Topic: Need Some Encouragement

I have a muse. A wonderful, seductive muse, who comes to me maybe once or twice a year tops, and takes over my entire being, driving me to write. I eat, sleep, poop, dwelling upon my stories. (My full-time job suffers) I give birth to them, and then I'm on to the next one. And that's the problem. When the muse is gone, writing is pointless. It is drivel. it has no soul. So I don't force it. However, I'd enjoy publishing the stories. I just know that they need work. They have plot, but not enough character development, and no setting whatsoever. I have to add these things in. And i can't bring myself to do it. I can't even look at my stories. I don't know why. I'm just overwhelmed with the idea that my stories SUCK.

Has anyone else ever had the problem of having to go back and work on their writing, and it makes them cringe?

If so, how did you break through it?

2 (edited by B Douglas Slack 2018-12-23 04:22:37)

Re: Need Some Encouragement

I can't think of a single person I've ever talked to about writing that hasn't gone through the same thing. It's happened to me many times. My favorite method for breaking through the doldrums is to build a scene in my virtual railroading program or go flying. Both hobbies will keep your mind so busy you don't have time to overthink a particular roadlbock in your novel.  Often enough your subconscious will provide a clue--the very key you need to turn your negatives into positives.

The writing I've done as little as a year ago is subject to my staring at it and wondering how the heck I managed to write such drivel. I gleefully rip out whole paragraphs, slash every adjective in the story, cream comma splices, and turn all tells into shows. Other times, I'll stare at it for ten minutes, then go have a cup of tea.

Trust me, you'll get through it.

Bill

Re: Need Some Encouragement

I fought the same demon with my art until I sat down one day and accepted the truth:   If I was meant to be an artist, I wouldn’t need to be compelled by a frequently delinquent muse - the art would want to come out of me and the passion would be with me far more often than it wasn’t with me.  So, I indulge the muse when she visits.  And while I wait for her to favor me with a passion for art in a more permanent way, I focus my effort on expression that compels me and that fills me with passion without needing a “muse”.

Look, if you are happy writing, you’ll write.  If it doesn’t make you happy, then what’s the point of bemoaning it?

And if you REALLY want to know if your stories “suck,” that question is easy to answer.   Submit them for publication and/or submit them to readers (such as us). Publishers and readers are very good at answering that question if you ask enough and if you ask honestly and are willing to accept the answer without being defensive.

Re: Need Some Encouragement

Temple, thank you. I will think about the idea that maybe I am not meant to write. I have other passions. As for submitting, I submitted them about 4 years ago, and they were fairly well received. No one said they were drivel. Although a recent one got panned. My friends love them. I have had a woman who publishes offer to publish them. They have "potential". I sat down last night and started working on "setting". Figuring out the cities where the stories would take place. There are 13 stories. I noted which ones have weak endings based on feedback, and those will wait until I have a muse.

Douglas, you have given me pause for thought. Slash, burn, fix, re-write. I think I am afraid to do that without a muse. But I will think about it.

I appreciate both of you for taking the time to respond.

Thank you.

Re: Need Some Encouragement

You're learning that your work can get better--which means your judgement is getting better.  Remember what the Marines say: Pain is weakness leaving the body.

Re: Need Some Encouragement

I think the secret is accepting that you suck and not taking yourself too seriously. Even if you don’t objectively suck, you’ll always feel like you do. The question is not whether you’re meant to write. The question is whether you enjoy it. If you focus on the pleasure of it istead of the pressure to be good at it, you might keep your interest in a story long enough to improve it. At the same time, the only way you can improve is practice.

For me, the secret for getting a first draft out is to write “like no one’s watching” (because no one is), and accepting that it will be utter crap (first drafts are meant to be), and then pretending it’s someone else’s writing and seeing if I can salvage it. Accepting that things will need to be sacrificed and the final might look completely different, that some ideas are meant to die young. Accept that it may never actually be good, just getting it to the best version it can be.

Re: Need Some Encouragement

Hello, Lauren!
I was going to welcome you, thinking you a new member, but checking out your profile page to see your work, I see you have been a member for more than eight years!
I look forward to reading some of your work. Happy holidays.  JP

Re: Need Some Encouragement

https://www.livewritethrive.com/2018/12 … more-10402

Re: Need Some Encouragement

Here's what one successful writer has to say about chasing perfection: https://accordingtohoyt.com/2018/12/24/drumming/

Re: Need Some Encouragement

I love that you're being so open (and vulnerable) about your self-doubt, QW. Because that's something every writer MUST struggle with. By which I mean... It's a struggle. Period. If it ain't a struggle (a compelling one, I mean) then yes... There ARE better things you could probably spend your energy on. But will they make you as happy? I've been "struggling" here for ten years already, pouring it out with no profit to show for it, but that's the point and the "ladder to climb" all in one and all at once. Being artistic WILL cleanse your soul. Even if your soul is already clean.

Merry Christmas
John