Hi JP!
Congrats on publishing Fruit of the Poisonous Tree! Good luck, JP. I'm sure it'll be great. Alas, I was not one of the reviewers, so I will not be included in this list. But, I did buy Adventures of a Young Girl, and I'll look forward to purchasing Tree as well.
I know the struggle to give credit where credit is due. At one point, I wasn't sure if I wanted to keep my membership, so I tried to copy/paste all of the reviews I'd received on my stories so that, when the day came, I'd have a concise list of those I needed to thank. Well... Let's just say it was too extensive an undertaking. Also, I (obviously) decided to keep my membership.
I do agree with this piece of advice...
Simon Morris wrote:"...keep a tally sheet and add the names of people who deserve thanks for their contributions..."
I used Excel to create a spreadsheet of reviewers per story. If you choose to do this, you'll find a bunch of other stuff you can attribute to any one author (i.e., helpful/professional/not so much). I'm thinking of doing something similar for the stories I review. As I age, I'm finding it more and more difficult to recall the plots and characters of the storylines.
Good luck, again, JP. I'll be looking forward to reading the published work.