1,226

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

My earlier write-up on how the Father, with the help of the Holy Spirit, might wall himself off before accepting Satan's challenge, is unnecessarily complicated.

I'll probably have Satan explain the challenge to God, then tell him he has to accept or reject the challenge without regard for who will win, which God would obviously know. God accepts the challenge on those terms as if he knew nothing about the outcome. However, God insists on a few details of his own, including choosing Satan's son (the Antichrist) as the person who decides at whom to throw the dagger. Naturally, Satan loves that choice and agrees.

Although one could assume God wouldn't agree if he could lose, he agreed not to consider win/loss when deciding whether to accept the challenge, which he does. Since God doesn't cheat, there's a real chance now that Satan could win, and the reader won't know whether or not he does until the end of the trilogy.

So much simpler....

1,227 (edited by George FLC 2024-09-19 17:11:02)

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

It feels like you're stuck between a rock and a hard place. You will have to explain the above without stating it exactly as you did above. Make it sound like Satan actually believes he has a chance. Expand this belief. I still like the notion that Satan is desperate and will grasp at straws to avoid an eternity in hell.

1,228

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

Why wouldn't the Father of Lies lie to himself?  And to anyone else he could ensnare for eternal damnation?

1,229

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

njc wrote:

Why wouldn't the Father of Lies lie to himself?  And to anyone else he could ensnare for eternal damnation?

Because Satan is headed for an eternity in the Lake of Fire on Judgment Day, which he is desperate to avoid. Ditto for the Antichrist (Connor) and the False Prophet, all grave human sinners, and (I think all other demons).

Satan knows God will know the outcome of the Last Challenge, which is why he asks him to agree to the challenge regardless of the outcome. I've taken out the concept that Christ could be destroyed as part of the challenge and will make it so that only Christ's human half can be destroyed, forcing Christ back into spirit form, after which the Holy Trinity and all angels must leave Earth for the spirit realm and never return. Normally, Christ and his body are inseparable, but the Father created the supernatural dagger that Connor will eventually throw at either Christ or Satan. Since the Father created the dagger, Christ, who is equally all-powerful, could easily sidestep it, but because the Father agreed to the challenge and the potential results, if Connor throws the dagger at Christ, he will honor the Father's commitment and allow his human half to be destroyed.

The next thing I need to figure out is why would the Father take such a risk. As it says in my content summary, what is so important that he would risk it all? It originally was supposed to be because of the huge rescue mission into Hell that Connor is meant to lead. However, God could implement the rescue plan himself with a single thought, so I need better logic.

1,230

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

I managed to work out a reason why God accepts Satan's challenge. Once again, it begins with the rescue mission, but Connor scales it up to rescue everyone except the nastiest of humans, knowing full well that the Father didn't give permission for that. And, technically, it comes very close to matching the end of Revelation in the Bible. Everyone who was destined for the Lake of Fire is forced into it, including all those Connor just tried to free.

But it turns out the lake is actually a portal to other worlds. All the condemned souls go into the lake, but most emerge on other, pristine worlds in regular (non-glorified) human bodies. The remaining humans who Connor freed, go into the lake and end up elsewhere on Earth, which has also been restored to a pristine state.

There will probably be a way to travel between worlds using the portals since there will be hundreds of planets to which humans are transported. These humans are required to "try again" from the beginning. smile  God will put Connor in charge of ruling everything as punishment for having freed them all, even though God knew he would do that and didn't try to stop him. Could this have been His plan all along? smile

Naturally, those destined for Heaven never go through the lake and simply end up on a different plane, in a new Heaven and Earth, where they live with God, free from sin. Everyone else will aspire to get there.

The demonic spirits and nastiest humans (past and present) will also enter the lake but wind up on nasty frozen or burning worlds, and their portals will be one way only. smile  I can't wait to figure out what kind of world to put Satan on.

1,231

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

Wouldn't Satan build a spaceship and come back? I mean super genius with time on his hands...

1,232

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

Dirk B wrote:

The demonic spirits and nastiest humans (past and present) will also enter the lake but wind up on nasty frozen or burning worlds, and their portals will be one way only. smile  I can't wait to figure out what kind of world to put Satan on.

Didn't Dante have some ideas?

There's an old joke about a fellow with his feet in a freezer and his head in an oven.  On average, he's comfortable.  Or you could assume a spherical cow ...

1,233

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

>> Wouldn't Satan build a spaceship and come back? I mean super genius with time on his hands...

