Re: What's With Some of the New Members

As Memphis said, such a group (groups?) should require permission to enter, which the site already supports. I disagree about charging more for it, though. As Lynne said, other sites have this, too.

77 (edited by Jan's Stories 2018-12-21 00:54:30)

Re: What's With Some of the New Members

I am a newbie and I had three people give me reviews, which I appreciated. I'm still trying to figure out how to thank them and I think I left a thank you on my site instead of theirs! My brain has been very tired lately.
I too am worried a bit about leaving reviews because I only took one creative writing class, and I don't think my writing skills are as good as alot of other writers. I'll give it a go though. Maybe I'll even learn a thing or two.

Re: What's With Some of the New Members

Well, doesn't it suck that I can't give an honest, unvarnished opinion on this topic!   As a newbie three times over (since 2005?) I do remember a change from a site containing members inclined to give impersonal and honest content review, thumbs up or thumbs down, to now a kaffeeklatsch of Chardonnay sipping chatterers. Not that that there is anything wrong with that, mind you, but it could explain an off-putting nature for newbies, who are not the only ones who will neglect to thank a reviewer, but certainly the only members who never thank, or comment, and resort to delete a newbie review and block the newbie reviewer for giving an honest Simon Cowell opinion.

Re: What's With Some of the New Members

Charles_F_Bell wrote:

Well, doesn't it suck that I can't give an honest, unvarnished opinion on this topic!   As a newbie three times over (since 2005?) I do remember a change from a site containing members inclined to give impersonal and honest content review, thumbs up or thumbs down, to now a kaffeeklatsch of Chardonnay sipping chatterers. Not that that there is anything wrong with that, mind you, but it could explain an off-putting nature for newbies, who are not the only ones who will neglect to thank a reviewer, but certainly the only members who never thank, or comment, and resort to delete a newbie review and block the newbie reviewer for giving an honest Simon Cowell opinion.

http://lowres.jantoo.com/restaurants-spite-spitefulness-restaurant-menu-spleen-03401263_low.jpg

Re: What's With Some of the New Members

Temple Wang wrote:

restaurants-spite-spitefulness-restaurant-menu-spleen-03401263_low.jpg

While I have your attention (again) what is your opinion on a member using false identities to get around blocking, for example, aka, Charly Ring, Bevin Wallace, Bill Weldon, Van Alsen.  Interesting that the aborigine from Australia, Wallace, and the Vietnamese, Alsen, have the same bugaboo in preferring the word quaver over quiver when the two have the same meaning when used as a verb, but quaver is rarely used in American English.

81 (edited by Temple Wang 2018-12-21 13:05:27)

Re: What's With Some of the New Members

Charles_F_Bell wrote:
Temple Wang wrote:

restaurants-spite-spitefulness-restaurant-menu-spleen-03401263_low.jpg

While I have your attention (again) what is your opinion on a member using false identities to get around blocking, for example, aka, Charly Ring, Bevin Wallace, Bill Weldon, Van Alsen.  Interesting that the aborigine from Australia, Wallace, and the Vietnamese, Alsen, have the same bugaboo in preferring the word quaver over quiver when the two have the same meaning when used as a verb, but quaver is rarely used in American English.

Dunno, Chuck.  Sounds like you have quite a fan base—or maybe it’s some right-wing conspiracy aimed at helping you improve your writing.  How dare them. The bastards...
If you don’t mind me saying so, you seem to have WAY too much time on your hands.  You should get a hobby or a mate, dog maybe?  And meditate, too.  Get all that hate out.  Hate corrodes the vessel that contains it ... Merry Christmas!
https://i2.kym-cdn.com/entries/icons/original/000/016/146/eird-al-yankovic-tin-foil-hat-160x160.png

Re: What's With Some of the New Members

Temple Wang wrote:
Charles_F_Bell wrote:
Temple Wang wrote:

restaurants-spite-spitefulness-restaurant-menu-spleen-03401263_low.jpg

While I have your attention (again) what is your opinion on a member using false identities to get around blocking, for example, aka, Charly Ring, Bevin Wallace, Bill Weldon, Van Alsen.  Interesting that the aborigine from Australia, Wallace, and the Vietnamese, Alsen, have the same bugaboo in preferring the word quaver over quiver when the two have the same meaning when used as a verb, but quaver is rarely used in American English.

Dunno, Chuck.

Of course you don’t actually have an opinion on anything but I’ll just just keep asking nevertheless to  see how your statement on facts vary.

