Here's my opinion for whatever it may be worth (hopefully at least the standard "2 cents" cliche`) on "The Opening Lines".
Characters involved: I'll agree Charles Bell has a history and looks to beat down others on this site. BUT ... is he the only one? Are there pots calling kettles black? Temple Wang seeing herself as a trollbuster? Really? She was temporarily banned at one point in time by SolN for the same conduct she proclaims she is fighting against. Where's my dictionary? Oh, there it is - hypocrisy. Vern - another black pot. He is particularly missile-locked on anything to do with religion and relishes chances to smash down anyone's belief under the alter of atheism, of which he is a card carrying member. He and his I'm-not-here-to-get-anything-written cohort, Memphis Trace, were solely responsible for turning the general forum into a political forum of destructive arguments leading SolN to step in and shut it down. The dynamic duo then tried to create a separate political / verbal warfare forum, which failed miserably and I think lasted less than a week. Trollbusters ... sure, haha.
My opinion: I agree and think it's a wise move for Suin to seek a free opinion, why not? It's not like she has to agree with it and even if she did or did not, there may be something worth looking at for improving the novel. Personally, I know romance genre novels are near the top of readership overall, and I do think her novel will do very well from what I've reviewed.
That said, I also agree with Charles Bell's points about the editor - gasp! I don't think that was his intention, but if he wanted to try to warn Suin from using Richard Bradburn as a *paid* editor, then I'd try to steer Suin away also. Yes, it's her decision in the end, but sharing is caring and that includes opinions and thoughts.
Problems: I read a lot of editor and author blogs to build up my writing knowledge since that's a good way to do so. Many accomplished editors will list the novels they were editing as references. It is not some sort of standard to hide such a fact. As a business major, who was required to take marketing as well, I can see some of the same marketing tactics used by Richard Bradburn. He mentions a global list of clients etc. and leaves it to the imagination if such authors actually exist. A standard marketing tactic. OH, and you have to dig his name out from a blog link, rather than seeing him put his name out front and center under "About me" (unless I missed it?).
Now, ghostwriters will always do this - not list the books they have worked on for obvious reasons. I remember one ghostwriter proclaiming she had just written a novel that reached #4 on Amazon. Of course, her contract would never allow her to divulge the book and thus compromise her client. However, this is not true for accomplished editors. There are no such restrictions needed to associate themselves with any novels they wrote or worked on. Richard Bradburn doesn't indicate the novel he wrote either. There's no novel I could quick search and find under his name - possibly he may have written under a pen name though.
His website mentions memberships where upon closer examination, one only needs 5 years of experience in editing and passing certain courses. There was no stringent requirement such as must have work experience with one of the "big 5" publishing houses, which some free lance editors can proudly proclaim on their sites.
This reminds me of many college professors, who get paid an obscene amount of a salary for far less in return. It's that old saying, "Those who can - do, and those who can't - teach."
If I had a romance novel and wanted to in the end hire an editor, I would be looking at Ann Everett (I don't know if she even hires herself out for editing though). Apparently, she's quite an accomplished romance novelist on TNBW and has at least one highly placed romance novel on kindle choices.
As you all know, my WIP is in the heroic fantasy genre, so if I do hire an editor, I'm most likely to turn to Janet Taylor Perry on this site. She has written in that genre and routinely gathers 4-5 star reviews en masse for her novels. My first choice - George R.R. Martin - probably won't return any of my emails if I reach out to him?
Didn't you have anything better to do with your time than pick at his website, Jube? You know, like write another chapter? Guilty as charged.