Since Connor will throw the dagger at De Rosa, I had thought to destroy his physical form, leaving just Satan's spirit. But then I have to figure out how to drag him and all other demons into the lake of fire since humans can't hold him. I can leave that up to Jesus, I guess. So, it's only his spirit that goes through the lake to another world, or perhaps to an asteroid or moon like Io, preferably a celestial body that is spiralling into a black hole. Also, Satan's spirit has very little power to manipulate the physical realm without De Rosa's genetically engineered body, which is where most of his physical power came from while he was masquerading as the dark figure in Rome (same breeding program as Connor).

1,234

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

Also, Satan's spirit has very little power to manipulate the physical realm

In this state, does the nature of his environmental condition (eg cold / hot) bother him? Can he sit around for ten thousand years and wait for colonists to show up so he can make a new body?

1,235

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

If he can't sit around, interesting thought. As closer to the Jew side of the spectrum, the lake of fire is instantaneous (read: little suffering). If I understand Catholicism, it's perpetual suffering (read: torture)

1,236

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

He doesn't have a choice. He has no place to go unless someone can find a way land on his moon/asteroid spiraling into a black hole. If the lake of fire on Earth dumps him on some searing moon, he's likely to suffer as he would in an actual lake of fire. Based on that, I'd say he'd also suffer in extreme cold. And, yes, Catholics believe it's perpetual suffering. Purgatory, I've read, involves suffering as well. Fun, huh?

Connor is actually going to be the first one who goes into the lake of fire, where he will burn to atone for Adam (his soul) bringing sin into the world. He's returned right back to Megiddo, where the end of the story is still playing out. Every mortal sinner will burn to some degree for their sins before passing through. Their suffering will equal that of the suffering they themselves caused while alive.

1,237

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

Since human souls that go into the lake acquire a new human body before emerging on the other side, I could do the same with all the demons. Put all of them into corpses, in which they get stuck. Satan would probably get the same body back, which had been mutilated/deformed when the resistance took back the Vatican at the end of book 2. I could even put a cross around his neck again to trap him inside. Perhaps crosses around each corpse's neck to trap them all in bodies that undoubtedly experience searing heat and freezing cold?

It's not critical that they be in physical bodies since I could simply write that their spirit forms experience cold/heat too. However, putting them into bodies makes things consistent. A soul goes into the lake, burns for a time to pay for all the pain that person had caused while alive, then gets a non-glorified human body and is transported elsewhere.

The two inconsistencies I have to work out are that, in theory, Adam and Eve are responsible for every evil act since Creation. Eve was given a glorified body with which she returned to Earth as Dr. Lombardi, ostensibly a member of the conspiracy, to keep an eye on Connor/Adam at the Vatican. Perhaps that's why she was given a pass. Yet Connor/Adam will burn like hell until there's nothing left of them but their shared soul in agony.

Also, Satan is much more culpable for evil in the world. He is the reason Adam & Eve sinned, and he continued to stir up evil throughout history. This means he should suffer more than anyone else. The intensity of that heat would have to be staggering.

1,238

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

As I try to think through some of the elements of the book that I included in the first draft, I'm having a bit of a problem explaining why the Unholy Trinity (or anyone for that matter, especially the reader) would believe a spiritual poisoning of Christ (from the dagger) is even remotely possible.

In the story it's quite clear in several places that Connor/Christ seems to interact with the Holy Spirit even though Connor has yet to realize who he really is (and for some reason, the HS doesn't tell him). Naturally, all that is made up by Satan & Connor since Connor has never been baptized (not yet, anyway). I could have left that whole element out of the story, but given that other people far less pious than Connor have interacted with the HS in the past (true of both Romano and Campagna), it wouldn't make sense for Connor of all people not to have access to the HS, even though he's faking it.

I suppose I could have it be one of the details of the (fake) wager/challenge. Namely, the fake HS can't tell Connor who he really is (Christ) until the fake Father says so, which happens at the Church of the Holy Sepulcher. Also, it's the reason Christ, an all powerful spirit, doesn't seem able to enter Connor's mind to fully awaken the Christ within him until the climax. In other words, the Father told them both to wait.

Another issue is that the HS withdrew from Romano as part of the rules for the wager. Satan didn't trust the HS not to reveal something to Romano. Similarly, though, shouldn't the HS withdraw from Connor (Christ) for the same reason? As above, Connor fakes the presence of the HS within him, but then shouldn't he pretend that the HS withdrew from him too?

Just to clarify one item, there are actually two wagers in this story: a real one and a fake one. The real one is the decision Connor eventually has to make about whom to destroy (Christ's human half or Satan's De Rosa zombie). The fake wager is that if Christ comes back as a child and is raised by the Catholic Church, Christ will eventually become so disgusted with it, that he will destroy it. Only the fake wager appears throughout most of the book. At the end, Connor reveals the real wager to Campagna, which Connor himself didn't even know until that day.

