Do you know or have you heard of a "in a nutshell this is what he is doing" explanation as to what makes Game Of Thrones go over so well with its readers? I read the books when they first came out before the TV shows began, and it would help me, in terms of writing concepts, to know if there is something in particular that George R.R. Martin does in his writing to win over his readers. What I took away from the series was: He has no problems, like a Japanese manga, in killing off even major characters to inject a sort of realism (I think everyone picked up on that). He uses violence and negative emotions within his characters in abundance throughout the novels. Anything else you know of that makes his writing somewhat unique? I figure once I have a good handle on what makes 4-5 of the top authors in my genre tick that will help a lot with which way I should be pointing my pen and what direction to avoid. I"m guessing from MICE he's more of a character driven writer with some Milieu since he does have a world build going that is more than pasted together on the fly.
I've read the Fire and Ice series and like them. I haven't heard anyone disassemble their success, but in my opinion it's a combination of factors:
1. He has complex characters who are not just good or bad. This is refreshing to many readers.
2. He has created an interesting and complex world that resembles the middle ages but with some significant differences: magic, dragons, the Wall, etc.
3. His plot is not predictable. He kills off major characters, the good guys do not always win, etc.
4. He knows how to write to maintain reader interest and suspense. This is probably the hardest element for any writer to emulate or capture and comes with either natural talent or experience/practice. The best writers can put the reader into the character's mind with just a few sentences or describe a scene in a way that draws in a reader.
Anyway, these are my thoughts. All others are welcome.