Re: What's With Some of the New Members

Charles_F_Bell wrote:
Temple Wang wrote:
Charles_F_Bell wrote:

While I have your attention (again) what is your opinion on a member using false identities to get around blocking, for example, aka, Charly Ring, Bevin Wallace, Bill Weldon, Van Alsen.  Interesting that the aborigine from Australia, Wallace, and the Vietnamese, Alsen, have the same bugaboo in preferring the word quaver over quiver when the two have the same meaning when used as a verb, but quaver is rarely used in American English.

Dunno, Chuck.

Of course you don’t actually have an opinion on anything but I’ll just just keep asking nevertheless to  see how your statement on facts vary.

I’m just glad to have you as a fan, Chuck.  And you really should get those sleeves trimmed.
https://media.giphy.com/media/Rz5mrlv5kPwdi/giphy.gif

Re: What's With Some of the New Members

Jan's Stories wrote:

I am a newbie and I had three people give me reviews, which I appreciated. I'm still trying to figure out how to thank them and I think I left a thank you on my site instead of theirs! My brain has been very tired lately.
I too am worried a bit about leaving reviews because I only took one creative writing class, and I don't think my writing skills are as good as alot of other writers. I'll give it a go though. Maybe I'll even learn a thing or two.

You can certainly leave a thank-you note on the authors' home page by means of a quickie, which I think they may appreciate, but the best way is to read and review their work. Don't feel you're not prepared to comment somebody else's work, you may be able to spot something important other reviewers, supposedly more seasoned, may have overlooked.

My grammar and English construction suck, so I can't review other writers' grammar. Instead, I focus my comments on the plot, character and world building, plausibility of events, suspension of disbelief, etc. I haven't taken any creative writing classes either, and I bet neither many of the best reviewers on this site have. Just follow your instinct and point at what feels out of place in a certain story.

Kiss,

Gacela.

85

Re: What's With Some of the New Members

JM Straczinski likes to say "When you become obsessed with the enemy, you become the enemy."

When you become obsessed with the troll, you become the troll.

Unless you and Charles are the same person, or you're paying him off like Lord Cholmdelmondeleigh in GKC's =A Painful Fall of a Great Reputation= (in =The Club of Queer Trades=).  (Apologies if I missed a syllable in the villain's name.)

86 (edited by Temple Wang 2018-12-21 22:47:31)

Re: What's With Some of the New Members

njc wrote:

JM Straczinski likes to say "When you become obsessed with the enemy, you become the enemy."

When you become obsessed with the troll, you become the troll.

Unless you and Charles are the same person, or you're paying him off like Lord Cholmdelmondeleigh in GKC's =A Painful Fall of a Great Reputation= (in =The Club of Queer Trades=).  (Apologies if I missed a syllable in the villain's name.)

njc,
Think of  “troll-baiting” as a cerebral endeavor, nay, a zen-like sport, as opposed to an obsession.  Or perhaps more akin to doing the NY Times crossword puzzles to keep the mind sharp.  Plus, I’m plotting out a new thriller starring a serial killer and would-be assassin who is also a misanthropic online troll who wears pinafores over his wife beater and boxers, has a swastika tattooed on his neck, and binge-watches Infowars and Donald [t]Rump’s Twitter feed.  You know the kind: they finally nab him and find he’s got buckets of orange body paint and a collection of tinfoil hats in the garage—and body parts buried in the backyard, and all the neighbors can say about him is: “He seemed like such a quiet guy.  He did smell a little funny, now that you mention it though ...”

Oh vey, what a writer’s gotta do for the sake of verisimilitude. 

LOL
Merry Christmas

Re: What's With Some of the New Members

Looking forward to reading that thriller, Temple!

88 (edited by njc 2018-12-22 02:22:24)

Re: What's With Some of the New Members

Corrobative detail intended to give artistic verisimilitude to an otherwise bald and unconvincing narrative?

Re: What's With Some of the New Members

Exactly. Hard to concoct a more compelling antagonist than whichever one is on the front page on any given day. 
http://celebrityinsider.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Stephen-Miller.jpg

90

Re: What's With Some of the New Members

True.  They are trained pros, accustomed to trolling the populace, often with a story that contradicts the one they told last month.  I have no doubt a panic would ensue if they proclaimed the sun was going to set in the east.  And they would blame it on whichever Public Scapegoat they were targetting that week.