Re: The Hollow Man

He is nothing if not persistant.

Re: The Hollow Man

Chapter Two is up, hooray lots of talking!

53

Re: The Hollow Man

Will  review later.  Looks pretty good.

Re: The Hollow Man

So I've run into a rather, tiny, gigantic, ever so wonderful problem.  There are several things going on in the war that Silas could be involved with given his recent, shall we say, murder extravaganza.  I have no idea which one to choose, they all seem interesting, but I want to pick the most interesting one, suppose I should just share what I've got so far.
Silas joins a rag tag group of blood thirsty bastards for a shadow campaign behind enemy lines, looting, burning pillaging, etc etc
Silas joins a group going to the eastern kingdoms hoping to bring the undecided Khans under the kings banner
Silas discovers the true meaning of Christmas
Silas and his Brother both join the King as body guards because of increased assassination attempts
Silas joins the secret police and murders people who seem to be getting uppity

55

Re: The Hollow Man

Do you want the event to drive him along, or do you want to run counter to it?

Re: The Hollow Man

The event is more catalyst for the growth Silas does in the first 'act'  I want to show the reader the world and what's in it, give you characters to love and hate, that sort of thing.

57

Re: The Hollow Man

Silas is going to be recognized, and perhaps praised, for his berserking spree.  Does he embrace it or fight it?   Who praises him?   Who fears him?  Does the King approve,  or does he treat Silas as a valuable, dangerous weapon?  How does the King regard those red eyes?

Re: The Hollow Man

Praise, embraces, with some hesitation, the average solider follows him gladly, but Knights and Lords look down on him.  The King treats Silas as a weapon, and as to the red eyes, they do not scare the king, but they do scare many of his advisers.

59 (edited by njc 2015-02-18 00:01:28)

Re: The Hollow Man

Then either your story follows this or defies it.  There is conflict in how he is regarded.  The most 'organic' thing, at this point and neglecting later story arc issues, would be to play out that conflict in a way that determines the next part of Silas's story.

And, of course, we must ask how all these things comport with what Silas wants for himself.

Re: The Hollow Man

Shearluck wrote:

So I've run into a rather, tiny, gigantic, ever so wonderful problem.  There are several things going on in the war that Silas could be involved with given his recent, shall we say, murder extravaganza.  I have no idea which one to choose, they all seem interesting, but I want to pick the most interesting one, suppose I should just share what I've got so far.
Silas joins a rag tag group of blood thirsty bastards for a shadow campaign behind enemy lines, looting, burning pillaging, etc etc
Silas joins a group going to the eastern kingdoms hoping to bring the undecided Khans under the kings banner
Silas discovers the true meaning of Christmas
Silas and his Brother both join the King as body guards because of increased assassination attempts
Silas joins the secret police and murders people who seem to be getting uppity

Going to the eastern kingdoms gets my vote. It will take leadership diplomacy and probably some more fighting to do that. Epic comes to mind. It will be a massive final battle, brother against brother type of thing.

Not sure if I read the rest of the tread correctly, but are you worried readers won't "like" Silas because of what he's done in Ch1? It was pretty out there, but it's war and I'd rather that than someone "romanticising" things- cutting someone with a sword gets messy real quick. In any case, other than toning down Silas in Ch1 ie making him less bloodthirsty and more in control yet still effective at slaying rebels, you can always make readers hate the rebels more ie have them slaughter a few babies. You'd be amazed how quick readers will cheer Silas on next time he meets some rebels ...

Or, like usual, I might just have no idea what we're talking about here! smile

61

Re: The Hollow Man

The most important thing is that Silas's story is interesting.  It will help if we can like him.

We've been told that people are calling him The Butcher of V----.  Do we think of him that way?  If not, he's already wronged (in our minds) and thus sympathetic.

Re: The Hollow Man

Not knowing the rebel's cause, what we think of Silas can still go both ways. If the rebels are bloodthirsty greedy pigs, we root for Silas. If not, then we might have a little problem with Silas, so if the rebels have a just cause, I'd strongly suggest that Silas realises that, feel bad about killing them by the hundreds and see to justice being done despite the personal cost to him as a son/brother. Basically, I'm still open-minded and it's up to Shearluck to make me go either way.

This is one of the reasons I plaster my thoughts all over my reviews - to let writers know whether they've succeeded to convey their intent to readers (or, at least this reader).

63 (edited by njc 2015-02-18 02:03:17)

Re: The Hollow Man

Those red eyes, and the legends associated with them, will mark Silas among those he meets.  And his performance as a berserker will not recommend him as a diplomat or statesman, but as a warrior.

To establish him otherwise among kin, nobility, and King will take time and the passing of events.

Re: The Hollow Man

The rebels caused is mix, end to slavery, new lands given, an end to the status quo

Re: The Hollow Man

Total change of topic.  On March 14th 2015 at 9:26 and 535 milliseconds, a grand conjunction shall occur.  I choose my conjuction to happen during Eastern Standard Time, and fully plan to dig a big fork into a piece of pi.  Strawberry rhubarb, to be exact :-)

Re: The Hollow Man

It is decided, Silas will travel east, where he must defeat the Khans in a strawberry rhubarb pie eating competition.  I must say, most unconventional but I think with his berserker abilities Silas should be up to par.

Re: The Hollow Man

Alright I'm just about ready to start the next chapter, but I have again found another, 'fly in the lotion'.  I'm not sure if I want Chapter Three to be the meeting with a King, or about Silas and his mother.  Also if anyone has experience with Japanese feudalism, I'd love to have a chat.