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

njc wrote:
Dirk B wrote:

The demonic spirits and nastiest humans (past and present) will also enter the lake but wind up on nasty frozen or burning worlds, and their portals will be one way only. smile  I can't wait to figure out what kind of world to put Satan on.

Didn't Dante have some ideas?

There's an old joke about a fellow with his feet in a freezer and his head in an oven.  On average, he's comfortable.  Or you could assume a spherical cow ...

You are correct njc. Dirk, I was investigating your blue section above and came across something that sounds somewhat similar to what you wrote.:

The idea that there are different levels of punishment in hell is graphically portrayed in The Divine Comedy, written by Dante Alighieri between 1308 and 1321. In that poem, the Roman poet Virgil guides Dante through the nine circles of hell. The circles are concentric, representing a gradual increase in wickedness, and culminating at the center of the earth, where Satan is held in bondage. Each circle’s sinners are punished in a fashion befitting their crimes. Each sinner is afflicted for all of eternity by the chief sin he committed. According to Dante, the circles range from the first circle, where dwell the unbaptized and virtuous pagans, to the very center of hell reserved for those who have committed the ultimate sin—treachery against God.

Although the Bible does not specifically say there are different levels of punishment in hell, it does seem to indicate that the judgment will indeed be experienced differently for different people. In Revelation 20:11–15, the people are judged “according to what they had done as recorded in the books” (Revelation 20:12). All the people at this judgment, though, are thrown into the lake of fire (Revelation 20:13–15). So, perhaps, the purpose of the judgment is to determine how severe the punishment in hell will be.

A clearer passage is Luke 10, where Jesus speaks of comparative punishment. First, Jesus says this about a village that rejects the gospel: “I tell you, it will be more bearable on that day for Sodom than for that town” (verse 12). Then He speaks to Bethsaida and Chorazin: “It will be more bearable for Tyre and Sidon at the judgment than for you” (verse 14). Whatever punishment the former residents of Sodom, Tyre, and Sidon were experiencing in hell, the Galilean towns that refused to hear Christ would experience more. The level of punishment in hell seems to be tied to the amount of light a person rejects.

Another indication that hell has different levels of punishment is found in Jesus’ words in Luke 12: “The servant who knows the master’s will and does not get ready or does not do what the master wants will be beaten with many blows. But the one who does not know and does things deserving punishment will be beaten with few blows. From everyone who has been given much, much will be demanded; and from the one who has been entrusted with much, much more will be asked” (verses 47–48).

Whatever degrees of punishment hell contains, it is clear that hell is a place to be avoided.


I'm not done looking your stuff over, but this looked interesting to me, and it doesn't hurt to send chunks your way.

1,240

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

Thanks, George. Looks like Dante beat me to some of the ideas by a "few" centuries. smile

Below is part of the writeup for the 4th century documents written by Satan, pretending to be a couple of future saints. Some of it is true (e.g., there is a last challenge) and some is total malarky (e.g., Christ coming back as a child). The part below is intended to allow me to say, yes the story events don't match the Bible, but that's because the characters are on a different timeline from the Bible prophets, especially John.

Cave-Dwelling Theologian (Satan) wrote:

A remarkable side effect of the Last Challenge is that, as time goes on, there will be an increasing number of differences between the events of our world and those prophesied in the Bible right up until the Day of the Lord.

But how is this possible when we know the Bible to be free of error? The answer is, we no longer exist along the same flow of time as the Bible’s prophets. It seems there can be many such flows, each of which I shall refer to as a timeline.

Had there been no challenge, we — humans, angels, and demons — would have continued along our original timeline, and events would match the Bible, including, eventually, the Apocalypse as prophesied in Revelation.

However, due to the challenge, changes are now inevitable. Rather than allow them to invalidate the Holy Bible — the flawless word of God — he created a new timeline for us not bound by the original prophesies.

The timelines share an identical history up to the moment the new one came into being, meaning that both have the very same Bible even though its prophecies only apply to the original timeline, whereas the challenge only exists in the new timeline.

As a result, the Bible itself remains entirely free of error, provided we read it as God intended — a Bible for us as we existed on the original timeline, not for us now that we exist on the new timeline.

Dirk wrote:


How clear is the above explanation? It’s a little long-winded, but it has to be clear enough for a 4th century theologian to understand, who has never heard of timelines. It will allow me to eliminate the silly statements/musings in the first draft that the Bible seems to be wrong. While I wasn’t keen to introduce an alternate timeline into this story, it closes the glaring plot hole.

