Topic: Meeting Dialogue

There are guides to writing good dialogue.  But what about depicting meetings?  I've struggled a little, and I just completed a review that reminded me of the difficulties.  Does anyone know of any guides?

Re: Meeting Dialogue

Don't know of any guides, but if you have lots of people, you have to do something (tags/movement) to show who's speaking.

Re: Meeting Dialogue

I'm not sure why meetings should be treated different from any other scene; you don't need a separate set of guidelines for each type of scene whether a family gathering, a car chase, a romantic dinner, an alien abduction, or whatever. You cover enough to paint the picture and let the reader fill in the rest. You don't have to cover every speaker or every word of those who do speak and you don't have to show all the actions and reactions. You only need to present what is necessary to move the story to the next stage. That's the way I see it anyway. Take care. Vern

4 (edited by j p lundstrom 2015-10-26 16:10:42)

Re: Meeting Dialogue

Janet Taylor-Perry wrote:

Don't know of any guides, but if you have lots of people, you have to do something (tags/movement) to show who's speaking.

So right, Janet. You told me this last year and now, I can see what's lacking. Movement/ action gives a sense of place and time without having to describe the people and surroundings ad nauseum. No clocks, calendars or sundials required.

vern wrote:

I'm not sure why meetings should be treated different from any other scene. You cover enough to paint the picture and let the reader fill in the rest. You don't have to cover every speaker or every word of those who do speak and you don't have to show all the actions.

Vern has a point, too.

Re: Meeting Dialogue

The difficulties I see have to do with flow of topic, question and answer, axes arising between people and groups, tension, the dynamics of coming to a decision ... all the things that get hard when you actually try to depict them.

6 (edited by j p lundstrom 2015-10-26 16:29:49)

Re: Meeting Dialogue

I discovered a trick one day when I was faced with a screenful of bits I wanted to use in some way. (They became "The Blonde on the Beach.") Now I use it all the time. I type every bit as a separate phrase or sentence, each on its own line. Then I start playing around with them--If A said this, what would be B's and C's reactions? When everything fits together in a sequence I like, I turn the phrases into sentences, and the sentences into paragraphs, and there you are. Need a little action? Use actions instead of dialogue tags.
"Order in the court!" The judge banged his gavel until it broke and went flying across the courtroom.
Juror number 5 leapt out of the way. "Hey, Judge! Look out!"
The defense attorney picked up the offending piece of wood and brought it back to the bench. "I believe this is yours, Your Honor."
No boring tags, plenty of action.

Re: Meeting Dialogue

Good points, but again, that's  a specific  bit of action.  It's not the social decision-making process presented in narrative.

Re: Meeting Dialogue

njc wrote:

The difficulties I see have to do with flow of topic, question and answer, axes arising between people and groups, tension, the dynamics of coming to a decision ... all the things that get hard when you actually try to depict them.

If there are axes being raised, etc., then pick what is relevant to the story unfolding and show it. You don't even have to do it all within the meeting proper; someone's statements or reactions could be shown at a different time and place either in another conversation or in narrative to get to another stage of the plot, etc. Each segment is still merely another scene to describe; pick which ones should be shown and gloss over the rest. Just as with any other action scene, you don't write out every single detail; you don't bring in every curve or turn and squealing tire in a car chase for instance.

You might write out the entire script for the meeting with every bit of detail you can think to throw in and then go back and cut out what is not really relevant to the story or glaciates the pace, etc. Unless this meeting is the be all end all for the storyline, probably the less you dwell on it the better for the reader who doesn't want to get bogged down in minute detail. Just a thought. Take care. Vern

Re: Meeting Dialogue

'Axes', plural of 'axis'.

Your point about scenes is well-taken.

Re: Meeting Dialogue

njc wrote:

'Axes', plural of 'axis'.

Your point about scenes is well-taken.

I took it to be the plural of "ax" as in an "ax to grind." Sorry for the misunderstanding, but if you're looking for tension, I visualize them chasing each other with axes, rather than revolving around one another, but either way, the solution is the same albeit one picture is a little less colorful, lol. Take care. Vern

11

Re: Meeting Dialogue

That's my mid-level math background showing.  But then I may be slightly overeducated.  (My definition of overeducated includes knowing the proper, fully inflected past tense for the common Anglo-Saxon verb for defecation.)

Re: Meeting Dialogue

njc wrote:

That's my mid-level math background showing.  But then I may be slightly overeducated.  (My definition of overeducated includes knowing the proper, fully inflected past tense for the common Anglo-Saxon verb for defecation.)

Well, I hope you keep it to yourself, lol. Take care. Vern

Re: Meeting Dialogue

There are plenty of how-to articles and books out there, but I don't think I've ever seen one dedicated solely to handling group dialogue. Other than having to employ more speech attributes, constructing it is no different from a two person conversation. You don't need to highlight the nuances of every speaking person unless doing so is vital to plot. You choose the characters who have the largest stake in the conversation and focus most heavily on what they have to say. The rest is color. 

You might try creating the scene with only the key characters first. Get the vital part of the conversation constructed before adding comments from the color characters.

Re: Meeting Dialogue

JP suggested that I submit The Cat and her Ship, Chapter 3 as an example of meeting dialog. Those that wish can take a look at it and comment.

~Tom

Re: Meeting Dialogue

Tom Oldman wrote:

JP suggested that I submit The Cat and her Ship, Chapter 3 as an example of meeting dialog. Those that wish can take a look at it and comment.

~Tom

Good suggestion.