Topic: Inline review bug

Sol, I just discovered that it is not possible to save an inline review unless there is at least one inline comment (at least I think that's the problem). I read a very short chapter (0.5 points) and found nothing to nit, so I just left a summary comment and clicked submit (I didn't care about the half point). The review wasn't saved. I had to switch to a regular review to save my summary comment. I won't complain about the half point I gained, but the system didn't warn me that the inline review hadn't been saved.

Dirk

Quote Post 1

Re: Inline review bug

Just scratching my head here, but why would you want to save an inline review with no comments? It does tell you how many comments you've left and that you need 5 for the points. Okay, you left the summary comment in a regular review, so still wondering why the inline should be saved? I may be a little slow, but I don't get it. Damn, now my head's bleeding, lol. Take care. Vern

Quote Post 2

Re: Inline review bug

I frequently submit inline reviews shy of five. They always save. This is the first time I can recall that I left no comments and submitted just the summary. It gave no error message but didn't save. That's the bug.

Quote Post 3

Re: Inline review bug

You know, you can comment on what is working, what you find effective, not just improvements. There is a way to get at least 5 comments in even a short review. Even if it is the occasional well done!

Quote Post 4

Re: Inline review bug

I do it inline when appropriate, otherwise I do it in the summary. Had I cared about the half point, I would have switched to a regular review. I found a bug, I reported it. I would appreciate it if people would stop hijacking this thread to teach me how to do reviews.

Quote Post 5