Of course, God could simply decide to invalidate his own Bible, but I really dislike saying the Bible is wrong and/or God simply ignored it. I think my target audience is more likely to buy an alternate timeline than an erroneous Bible. Remains to be seen as I get more feedback about this chapter.

Unless someone has an even better solution....

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

Actually, I felt that your creativity earned an A. And since you came up with similar solutions as Dante then you're doing something right!

Can you treat "All the condemned souls go into the lake, but most emerge on other, pristine worlds in regular (non-glorified) human bodies. The remaining humans who Connor freed, go into the lake and end up elsewhere on Earth, which has also been restored to a pristine state" as a sort of purgatory? Or it's purgatory if they end up with glorified bodies.

1,242

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

No, the portals and the other worlds are for mortal sinners. They get there via the lake of fire, which is not the case for sinners going to purgatory. Granted, I could just wave my magical fiction wand and make it so, but it seems very clean at present in terms of a reader wrapping their minds around the story, especially a Catholic reader. The more I deviate, the harder it gets for them, and the less they're likely to like the story, imo.

Technically, one doesn't get a glorified body until after the Second Coming, so I guess you're just a disembodied soul waiting in Heaven for the Second Coming. Eve, if you recall, does get her glorified body, so she could be at the center of events to keep an eye on Adam/Connor, although that part of her mission doesn't begin until book 2.

Antonio will be the example of what purgatory is like in this story. It's not truly Catholic, but then not much is known about purgatory. I figure if you want absolution from a priest, you usually need to do some penance. If Antonio wants out of purgatory, he needs to make things right with Romano, which includes telling Romano the truth (that Antonio had already gone to confession prior to being hit by the truck, but he allowed Romano to think he died in a state of mortal sin). I'll treat what he did to Romano as a venial sin.

Antonio will continue to travel with the group like in the first draft, but he also needs to do some good works before he gets out of purgatory. If you recall, he "cured" Connor of the spiritual poison by figuring out the solution and dunking Connor in the Sea of Galilee. Naturally, Connor wasn't actually sick, but Antonio didn't know that. Still, I'll probably make that the last thing he needs to do to complete purgatory, even though Antonio won't know it right away.

So, for some reason, he remains with the group throughout the entire trip. Eventually, he'll get a chance to ask Phanuel what else to do to complete purgatory. He's told he already did complete it, and he may go to Heaven whenever he wishes. But he decides to do a few more good works by staying with Romano to oppose the efforts of the Unholy Trinity. My other option is to simply keep Antonio in the story, while he thinks he's still in purgatory, whereas in reality he cares too much about Romano and Connor that God knew he'd rather stay in purgatory long enough to finish his life's work. He would then find out at the end of book 3 that that's the real reason he's still on Earth.

One thing I'd like to include, though, is the idea that Antonio becomes more and more holy as he does more good works. It's a transformation that would happen automatically. It slowly purges him of sin, so he can go to Heaven, which definitely is Catholic. I just have to be careful that his holiness doesn't ruin him as an interesting character. I figure he can still say sarcastic things without them being sins.

Did I answer your question? :-)

1,243

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

I managed to purge the word timeline from Satan's 4th century documents. The new terminology is river(s) of time, or river(s) for short. Seems more appropriate to the time period.

Cave-Dwelling Theologian (Satan) wrote:

A remarkable side effect of the Last Challenge is that, as time goes on, there shall be an increasing number of differences between the events of our world and those prophesied in the Bible right up until the Day of the Lord.


But how is this possible when we know the Bible to be free of error? The answer is, we no longer travel on the same river of time as the Bible’s prophets. It seems there can be many such rivers, branching off in different directions to different destinations.


The prophesies about a particular event or outcome apply only as long as we remain on the same river as those, like the Apostle John, who foresee events to come. However, the prophets see only what lies ahead on whichever river they travel. Only God sees them all.


Had there been no challenge, we — humans, angels, and demons — would have continued along the same river, and future events would match the Bible, including, eventually, the Apocalypse as prophesied in Revelation.


However, due to the challenge, changes are now inevitable. Rather than allow them to invalidate the Holy Bible — the flawless word of God — he created for us a new river in time that branches off the original and is therefore not bound to its prophesies.


The two rivers — which, prior to the challenge, were but one — share an identical history up to the moment the new one came into being. As a result, we have carried with us the same Bible along both currents, even though its prophecies apply only to the original river, whereas the challenge exists only along ours.


