dags, I agree, this isn't the place for such a discussion. If there is another, more appropriate venue, I'd be in favor of it. So what group are you referring to, Janet?

169 (edited by janet reid 2015-03-06 02:43:46)

Re: Wishlist Cont.

LOL, for sure!  No one can!  big_smile

I'm referring to the group aptly named:  Writing Tips & Advice
http://www.thenextbigwriter.com/group-w … -advice-36

Not sure if this is the one Dags have in mind, but I think so.

edit:  Janet T-P has already started this thread yesterday in that group too!  *scatches my head*  How did she know?!  LOL

Re: Wishlist Cont.

I checked out the forums on that site, Janet. Not a lot going on over there. So maybe you could stir things up in that group.

Re: Wishlist Cont.

When I first joined TNBW I had never done a review and didn't have a clue until I read others' reviews. I still read them, always, to educate myself. The knowledge on this site is amazing.

Re: Wishlist Cont.

I would recommend using the Writing Tips & Advice group for such a discussion. If we keep putting all threads in Premium, we'll soon have all kinds of unrelated conversations here that were intended to belong in other groups. Otherwise, why have them?

Either way, let's take this out of the Wish list thread.

Dirk

173

Re: Wishlist Cont.

From the other thread:

corra wrote:
Linda Lee wrote:

Gah!

I was going to type "I'm so reporting this," and I almost hit the Report button again! I am making enemies right and left. cool

Could we please have the Report and Delete buttons on the opposite side from the Edit and Quote buttons?

Re: Wishlist Cont.

having those two links (Report & Delete) on the left would be a wonderful idea.  I, also, have nearly hit the Report link (as well as the delete key - which got rid of a long post of mine causing me to have to recreate it).  I use a 1600x900 screen and still this happens.

~Tom

Re: Wishlist Cont.

I concur with moving both the Report and the little trash can. I haven't accidently hit report, but I did almost do what KHippolite did when I went to view a review.