Thus, the Bible itself remains entirely free of error, provided we read it as God intended — a Bible for us as we existed on the one united river prior to the challenge. Although we share that Bible, it is no longer meant for us. The challenge takes us into uncharted waters for which I have included new prophecies given to me by the Holy Spirit.

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

Dirk B wrote:

One thing I'd like to include, though, is the idea that Antonio becomes more and more holy as he does more good works. It's a transformation that would happen automatically. It slowly purges him of sin, so he can go to Heaven, which definitely is Catholic. I just have to be careful that his holiness doesn't ruin him as an interesting character. I figure he can still say sarcastic things without them being sins.

Did I answer your question? :-)

What? Being more holy is less interesting? Say it isn't so! Jesus was rather interesting. The apostles were rather interesting. Eternity will be nothing but holy so I expect it to be rather thrilling. Jesus said some pretty brutal things to people so perhaps sarcasm is allowed but it should be holy sarcasm... whatever that is. I gotta think on that one.

George FLC

1,245 (edited by George FLC 2024-10-04 22:31:55)

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

I just googled it and found that apparently Jesus did use sarcasm:
https://relevantmagazine.com/faith/4-ti … e-a-point/

Just remember... it's gotta be holy.

1,246

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

>>I just have to be careful that his holiness doesn't ruin him as an interesting character.

What I meant was if it's not written correctly, the character will become boring (for the reader and the writer). The plot and his character arc still need to happen beyond him becoming holy. It has to serve the story somehow. Perhaps as he becomes more holy, he becomes more insightful about Connor and the dagger, and realizes the Sea of Galilee would cure him. Also, if I bring him back for books 2 & 3, I would then have to think up ways to use his holiness to benefit the rest of the story. And he probably wouldn't be the right person to get caught up in some violent event, although perhaps his growing holiness makes him a good choice for tackling demons. Stuff like that. Details TBD.

I was told many years ago that the story was becoming boring because, every time anyone runs into trouble, Connor prays and solves everyone's problems. Zero tension with that. It's the reason I added the demonic dagger and the various stages of Connor's sickness from it. Despite that, Seabrass thought things in the Holy Land were too predictable. He suggested I kill a few of the guards, but I couldn't do that since that would make Connor a murderer since he controls the events in the HL. If he's a murderer, then there's no point in having him fail to kill the pope too. Can't go that way. I'm still pondering how to address his concern.

1,247

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

I thought of a great addition to the Holy Land chapters. Since Connor is frequently attacked by and/or saved by animals, I figure it should build to an all-out battle between dark animals, who bow to Satan, and light animals, who defend "Christ".

The dark animals are easy since they can each be possessed by a demon who know how to drive the animals into an attack. They do that with the hyenas at Capernaum. The light animals is trickier since Connor is the AC, not Christ. He can definitely make himself liked by animals, which he did a few times in the first draft. In fact, the whites doves even came to his rescue when he was attacked by the wild cat at the baptism site. Ditto for when the pratincoles saved the group from the demonic locusts.

It does beg the question how is Connor able to steer an entire army of animals to defend him? Obviously, he can't be in all their heads at once. The best way, which I think is already implied by the pratincoles and doves, is for him to be able to give off some "good" vibe that brings the unpossessed animals to his defense. I can also use some of the animals in the final battle of book 3.

I'm also thinking of giving Connor a dog throughout the trip in book 1. But I need to figure out what major contribution it can make to the story beyond merely giving a sick kid a dog, although it could reinforce the image of Connor as a sweet kid if his dog adores him. I doubt pets are allowed at the Western Wall in Jerusalem, though, not to mention at other tourist attractions, and in all the churches they visit.

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

I don't know if this helps... Scriptures state that Satan can appear as an angel of light. So, it's not much of a stretch to think that Connor has a demon dog that masquerades as a nice little doggie. Perhaps it can spy on the good guys for Connor.

2 Corinthians 11:14-15 Holman Christian Standard Bible
14 And no wonder! For Satan disguises himself as an angel of light. 15 So it is no great thing if his servants also disguise themselves as servants of righteousness. Their destiny[a] will be according to their works.

1,249

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

I knew about the angel of light disguise, but not the idea of his minions disguising themselves as good. It's an interesting idea, but I can't think of a reason why he would need a demonic dog. In fact I'm having trouble trying to figure out a dog's reason to be in the story except that Connor is sick and they get him the dog to cheer him up. Not much of an addition to the story.

An all-out battle between good and evil animals I definitely intend to do.

1,250

Re: Satan's Last Stand (the Connor series) - Dirk B.

More moving parts might not be a good thing